15 ms·
Fairphone 3 Teardown
- mosselman 7y agoThis is great, especially since modern cell phones are not that revolutionary anymore and should be fairly static in terms of parts. In theory you should be able to upgrade your fairphone in a few years with new parts, like you can with a PC.
- OrangeMango 7y agoThis is the 3rd version; their website doesn't list the previous two. Are parts still available? Can you fit the guts of the 3rd version into the shell of the 2nd? I'm going to pay attention to this brand; it's very promising. But they still have a lot of work to do before its sustainable.
- mosselman 7y ago> This is the 3rd version; their website doesn't list the previous two. Are parts still available? Can you fit the guts of the 3rd version into the shell of the 2nd? I have no idea, I was just speculating that in theory it should be possible to create a base phone that can be upgraded continuously.
- OrangeMango 7y ago> it should be possible to create a base phone that can be upgraded continuously. Yes, that is exactly what we need to have happen.
- pvorb 7y agoA problem that often isn't considered is firmware/drivers. In the smartphone world you often can't simply install a driver for your new 5G module, for example. I haven't seen a solution for this, yet.
- RandomBacon 7y agoThe Librem 5 seems to potentially solve this. If it is an m.2 card and there are Linux drivers, then it can be upgraded.
- dublinben 7y agoThis is the goal of the EOMA68 project, but for laptops. https://www.crowdsupply.com/eoma68/micro-desktop https://www.crowdsupply.com/eoma68/micro-desktop
- iamatworknow 7y agoFrom the iFixit article: >If you hope to upgrade your Fairphone 2 with these modules, we have bad news. Modules and their inner parts are not compatible. But their housings are said to be produced from 50% recycled polycarbonate, so there's at least some reuse!
- Tepix 7y agoYes, parts are still available at https://shop.fairphone.com/en/spare-parts https://shop.fairphone.com/en/spare-parts
- pvorb 7y agoThe article mentions that tha parts of the Fairphone 2 are not compatible with this version, unfortunately. Maybe future versions will be compatible to the Fairphone 3, though.
- lnsru 7y agoIt’s a nice theory, but the real world has the problem of component obsolescence. Basically the company must start redesigning parts with new components for old product while developing a new product. It’s ok in industrial settings, but I doubt anybody will do this in consumer space. DDR2 memory is already gone. Plus cellphone market cycles are extremely short.
- zrm 7y agoThat's not really the problem. I can take the ATX case that I used for a DDR2 Core 2 Duo and put a DDR4 Ryzen in there. I can use the same PC screen for as long as I'm satisfied with it even if it lasts through four generations of CPU and memory technology. And because they're fungible, there are scads of parts available for the old hardware even if nobody really makes it anymore, because a stick of DDR2 from an old HP Athlon II works fine in an old Dell Core 2 Duo, much less between two models from the same OEM. So why not with phones too? All it would require is to standardize dimensions and power connectors for system boards etc. It doesn't even require absolute uniformity. You can have the equivalent of mATX, ATX, E-ATX, etc. for different size devices, as long as the board dimensions and connectors for a ~6" phone are the same as for another ~6" phone.
- lnsru 7y agoCellphone is extremely space constrained device, ATX main board case isn’t really valid argument. I build last computer very long time ago, but I think, that motherboard for Core 2 Duo also requires different power supply connector than Ryzen. Basically only the case and monitor are common components for both. I don’t think, major players want to standardize components. This might cost more and add limitations.
- zrm 7y agoIt has been ATX12V/EPS12V since around the Pentium 4, which itself only added more 12V rails to the original ATX connector to supply more power. Moreover, ATX and ATX12V power supplies have the same dimensions, use the same mounting, and the original 20-pin ATX connector is still the same. The newer power supplies can generally be used on older system boards going back to the mid 1990s and many of them separate the 24-pin connector into 20+4 for exactly that reason. It's not just the case and monitor. Drive bays have standard sizes and mounting (2.5", 3.5", 5.25"), the SATA connector has been the same since its introduction even though modern systems support higher speeds using it (and is also electrically compatible with the SAS connector and SAS HBAs typically support both), expansion cards have standard dimensions and use standard PCIe slots, etc. They'll make breaking changes from time to time (e.g. PATA to SATA, PCI to PCIe), but it's typically a decade or more between them and then many systems will support both for years after that. PCIe was introduced in 2003 but you can still find new systems with 32-bit PCI slots, and SATA to PATA adapters are available. If you want to you can build a PC with the latest CPU, install a SCSI HBA into it and connect that to a hard drive from the 1980s that will fit into the same drive bay as a modern 3.5" hard drive. Granted there are more space constraints in a phone, but that doesn't mean you can't do it at all. And an iMac or Mac Mini is not ATX. There is no law requiring every device to follow every part of the standard if it's necessary to satisfy some other constraint. But a G5 iMac is basically slag; the contemporaneous ATX PC has half a dozen components that could plausibly be reused in a modern PC.
- pjmlp 7y agoGiven the trend regarding consumer devices towards laptops and 2-1 devices and decreasing desktop sales, it is more like "you used to do with a PC".
- victorbojica 7y agoWhat would be the use cases for such a easy repairable phone? Compared to other phones not so easily repairable (i.e. 6/10).
- Tepix 7y agoLongevity. Use less resources by repairing.
- ErikHuisman 7y agoBut needs repairing more often due to no waterproving and a soft shell.
- zaroth 7y agoIt’s somewhat morose to consider that the resources expended to bring this device into the world likely far exceed the positive environmental impact of the relatively few number of repairs that users of this device will ultimately perform. That is to say, a mainstream phone’s production is so optimized and streamlined, that the weighted average environmental impact of making 10 more (e.g. iPhones) is significantly less than the weighted average environmental cost of making 1 Fairphone. Maybe if you factor in the value of performance art and political proselytizing then you can justify it!
- kasbah 7y agoAnd 80% of statistics are made up on the spot. (Would be interested in any links to studies or economic models in this area though.)
- vanderZwan 7y agoWell, there is obvious bias but Fairphone itself has lots of articles about their research into their environmental impact: https://support.fairphone.com/hc/en-us/articles/208539846 https://support.fairphone.com/hc/en-us/articles/208539846 https://www.fairphone.com/en/research-resources/ https://www.fairphone.com/en/research-resources/
- Tepix 7y agoCongratulations to the Fairphone team for achieving a 10/10 score!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 24gttghh 7y agohttps://www.ifixit.com/smartphone-repairability?sort=score https://www.ifixit.com/smartphone-repairability?sort=score There is only one other phone from the last five years (that isn't also a Fairphone) that has a score better than an 8/10 on ifixit's 'repairability score'. Well done!
- steeleduncan 7y agoDoes anyone know if the Fairphone 3 will support Android Pay? I've asked their support a few times now, but I've never gotten a clear answer.
- sbradford26 7y agoTheir website says it has NFC for card payments. So I would assume it would.
- mkettn 7y agoWhat about the software side? Fairphone 3 supports Android 9, Fairphone 2 supports Android 7. I see no use in a smartphone with replaceble hardware parts if I cannot install at least security patches for my phones OS on the long run.
- vanderZwan 7y agoFP2 still gets Android security patches - the main problem by now is that the drivers for the hardware are not properly updated to Android 7 (due to the manufacturer not providing any updates)
- jsingleton 7y agoAnd that's better than even Google's own devices. Old Nexus models don't get patches any more.
- sct202 7y agoIn one way, but the comparably aged Nexus 5X at least got updated to Android 8.1 while the Fairphone 2 is still on 7.1
- Fnoord 7y agoThe Fairphone 2 can run Android 9 via LineageOS. The official versions (the one with and the one without OpenGapps) still get security updates. Can you say the same about Nexus 5X with Android 8.1?
- joecool1029 7y agoThat Fairphone 2 fully supports Android 9 officially on LineageOS: https://download.lineageos.org/FP2 https://download.lineageos.org/FP2
- alerighi 7y agoSure, but we are not talking about custom ROMs, but rather official support from the manufacturer.
- Rotareti 7y agoI think the repairability of the Fairphone 3 is a huge step forward, but in the long run I want a phone that allows me to run an up-to-date OS for as long as I want. The Fairphone 3 will get updates for 5 years, that's not enough if you ask me.
- ShteiLoups 7y agoSo you want indefinite software support? Technically achievable with open source, but even OSS projects come to an end.
- pessimizer 7y ago> OSS projects come to an end. Depends on the project. With necessary projects to operate still-used technology, I don't know that OSS projects actually end (without drop-in replacements) very often.
- ShteiLoups 7y agoI come across tools, frameworks, plugins, etc. all the time that are no longer being supported by their devs
- organsnyder 7y agoFive years seems reasonable to me. The further out they get, the harder it gets for them to provide support—they're dependent on chipset vendors for up-to-date drivers. I'll be interested to see what options there will be at the five-year mark: I'd guess that there would be options for non-official firmware.
- rootusrootus 7y agoIf all I want from the phone is five years, any of the flagship phones will do fine. Certainly I know several people still rocking iPhone 6's from 2014. Still running the latest OS (though that stops this year with iOS 13).
- 7y ago
- tarkin2 7y agoI had a fairphone about three years ago (I'm guessing fairphone 2). The software was for a very old version of Android and the update was very slow coming. I tried to update but had huge problems. There were no custom ROMs for it either - hopefully there are now. I never got to the point where I replaced a hardware component because the software problems, especially software update problems, and perhaps some mild hardware problems, meant I eventually gave up and used another phone. I hope FF3 is a vast improvement. Edit: I see lineage has a ROM for FF2 giving it Android 8.1. That wasn't there when I used my FF. It may have given me a good experience.
- Fnoord 7y ago> Edit: I see lineage has a ROM for FF2 giving it Android 8.1. That wasn't there when I used my FF. It may have given me a good experience. The LineageOS 16 OS is based on AOSP / Android 9.x Pi; not 8.x Oreo. That was LineageOS 15. (We also don't use the acronym "FF"; we use the acronym "FP".) > I had a fairphone about three years ago (I'm guessing fairphone 2). [...] There were no custom ROMs for it either - hopefully there are now. I have a Fairphone 2 (FP2) for 4 years, and what you say is untrue. There have been alternative OSes for Fairphone for ages. Fairphone delivered a version of FPOS called Fairphone Open. It is Android without OpenGapps. The OSes which have been around the past 4 years on FP2: * SailfishOS (community edition) * FirefoxOS [now defunct] * Ubuntu Touch * LineageOS (for approx 2-3 years?) * /e/ (more recent, but also a newcomer) * PostmarketOS (more recent) Source: [1] Especially the SailfishOS port has been around for ages, by community member mal (who now works for Jolla). Ubuntu Touch I'm not sure about when that was released, but it was the main development device for UT. Assuming good faith on your behalf, are you sure this was 3 years ago? From the information you post, it was likely 5 years ago or so, and a Fairphone 1. [1] https://forum.fairphone.com/t/operating-systems-for-fairphones/11425 https://forum.fairphone.com/t/operating-systems-for-fairphon...
- tarkin2 7y agoIt was 2016. A FP2? There were definitely other OSes available but I wanted an uptodate Android phone. If FP could supply an uptodate stock Android version with painless update procedure I'd be happy to try again. This looks like Android 8? https://lineageosroms.com/fp2/ https://lineageosroms.com/fp2/
- ProZsolt 7y agoIt doesn't support USB-PD only QC3.0 [1]. I won't buy anything that uses a proprietary charging. [1]https://shop.fairphone.com/en/accessories/usb-charger-eu https://shop.fairphone.com/en/accessories/usb-charger-eu
- milankragujevic 7y agoThe SoC, baseband, WiFi, etc. chips are okay, but the charging isn't?
- bri3d 7y agoWhat's unreasonable about that? The charging standard is a lot more likely to affect day to day use. Being unable to charge quickly using a standard USB-C PD charger is much likely to affect me than some ethical argument about the proprietary baseband and SoC, especially when there are literally no alternatives to proprietary basebands.
- dbrgn 7y agoIf this is about practical use instead of ethical arguments: I think QC chargers are more widely available right now than USB PD chargers. Basically every Chinese charger or powerbank nowadays does QC. I've rarely seen one with USB PD.
- ProZsolt 7y agoYou are right if we only looking at the phone chargers. Actually that's my problem. I don't want to QC be the de facto standard for phone charging. First, with USB PD we have the opportunity to use the same charger for every device we carry with us (Phone, Laptop, Camera, etc.). If my phone doesn't support it then I still have to carry another just for my phone. Second, the USB-C standard prohibits any charging solution other than USB PD. Any proprietary adds another level of confusion using USB-C. Is it supports USB PD, Qualcomm Quick Charge, OnePlus Dash Charge, Oppo Super Vooc, Huawei SuperCharge, Motorola TurboPower or MediaTek Pump Express? In the end, something will fry my laptop if I just plug in a random charger and I will be angry. That's why I hate proprietary charging solutions.
- ansible 7y agoWow, that's neat. This might just be my next phone. It's a little more expensive than I'd like, but not bad, really.
- ineedasername 7y agoOn specs this seems to be a mid-low level phone. I'm not sure I see the point of having a phone built to be repairable and last for the long haul if it's not got the specs to see that lifetime through, and as others have noted the lack up updates in prior iterations is troubling. I also wonder if the repairability will really impact repair costs. Swapping a battery is one thing, but if the phone isn't mass produced in sufficient qualities then getting replacement screens might not be much cheaper. Other repairs seem much less likely to be needed-- battery and screen probably account for a huge majority of repair issues.
- nickserv 7y agoI've replaced my last 4 phones not because I wanted something faster or thinner or any hardware improvements at all in fact. Just that something broke and fixing it was almost as much as getting a new one. Or the software was full of security holes or incompatibilities, and no way of upgrading. Honestly phones are pretty much where PCs are now, upgrading every year is pointless except for certain specific use cases, and something that can last 4-5 years with minor repairs and regular software updates is enough for the vast majority of users. My only concern with the Fairphone is the high initial price.
- ineedasername 7y agoOn security holes, that's exactly my point when I mentioned updates. It seems from other comments that fairphone was very lax on that front. As for repairs, which ones were almost as much as a new phone? New flagships run $1000. Battery or screen replacement are $200-300. How much will a new fairphone screen cost? Even at half that, it doesn't seem worth a low spec phone when I can get a much higher spec phone at roughly half the $500 fairphone price. (A pixel 2xl costs about $250 with a bit of smart shopping) I just don't see the savings here or the reason to sacrifice performance and software updates.
- nickserv 7y agoI keep to sub 300€ or even sub 200€ since I don't game and prefer my DSLR for photography. So a screen replacement on a phone that's not getting software updates is not really interesting to me.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y agoThe more I look at this sort of project, the more I wonder if the "hyper-repairable" approach is worth it. How many of those phones will need repairs? How much more resources have to be spent, and what other trade-offs have to be made, to enable that repairability? (One of the trade-offs being less economy-of-scale because not as many people are willing to buy a bulky yet expensive phone.) At which point is it better to just build 12 non-repairable phones instead of 10 repairable ones + some spare parts? Take, for example, the user-serviceable battery with its thick casing. Given that you'd expect to swap it 1-2 times during the useful lifetime of a phone platform, does it need to be that easy to swap, or would it be OK to require some level of disassembly? Not "melt the glue, pull with suction cup, pry open, disconnect 15 connectors, loosen two sets of 8 screws (all different), remove all innards, replace some single-use parts" level of disassembly, something like "losen two screws, pry off the back, loosen two more screws, swap battery" like with the Nexus 4: https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Nexus+4+Battery+Replacement/13039 https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Nexus+4+Battery+Replacement/130... We don't complain when we take a wristwatch to a watch shop at the corner to swap the battery every few years, waiting a few minutes and paying $5-10 for the service and another $5 for the battery. I would be perfectly OK with a phone that works like that: Repairable (especially commonly swapped parts), but not average-user-servicable. Edit: Looking at the Fairphone 3, it doesn't look as bad. I remember looking at the Fairphone 2, which looked like a brick made of cheap plastic all around.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoThe more I read comments like this, the more I question the real possibility of shilling here. Yes repairability is important, but only if the likelihood of needing repair is not increased. Remember FORD? Easy to repair, but you might have to Fix Or Repair Daily. Don't be that company.
- disjhshava 7y agoAs a user of a phone with a swappable battery, I keep an extra battery in my bag and swap whenever the battery gets low. The dead battery goes in a charger when I'm home. The swapping functionally is getting used frequently. Also, as a user of a more recent phone with good battery life and wireless charging, the battery never dies so I've never felt the need to swap it. On a side note, I feel that the rampant accusations of shilling lower the quality of discourse here and are indicative of a failure of empathy or theory of mind.