10 ms·
> It effectively establishes a billion dollar bounty for any party who can rewrite enough blocks to erase it. I don't really agree with that statement. Yes, so
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
> It effectively establishes a billion dollar bounty for any party who can rewrite enough blocks to erase it.
I don't really agree with that statement. Yes, someone could mount a 51% attack to rewrite that block. However, it would be pretty straightforward to see what was happening (and which nodes were the malicious actors). If that did happen, the possible outcomes would be:
1. The value of bitcoin would fall to basically 0. The reason bitcoin has any value at all really has to do with trust - belief that the protocol is secure and can't be broken. In this case, an easily detectable spending "override" would cause faith in the protocol to evaporate.
2. Note I don't believe #1 would happen. The response would be all the other miners who do have a vested interest in bitcoins success would put all their resources in ensuring the original block was maintained.
I.e. the options aren't between one address getting the billion+ dollars or another address getting a billion+ dollars. The options are one address getting a billion+ dollars or everyone's bitcoin going to 0.
Edit: Another likely possible outcome is you could get what happened to Ethereum when the DAO was hacked: a fork to Ethereum vs. Ethereum Classic. But it's still important to note Ethereum Classic is worth a teeny fraction of what Ethereum is.
- ur-whale 7y ago>The value of bitcoin would fall to basically 0 Yes indeed. There are a number of very interesting game-theoretic feedback loops built into bitcoin that enhance security. This is one of them.
- mochris 7y agoI disagree, because historically major cryptos have allowed known attacks to succeed if they targeted a member of the public at large, and have defended only if they targeted named insiders. The expectation, at this point, is that defense will only occur if you are an elite insider. An unknown user may or may not be such an elite, and thus may or may not get defense.
- scottlocklin 7y ago> I disagree, because historically major cryptos have allowed known attacks to succeed if they targeted a member of the public at large, and have defended only if they targeted named insiders. Surely you aren't going to make such a statement without examples! I can think of examples where things were attacked, including some of the largest value destructions, and insider status didn't help. For example, the multisig thing that happened to Gav Wood (the second time). If your lone example is the Dao attack, that looked like successful governance to me.
- jefftk 7y ago> the multisig thing that happened to Gav Wood I wasn't sure what you were referring to, but it looks like maybe https://cointelegraph.com/news/parity-multisig-wallet-hacked-or-how-come https://cointelegraph.com/news/parity-multisig-wallet-hacked...
- scottlocklin 7y agoYep, that's the one. The astounding, insane decision to use "libraries" aka delegate call in any immutable smart contract always boggled my mind. The amount of space saved is so ludicrously small as to beggar belief. Hope the 10k or whatever worth of space savings (about 20 transactions worth) was worth it. Anyway, he didn't get a roll back, and the $200m in value that disappeared didn't either.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tossAfterUsing 7y agowonder if he got to claim that as a loss on a tax form somewhere... hmmm.
- scottlocklin 7y agoWell he's not a US citizen and unless he's insane, his corporations are offshored in a 0% domocile. It's really only a problem for Americans; everyone else who has their shit together can stick their corporate shell on Cayman or whatever.
- Stevvo 7y agoYou assume the value of bitcoin is somewhat logical, the Etc 51% attack proves otherwise; in the short term holders would rather sustain the delusion.
- fucking_tragedy 7y agoThis is an important perspective. Many BTC investors are unsophisticated retail investors, and are often "true believer" and magical thinking types. They're this decade's version of gold bugs.
- jkhdigital 7y agoTo borrow a phrase from Walter Sobchak-- 2500 years of beautiful tradition from the Lydian Stater to the American Gold Eagle, you're goddamn right I'm a f*ing gold bug!
- firethief 7y agoThe Mayan civilization lasted 3000 years
- knocte 7y agoLooking retarded doesn't make them wrong.
- perl4ever 7y agoI think gold bugs are this decade's version of gold bugs, and heavily overlap with "unsophisticated retail investors" but not necessarily bitcoin enthusiasts. I note that my emails from seekingalpha recently have ads saying "Vote <you-know-who> in 2020! Free Gold Victory Coin For Supporters - Claim Yours Now".
- esotericn 7y agoWell, it doesn't _prove_ it; it's just a data point. The Bitcoin and Ethereum ecosystems are rather different.
- keymone 7y agothe amount of trivialization and conflation irks me 1. "51% attack" is not a thing as in "one has to have 51% of hashpower to perform it". it's just that with 51% of hashpower it becomes relatively cheap to perform such attack. one can throw enough money at the problem and get lucky to perform large reorg with just 10% of hashpower. the lower the number - the more lucky attacker has to get. 2. "rewriting a block" or "billion dollar bounty" as the GP put it are just conveying wrong ideas. there is zero chance for that $1B to get stolen even if attacker gets 100% of hashrate. all they can do is revert the transaction so that money goes back to original owners by generating a fork in the chain that doesn't include said transaction. even that is not enough because competing miners (assuming attacker doesn't really have all 100% of hashpower) will still eventually include the transaction because it pays lucrative fees. the trick here is that in Bitcoin parties agree to finalize the deal only after certain number of confirmations (blocks created after the one that includes the transaction). general rule is to wait for 6 confirmations. if there indeed was some $1B deal where 94k BTC changed hands i wouldn't be surprised if their agreed upon number of confirmations was ~500 blocks (half the value of transaction in question in miner rewards), which is roughly 3 days wait. ultimately though i'm pretty sure this was some kind of cold-storage consolidation so no BTC actually changed hands.
- nybble41 7y ago> it's just that with 51% of hashpower it becomes relatively cheap to perform such attack The qualitative difference is that with 51% of hashpower you can sustain the attack indefinitely. Other miners might get the occasional block and temporarily take the lead but in the long run you'll always have the longest chain using only blocks you've mined yourself. With less than 50% there's a chance that you can revert a transaction temporarily by mining two consecutive blocks (one to omit the transaction and another to make your chain longer than the original) in less time than it takes the main network to reach the same block height, but the odds of maintaining the attack drop by at least half with each additional block. The main network will always win eventually. In any case no one controls anywhere close to 51% of the hashpower right now. There are pools which approach that size but they aren't monolithic entities; if the pool operators attempted to leverage their position as coordinators to carry out a sustained attack then miners would leave the pool.
- qroshan 7y agoSo, if I were a hedge fund, I can effectively short Bitcoins and spend a piddly amount to build a datacenter to carry a 51% attack. If the attack fails, I can re-purpose my datacenter
- servercobra 7y agoRepurpose it how? You'd need ASICs to mount a 51% attack. Using a few quickly googled numbers, you'd need ~56EH/s to double the network and mount a 51% attack. An S9 does 14TH/s, so you'd need ~4 million, at $3k each. So around $12 billion (plus the datacenter, operations, etc). You'd pretty much send BTC to being worth $0...and then you're stuck with $12 billion in useless hardware.
- lmpostor 7y ago94EH and close to 50TH for top of the line equipment. Even if we were extremely generous would be a billion in hardware at the very least (I am assuming $500 manufacturing cost)
- qroshan 7y agoThe Market Cap of Bitcoin is $184,000,000,000 Theoretically, I can spend that much to make it's value go to $0. (yes, there are liquidity and other concerns, but you get the point)
- arthurcolle 7y agoNo, you couldn't because you'd need to borrow the entire float, which is impossible, practically and theoretically.
- qroshan 7y agoIf my goal is to re-purpose, I would use a General Purpose Computer The Market Cap of Bitcoin is $184,000,000,000 I have plenty of money to play with.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- WMCRUN 7y agoDoes the time it would take to spin up enough compute to carry out a 51% attack decrease its likelihood? I.e more blocks are being written every day, so you need to do additional work to create the alternate chain?
- askmike 7y agoYep, but the timer potentially resets every time this money is moved.
- roenxi 7y ago> 1. The value of bitcoin would fall to basically 0. The reason bitcoin has any value at all really has to do with trust - belief that the protocol is secure and can't be broken. In this case, an easily detectable spending "override" would cause faith in the protocol to evaporate. That seems a little out there. (1) There is something like 1 person who uses bitcoin to move billions of dollars around. The small-time users (<$1,000,000 per transaction) wouldn't have any reason to lose trust in the system. If some company loses $1 bil in dollars, I really don't care; I don't live in a world where it affects me personally. Nobody is ever going to put serious resources into stealing from me because I'm just not that important. (2) If they re-write the block, that doesn't mean that they've gotten away with it. Most countries have a legal system that would sit up and take notice if someone signs up for a billion dollar transaction, takes the goods and welches on paying.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sprafa 7y agoYou’re not living in the real world, but whatever.
- Drdrdrq 7y agoFirst they came after those with 1b$, but I didn't stand up for them... :D
- perl4ever 7y ago"Most countries have a legal system that would sit up and take notice if someone signs up for a billion dollar transaction, takes the goods and welches on paying" Yes, but why bitcoin then?