4 ms·
Politics is all about hitting the right shade of gray; however if we follow the logic there all the way through we'd tax negative externalities and subsidise po
by roenxi 7y ago
Politics is all about hitting the right shade of gray; however if we follow the logic there all the way through we'd tax negative externalities and subsidise positive externalities; likely leading to a massive subsidy for fossil fuels. I know 'tax them!' is probably something of the realistic compromise solution but that justification has more holes than Swiss cheese.
Taxing the externalities also suggests we know how to measure how bad they are in some quantitative way and it is commonly accepted knowledge that the political process can implement in a law. Both of those assumptions are incorrect.
I'm basically arguing for 'tax them because we don't like this specific type of pollution' rather than trying to generalise into vague language. The generalisation doesn't hold.
- gshdg 7y agoHow on earth would that result in subsidy for fossil fuels? What positive externalities do they produce?
- roenxi 7y agoOn net; most of modern civilisation. China didn't have a hope of bootstrapping themselves using wind power. The energy harvested by mining and burning fossil fuels enables outrageous amounts of good. Nobody talks about it because it is too pervasive. If we blanket banned fossil fuels tomorrow; there would be a few billion dollars in losses to the producers. That would be the ... I don't recall what the opposite of an externality is. Internality, say. The extrenalities would be the collapse of a bunch of things that depend on fossil fuels, like cheap transport.
- srl 7y agoI think the broad point is correct (fossil fuels are a net positive, compared to the gruesome alternative), but I wouldn't say they have net positive externalities. This is a critical distinction. The positive effects of fossil fuels are mostly paid for; some important negative effects are not. As a result, fossil fuels are used more than they should be. Slightly pithier: fossil fuels currently have massive subsidies --- from all the people who pay for them! It's just that that isn't what `subsidy' is usually taken to mean.
- roenxi 7y agoI'm pretty confident on the point here. For a specific example, the Haber process [0] consumes quite a significant amount of natural gas. That and the logistics network of moving the food around is all fossil fuels. If we cut fossil fuels out, and food prices rise the damage goes a bit beyond the measurable short-term economic impact. If the cost of a sea level rise destroying a small island nation is a negative externality, then enabling population growth in a large city (without food riots) is a positive externality. An extrenality is just an impact that goes beyond the immediate buyer and seller; most of the value chain is an externality to a fossil fuel provider who was to be targeted by this hypothetical tax. The argument in essence is that cheap abundant energy always has a bigger positive impact than a first order approximation would suggest. Pretty much the entire industrial revolution was a long chain of "wow, coal is enabling stuff we never imagined" that was certainly not value being directly captured in the buying and selling the miners were doing. The oil & coal companies aren't capturing very much of the value vs what is created. I mean, seriously, nobody can argue that fossil fuels haven't enabled civilisation to move from the 1800s to 2019. In a very practical sense they are the enabler of everything we have; there wouldn't be any positive externalities without them. Fossil fuels, crops, wood, iron & a few other metals are the setup materials for all of it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haber_process#Economic_and_environmental_aspects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haber_process#Economic_and_env...
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 7y agoSo, your argument then is that if we ignore all but the least significant negative externalities of fossil fuels, then fossil fuels have mostly positive externalities? Is that a fair summary?
- roenxi 7y agoThe argument is that "we should tax externalities" is an intellectually lazy justification because it includes costs but not benefits. People should find a better one. We've never used fossil fuels because people have a political love of fossil fuels; we use them because they enable great works. My line is that we should either use the cheapest energy (before any government efforts to pick a winner) or nuclear as the most technically excellent energy source.
- Fricken 7y agoAt the 4 degrees and beyond conference in 2009 they estimated that at 4 degrees of warming earth would be able to sustain about a billion people. We're on track for 4-6 degrees of warming over the next century, and nothing says it will stop there. Fossil fuel based civilization is all for naught. There is no "outrageous amount of good", quite the opposite. Every benefit is trivial when held up against the disaster we are creating. Before fossil fuels we were able to go hundreds of thousands of years without crashing the earth's life support systems. Notions of good and evil change dramatically when you internalize the full scope of the climate emergency.
- macspoofing 7y agoHeat. Electricity. You know, all those modern comforts that the developed world is getting by building coals plants, that they didn't have and CAN'T GET with solar panels and wind farms.
- acdha 7y agoFor a complaint about generalization, I was hoping for more details — for example, how you arrived at the claim that a fossil fuel subsidy is a likely outcome or that we don’t know how to measure pollution after the better part of a century of doing so.
- mikeash 7y agoFossil fuels don’t have positive externalities. They have benefits, which are entirely captured by the user. You don’t need (or want) to subsidize those, because they’re already being paid for.
- roenxi 7y agoFossil fuels obviously have huge benefits that are not captured by the user. If everyone around me were banned from using fossil fuels but I was not, my lifestyle would crater. Even if all the people supplying me with stuff were allowed to use fossil fuels, my lifestyle would still crater. I benefit hugely from being in a world where everyone around me has cheap access to energy. My purchasing decisions are not responsible for the advanced and comfortable world I live in - which happens to be built on coal, oil and gas. I must be benefiting from externalities from fossil fuels.
- imtringued 7y agoThe "stuff" people would supply you with would be a dictatorship.
- mikeash 7y agoYou pay for those benefits. Those payments go to the people using fossil fuels. It's not an externality. Your thought experiment about banning fossil fuels doesn't tell us anything about externalities. An externality is when part of the cost or benefit of a thing is borne by someone with no control over it. This is bad because it means that the market will produce an amount of usage that isn't optimal. If the net externalities are negative, the market will use too much. If they're positive, the market will not use enough. The fact that a blanket ban would leave you worse off only tells us that the optimal amount of fossil fuel usage isn't zero and that the current amount of usage is better. It doesn't tell us whether current usage is optimal or, if non-optimal, whether it's too high or too low. For an example of something with positive externalities, consider public roads. Consider the road between me and the local grocery store. This road benefits me and the store. If I were responsible for building and maintaining it, I'd probably make it a minimal one-lane dirt track, because that would suffice for me, and the added expense of more lanes and more durable surface wouldn't pay off for me. But thousands of other people benefit from this road as well, and the total benefit to everyone makes it well worth building a wider, paved road. Left purely to the market, that road would be a narrow dirt track. Thankfully, the government steps in and builds a proper road, then captures the positive externality through taxes. Another way to handle it would be to make it a private road and charge everyone for access. Transaction costs make this impractical, but if we could handwave those away and have efficient micro-transactions for road usage, that would get rid of the positive externality and give us efficient road use and construction without government intervention. There's nothing like this for fossil fuels. People pay for the stuff based on how much they use. Other people pay those people based on the benefit they bring. The benefits are already captured. Subsidizing fossil fuels would increase the amount that gets used, which would be farther from the optimal usage than where we are currently. We currently use fossil fuels at a level above the optimal, because individuals deciding how much fuel to use aren't bearing the full costs of using it. There's no indication that anything like that is at play with fossil fuels.