5 ms·
DNA from cigarette leads to Dakota Access arrest warrant 3 years later
- draw_down 7y agoI’m sure our intrepid freedom of speech crusaders will be along to decry this any moment now!
- deogeo 7y agoI'll decry it - for the growing surveillance state that shows how difficult it's getting to anonymously protest, for the corporate-skewed use of police resources (I'm sure more serious crimes went under-investigated while they were busy doing DNA analysis on every piece of trash from the protest), and for the chilling effect of prosecuting on the mere basis of presence at a protest. There's always a chance protests will get out of hand, and few people would attend if merely being there resulted in being prosecuted for everything the protest as a whole did wrong. I also cried "censorship!" when 8chan got kicked off Cloudflare, when Facebook banned white nationalism, and when a cartoonist was fired from a rural newspaper after criticizing agribusiness. I hope this helps you to a less strawman-like view of free-speech crusaders.
- fzeroracer 7y agoThe problem is that what garners the attention of said free-speech crusaders tends to be wildly unbalanced. The issues of FB banning white nationalism and 8chan being kicked off of cloudflare incited a massive thread and attention here on HN. Then you have stories like this one with the government itself engaging in very selective measures in attempt to censure people and it doesn't gain nearly the same amount of attention as it should. I've posted various similar stories here on HN and there is a very obvious slant towards what 'violations' of freedom of speech invoke a larger response here on HN or across the various tech communities.
- deogeo 7y agoAre you sure they didn't get more attention from free-speech crusaders simply because they got more coverage in the media? Speaking for myself, I see stories of government prosecution used to stifle speech extremely rarely (unless we count every instance of the cops getting too rough with protestors). Which is not to say it happens rarely, it's just not reported on much. There's another aspect to this, I think. Cops have been arresting protesters for centuries - we've reached equilibrium there. But censorship by globe-spanning private companies is new, as is the growing share of communication controlled by them. Which makes it scarier, and harder to predict if it'll get much worse in the coming decades.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post ideological flamebait to HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- LMYahooTFY 7y agoThis response seems ridiculously low effort, and doesn't even try to conform to HN guidelines. Can you elaborate any more on "free speech crusaders" and why whoever you think they are deserve only your disdain and dismissal? I'm actually not clear on why it's relevant.
- acollins1331 7y agoI wonder if there will ever be enough of a political pushback on this stuff to change anything? I feel like people that care about privacy and not having a dystopian government are always going to be the minority. What needs to happen for normal people to start to care?
- robotron 7y agoIt will have to occur to someone they care about or themselves. By then it will be too late.
- kgwxd 7y agoBut that will only change the mindset of the person it directly affects, and only maybe. Somehow, it needs to become part of the system, by default, whether most people care about it or not. Once it's in place, any stray from that default needs to be met with instant backlash from within the system itself to keep it in position. It's a never ending fight.
- anigbrowl 7y agoYou could argue that the 'Green New Deal' touted by left-leaning members of Congress and some Presidential candidates is an (indirect) policy response vs the right's preferred approach of building more fossil fuel infrastructure.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y agoA crime was committed , and DNA evidence is being used to solve the crime. How is this any different than using DNA evidence to solve other crimes? Also, I find it interesting that a person who was there presumably out of respect for the environment, is polluting the environment by his smoking and littering.
- kennywinker 7y agoI have three replies: 1. is civil disobedience a crime, or the duty of all engaged citizens? 2. dna proves he was present AT SOME POINT, at that location, but not that he did anything illegal. I suspect they don't actually need to win the case, they just want to chase this guy down to chill further protests. 3. while I don't like cigarette butts littered around either, the environmental impact of a cigarette and its filter is so far outweighed by the impact of the pipeline in question. To compare the two is ridiculous.
- cjensen 7y agoThe whole point of civil disobedience is to intentionally commit a non-violent and non-destructive crime. If there is no crime, in the US it's just a lawful protest as permitted by the First Amendment.
- kennywinker 7y agoPardon, you are right. I'm actually not trying to say that the action itself is not illegal, just that I believe the RIGHT thing to do is consider political actions differently from un-politically motivated actions. To potentially punish or pursue them less (protest, civil disobedience) or more (hate crimes, corruption, terrorism).
- droithomme 7y agoThe protest was not illegal. Stop saying it was.
- capableweb 7y agoSeems to be missing an explanation on how they managed to figure out whoever smoked that cigarette was involved in the riot. Is there videos of that specific cigarette being thrown on the ground or something like that?
- whoisjuan 7y agoReaching that conclusion is pretty simple. At least simple and straight forward enough to charge someone. Probably not as simple to get an actual conviction. I think this is what happened. They probably found several cigarette butts inside the perimeter of the vandalized private property, they ran DNA tests for all of them and one matched this guy's DNA. There are only a few possible reasons for his DNA to be inside that perimeter: 1) He was a contractor doing work for the Dakota Access Pipeline operator (probably already ruled out, otherwise he wouldn't have been charged). 2) Somebody took his butt from outside and put it inside the perimeter (very unlikely). 3) He actually smoked that cigarette and dropped the butt in that location while he was vandalizing it (most likely scenario from the prosecution point of view). 4) He trespassed the property at a different time and smoked and dropped the cigarette butt at that time. This is still an unlawful behavior but is probably better than all the other charges. (This is a possible scenario but it would be pretty hard for his defense to demonstrate this is what actually happened). Again. This is enough for prosecutors to charge this guy but it doesn't mean at all that this is good evidence to get a conviction. In my humble opinion, a cigarette butt with your DNA is pretty weak evidence in this particular case.
- paulsutter 7y agoSo you’re saying, no problem, all he needs to do is prove his innocence?
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIf he had an alibi for (3), then (4) would be plausible to show.
- whoisjuan 7y ago
- blt 7y agoDaily reminder that police exist to protect the "property" of the ruling class.
- googlesux 7y agoTop rated comment from the commie
- m-p-3 7y agoThe police is there to protect the law and order, and the ruling class don't want the current order (them on top) to change.
- 19ylram49 7y agoPrecisely!
- Bostonian 7y agoMarxism has always failed but Marxist rhetoric remains popular. In a market economy companies make money by producing what people want, and we all depend on energy from fossil fuel.
- ajross 7y agoThat's because "Marxist rhetoric" expresses a legitimate grievance, though. Your argument is a conflation fallacy. It can be simultaneously true that: 1. Law enforcement disproportionately and unfairly serves the interests of the powerful above the reasonable interests of justice. 2. Proletarian seizure of the means of production is terrible economic policy. I mean, come on. They did three years of investigation and lab work to chase one guy down on a disorderly conduct[1] charge. That's just absurd. How many open case rape kits in Bismark ND went untested since 2016? If the number is more than one, I think even the most Blue Lives Matterest among us would agree that this was a miscarriage of justice. [1] Edit: it's even dumber: "conspiracy to commit criminal mischief". Three years, folks. They worked that case for three years.
- jeanperrot 7y agoIn order to function well, markets have to be correctly regulated. In particular, externalities must be accounted for. Energy markets fail to do that (CO2 emissions is a large externality) and are broken - I wager we wouldn't depend on fossil fuels for much longer if it weren't the case.
- nimbius 7y agoThis whole protest always seemed pretty dystopian to me. The fact that the government of North Dakota is still combing the scene for DNA leads to prosecute additional protestors 3 years later after having acquitted or probated nearly 400 of them seems to imply this is quite a witch hunt. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dakota_Access_Pipeline_protests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dakota_Access_Pipeline_protest... > In September 2016, construction workers bulldozed a section of land the tribe had identified as sacred ground and when protesters entered the area security workers used attack dogs which bit at least six of the protesters and one horse. >At least six protesters were treated for dog bites, and an estimated 30 were pepper-sprayed before the guards and their dogs left the scene in trucks. >In May 2017, internal TigerSwan documents leaked to The Intercept and other documents obtained through public records requests revealed a close collaboration between the pipeline company and local, state, and federal law enforcement as they carried out "military-style counterterrorism measures" to suppress the protesters.
- jessehorne 7y agohttps://theintercept.com/2018/12/30/tigerswan-infiltrator-dakota-access-pipeline-standing-rock/ https://theintercept.com/2018/12/30/tigerswan-infiltrator-da...
- m0dest 7y agolike something straight out of The East https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1869716/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1869716/
- jessehorne 7y agoOh man. It WAS wild.
- jessehorne 7y agoI was in Joels hotel room the night Trump got elected. I guess I was just an easy target. I was loud mouthed and easily singled out. All I can remember was being a little tipsy and ranting about how I hated the news, the presidents, etc...Months later I find out he was an infiltrator. All I could think was "oh crap I hope I didn't threaten the president or anything under the influence". I thought it was hilarious actually because Joel couldn't ever get any good information from anybody. We all knew the drill. What was our secret? To keep no secrets. Everything was planned out in the open and everyone involved in anything knew they would be going to jail.
- jessehorne 7y agoI went to North Dakota when the camp was at its height. It was incredibly beautiful and inspiring.
- droithomme 7y agoBrother, I was there with you as well. I saw no criminal activity by protestors (protectors). Everything was legal. No doubt there were some crimes here and there but certainly not rioting, terrorism, etc. Those claiming now that everyone there committed federal crimes, I am here. Come arrest me. File your charges. I will ensure you are countersued for libel and false arrest. I will take you all down and as a lifelong successful engineer and entrepreneur I have the financial resources and legal advisors to ensure my rights. I committed no crime whatsoever. Bring it on, everyone making these claims. Bring it. I am here, waiting for all the internet basement accusers to make this real. Come now, let us grapple and let the courts determine the truth.
- jessehorne 7y agoI think I had a cigarette butt or two in North Dakota at the time, too. Looks like they need to come get me as well. I'm still in good ole Des Moines, Iowa. :) There was no illegal activity going on. Everyone told everyone else how sensitive things were. We were all on our toes. The true crimes were committed by the paid oil protectors, the cops, the companies making this project happen and the government. They took a LOT of land from a lot of people, simply trying to get by. Even if you opposed it and refused any sort of financial compensation (which in fact several people tried to do) then the land was taken anyways.
- aaronax 7y agoI lived in North Dakota during it's height and 30 years prior. It was a ridiculous protest driven by emotional overreaction to a normal construction proceeding (the Missouri had already been crossed near Williston by the same pipeline). It had a disruptive negative impact on many of the surrounding communities. And the state was left with a huge mess to clean up after all the protestors left.
- segmondy 7y ago"we only collect DNA for violent crimes" right! we need to remember this as they push for facial recognition, gait recognition, voice recognition, etc.
- sieabahlpark 7y agoThey left quite a trash pile when they left at the expense of to the Dakota taxpayers
- mattnewton 7y agoIt was mentioned elsewhere, but it is hard to pack up when you are fleeing attack dogs, carried off in cuffs, or being pepper sprayed. Besides the fact that that isn’t one of the charges filed here, and the cost of cleaning up litter can’t possible compare to the amount of police work spent to hunt down this person.
- zonidjan 7y agoDo you really believe that any police officer anywhere in the US actually cares enough about littering to do a full-on forensic investigation?
- zonidjan 7y agoWe don't live in a surveillance state! We have all these rights and everything to prove it!
- aussieguy1234 7y agoFirst it's these protesters in the US, next this will be used against Hong Kong protestors
- sys_64738 7y agoHow do you prove the evidence wasn’t tampered with in the intervening years? Are we to trust the police evidence gathering and storage techniques for that long?