4 ms·
i said right at the beginning when people were starting to recommend e-cigarettes as a replacement for cigarettes that they should keep the good old 'unknown un
by Barrin92 7y ago
i said right at the beginning when people were starting to recommend e-cigarettes as a replacement for cigarettes that they should keep the good old 'unknown unknowns' in mind and that a recommendation without knowledge of long term risk is dangerous.
This should maybe be a general lesson when people advocate unproven replacements for unhealthy habits.
- devoply 7y agoat the same time it's entirely possible if not likely the issue is with some additive which needs to be banned and all other additives highly regulated and logged so these sorts of issues can properly be attributed to those problematic additives.
- EpicEng 7y agoYet all we know is that these people vape and many of them were vaping black market THC oil with high levels of vitamin E. An estimated 10M people vape in the US and here we have an acute health issue with a few hundred people. https://www.nbcnews.com/health/vaping/vitamin-e-now-focus-investigation-some-vaping-illnesses-n1050361 https://www.nbcnews.com/health/vaping/vitamin-e-now-focus-in...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mattmanser 7y agoRight now there are literally 100s of millions of people vaping. A small percentage of Americans, who mainly smoke THC, are suffering. Sounds like someone in America is doing something dodgy.
- joezydeco 7y agoTo be clear, only a small percentage are showing critical damage (breathing trouble, death). What percentage is not showing life-threatening issues yet, but are slowly building up accumulated damage?
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoBear in mind their invention was, I believe, a positive. That by adjusting the nicotine in the vape you could ease off smoking. The goal was not for vaping to become a cool thing to do. (Although I'm certain once e-cig companies realized the market they were encroaching on, they capitalized as capitalists do.)
- inimino 7y agoSame. Call me in 50 years when they've had as long to examine the effects of vaping as we needed to definitively establish the lung cancer link to smoking. It amazes me that people hear "no known, proven side effects" with a technology that never existed before and read that as "safe".
- EpicEng 7y agoThe alternative for most is cigarettes. Do you really believe that vaping is worse than that? Are you going to wait another 30 years before picking up a cell phone? What about GMO's? New medicines? Waiting to prove a negative is a silly stance when you know the alternative will kill you and severely lower your quality of life until that day comes.
- inimino 7y agoThe alternative is quitting. Only a lack of willpower and predatory marketing lets anyone fool themselves into thinking otherwise. Cigarettes used to be advertised as healthy, too. I believe cell phones may have negative health effects that we have not yet discovered. They offer considerable convenience and that's worth it for me, but I know people who don't use them for that reason. I'm skeptical about GMOs in general as they have potentially unknown environmental risks that we are poorly equipped to reverse or undo once we discover them. New medicines obviously must be weighed against the disease they treat and the existing standard of care. Waiting is exactly the wise choice, and acting like the alternative is cigarettes is nonsense when there's a perfectly available, free, harmless alternative that works for billions of people all over the world and has done for all time, which is simply not smoking. As for your actual question, whether vaping is worse than cigarettes, I don't know and wouldn't guess, but I wouldn't quit smoking to take up vaping.
- EpicEng 7y agoYes, the old abstinence approach. That one always works well. You don't know what you're talking about. >As for your actual question, whether vaping is worse than cigarettes, I don't know and wouldn't guess, but I wouldn't quit smoking to take up vaping. So you "don't know" if something known to cause cancer and respiratory disease is worse than something not known to cause any disease? And you see some amount of logic in this belief?
- d1zzy 7y agoIf we replaced large increasing lung cancer rates with acute respiratory issues for some people vaping fake products I say we're much better off.