42 ms·
India Loses Contact with Probe Just as It Prepares to Land on Moon
- abhiminator 7y agoHere's [1] a data graph of the Doppler curve from Dwingeloo Radio Telescope (based in Netherlands) showing the exact moment the probe crashed into the surface of the moon. https://twitter.com/cgbassa/status/1170072672266592256 https://twitter.com/cgbassa/status/1170072672266592256
- baybal2 7y agoIt bounced back?
- mkagenius 7y agoI am confused, the contact with ISRO was lost at 2.1 km height (as per ISRO's last night statement). So, not at 0 km height (crash) ? Edit: I meant contact with ISRO..
- jcims 7y agoAny RF experts in here kniw what that cirrus cloud effect on the center transmission could be? Good view here: https://twitter.com/cgbassa/status/1170069055140765700?s=21 https://twitter.com/cgbassa/status/1170069055140765700?s=21
- sandworm101 7y agoThe blur is because the vehicle was vibrating. It means the thrusters were on. Note how they smooth out shortly after deceleration stops. Some of the larger movements could be maneuvering. If it is orientating itself then the antenna would intermittently move back and forth relative to the receiver.
- jcims 7y agoI was thinking vibration but wouldn't we see a change when the retro-thrusters hit halfway through? I'm assuming the first part with downward slope is the craft accelerating due to gravity? Given it's a polar landing I don't know how to translate this to the velocity vector of the lander.
- sandworm101 7y agoI think the change at the haldway mark is the thrusters stopping. The lander would continue shaking for a few seconds afterwards.
- raverbashing 7y agoIt seems it was supposed to be a polar landing, which should be harder (I think) than landing from an equatorial arrival Nonetheless, this is rocket science and failures are very common and not unexpected. Too bad, but it happens.
- egdod 7y agoWhy would landing from a polar orbit be harder?
- seer 7y agoI’m no expert but doing polar landing would involve a plane change maneuver after you arrive in moon orbit (or some clever orbital mechanics to minimize delta-v losses and somehow do it in a single burn (both capture and plane change). Apart from that, I’d presume theres also complexity of the landing site not being directly visible from earth, necessitating re-transmissions from the orbiter. Not something that hasn’t been done before by any chance, but still harder than say USSR’s lunokhod missions. Though this is mostly coming from my Kerbal Space Program experience.
- kraetzin 7y agoIn terms of orbital mechanics the polar orbit around the moon isn't significantly more complicated than an equatorial one. A small midcourse correction after entering a flight path towards the moon is all that's needed to ensure capture into orbit around the poles (and a capture burn), without the need for a plane change (note that this is also based on experience from KSP).
- raverbashing 7y agoI see what you mean, though I'm not sure of all the details, you might want to get into an equatorial orbit (there is an orbiter, though I'm not sure about its orbit) just because the error margin is smaller (?) or for some other reason. (But then of course the moon is neither too far nor too big so I might just be barking at the wrong tree here)
- shironineja 7y agoThis should have nothing to do with the unknown gel-like substance found by the Chinese drone: https://www.technologyreview.com/f/614262/china-says-it-found-something-bizarre-and-unexpected-on-the-moon/ https://www.technologyreview.com/f/614262/china-says-it-foun...
- thewhitetulip 7y agoI read that the maximum experiments are in the orbiter so this is a successful mission. The only thing for which it 'failed' was to let the ruling class do chest thumping by saying 'we are the fourth country to land a rover'. The ruling party had planned a great celebration today for it's 100 days in office, a date coinciding when the rover would land! They wanted to milk it for their nationalistic purposes while their blind followers dance to the tunes and love ISRO's achievements while bashing Nehru who started ISRO (1962).
- mysterydip 7y agoGiven the successful landing would've been a political bragging point, could contact have been lost deliberately by people with a different political affiliation?
- Macha 7y agoA bit like asking would democrats have foiled the moon landing to deny Nixon the credit - I find it hard to believe the scientists who put years into the project would screw it up over a change in political leadership
- mayankkaizen 7y agoI am anti Modi but I so much wanted this mission to succeed. ISRO is the only organization in India which is doing great on global level. It was really irritating the moment Modi turned this mission into his PR gimmick. Had this mission succeeded, the public euphoria would have been something unparalleled. Recently public reactions to Pulwama attack (months of protesting, candle light marches), article 370 issue (people started dancing on the streets when it was removed) were actually terrifying because it showed the rise of maddening extreme nationalism. But ISRO was away from this madness and political agenda. Now Modi has turned his eye on this organization, god save ISRO because Modi has tried to undermine the independence of every other major institutions like Army, RBI, EC, CAG etc.
- bigcloud1299 7y ago
- ironfootnz 7y agoIt remained me this gif https://www.jokejive.com/images/jokejive/4d/4d735fbf33e893db8410f95ba78b264f.jpeg https://www.jokejive.com/images/jokejive/4d/4d735fbf33e893db...
- dang 7y agoNationalistic slurs will get you banned here. No more of this, please, on HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dragonsh 7y agoIt's a good effort by ISRO and it's scientist. Just can't understand why so many countries reinventing the wheels. Space missions should be multi-country efforts continuously as it belongs to all. We should not extend our tribal nationalistic thinking to space. Best scientist can be in any nation and more diverse the group and experience the better chances of success. I know I am just dreaming, but hopefully we can come to consensus and try challenges of space as a new frontier as a single human race, originating from Africa.
- rayiner 7y agoNo. We’re different groups of people with different interests, different values, different ideas principles cultures histories views of the world. It’s good for us to be competing to explore space (and in trying to develop technological advantages in general). For countries like India it’s critical to develop their own technologies on this front. Otherwise they’ll remain eternally dependent on America, etc., for access to space. A “single human race” would be a deeply dysfunctional, unworkable mega-society. Our societies are already too big to be governable. (Ever notice how in Star Trek, aside from token, curated, differences, trillions of people are somehow almost completely culturally homogenous? That’s what makes the federation governable. But it would never work that way in real life. There would be intense conflict. The idea of a society that big being governable is part of the science fiction.)
- nafey 7y agoWell let's revisit this statement in 500 years. Every decade has brought the world closer. Even the recent developments (brexit, trump) are reactions to increased pace of integration. You can find kfc, coca cola in socities as diverse as Mongolia and Madagascar. It will be extremely difficult to turn the clock back on this and this will only keep on intensifying in my opinion.
- lenkite 7y agoOf-course you are right: there are likely to be several major wars in 500 years where smaller and poorer nations get annexed or more likely - simply subjugated by sheer economic dominance. The winners who perform this 'integration' will definitely be in charge of the space missions.
- mpaxd 7y agoOnly three months left to become a superpower... :(
- gingabriska 7y agoDo astronauts commit sucide if they get stuck in space? Do they take gun or poison pill into space?
- sanguy 7y agoAs usual for India attempts at greatness are usurped by incompetence! So common in this country. So much corruption. So much complacency. So much waste.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post nationalistic flamebait to HN, regardless of which nation you're part of or opposed to. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- williesleg 7y agoNo doubt somebody (quite possibly the entire team) simply just did the needful.
- org3432 7y agoI'm for space programs, but India is one of the poorest countries on earth, and spending that kind of money on social programs would actually have an impact on it's population. And then it looks like it failed on top of that, which is honestly not surprising, since space programs are so sensitive to minor quality issues and quality is the hardest thing for a 3rd world country. If I was living in India and struggling to get by I couldn't help question why this was a priority at all, national ego?
- mav3rick 7y agoThe budget is tiny compared to national welfare schemes. India's remote sensing satellites have helped countless farmers as well. Not to mention the inspiration it gives to future generations.
- axaydeshraj 7y agoEvery country with a space program has its issues and underfunded social welfare programs. This should not stand in the way of innovation. Having indigenously developed space technology offers India a unique strategic advantage especially when it's achievements have come at a fraction of the cost of other programs (Mangalyaan for example).
- mav3rick 7y agoSpeaking of quality. ISRO has a tremendous record of successful missions.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 7y ago1 in 8 households in America was food insecure in 2017 [1]. Do you think it's justified to spend 20 billion dollars on NASA when America can't even provide food security to each of its residents, and reports of crumbling infrastructure from all corners of the country, from collapsing bridges to cracking dams speak the sorrow tale of construction quality in what is supposed to be a 1st world country? [1] https://www.feedingamerica.org/about-us/press-room/new-data https://www.feedingamerica.org/about-us/press-room/new-data
- 7y ago
- agrippanux 7y agoKudos to India for even trying. While they are trying to put a probe on the moon, we have a President going through dementia arguing about a 2 week old weather forecast.
- nicodjimenez 7y agoWhile they are trying to put a probe on the moon?? We sent actual people there 50 years ago! And they did not crash on the moon. What do these people all have in common? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_who_have_walked_on_the_Moon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_who_have_walked... They are all American.
- jacobmoe 7y ago50 years ago we walked on the moon. This year we're not. _They_ went to the moon, built the interstate system, subway system, etc. _We_ are barely maintaining what we inherited.
- nicodjimenez 7y agoWe are maintaining what we inherited just fine. Blue Origin and SpaceX are leading the way on making space actually accessible at a reasonable price. US is doing just fine.
- ultrasounder 7y agoCame at a Yuuuuge price. The Appllo program claimed several lives even before the first probe launch. Recommend watching “The First Man” for accurate portrayal. Also the difference in budget between the NASA program and ISRO program is Apples one quarter earnings. Just saying
- nicodjimenez 7y agoWhen you're rich you can afford the huge price tag.
- tozeur 7y agoYay India’s great at trashing even the moon
- dang 7y agoNationalistic flamebait will get you banned here. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and don't post like this to HN. Edit: it looks like you've been posting quite a few unsubstantive comments to HN generally. Could you please not? We're trying for a bit better quality level than internet default here.
- ultrasounder 7y agoAlways puts a smile on my face when i read a comment from @dang!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tozeur 7y agoMy apologies, I didn’t mean to dilute the quality of HN. I’ll state my comment in a less “flamebait” manner next time. But you can’t deny that the Tragedy of the Commons can now be applied to the moon...
- brij0102 7y agoWhat do we think went wrong? I expect maths to be right but there was a comment somewhere about the regolith with fine particles whose specific composition could have caused unexpected dust clouds as the lander sped to the ground ... how was this tech different from the other 3 successes?
- sandworm101 7y agoThose dust clouds, depending on particle size/composition, could start reflecting radar. Lander then gets confused about its altitude and crashes. This sort of thing makes some areas, the dusty flat ones, potentially more dangerous than others. But they are also flatter and so you don't worry about landing on a rock and tipping over. It's a judgement call.
- brij0102 7y agoThat would always be a problem though, right? So for unmanned moon landings, do we instead need those inflated bouncy balls? Or did the previous successes just got it right?
- mzs 7y agoMy guess is the attempt at slowing caused it to pitch wildly.
- brij0102 7y agoSo the algo didn’t account for that or the hardware wasn’t able to compensate?
- jk27277 7y agoSame bug the brought the two boings down?
- kappi 7y agoLatest update.. DSN did a carrier lock on lander https://twitter.com/dsn_status/status/1170391223040954368 https://twitter.com/dsn_status/status/1170391223040954368 DSS 54 carrier lock on Chandrayaan-2 Lander Frequency: 2.2846GHz Signal strength: -143dBm IDLE OFF 1 TURBO
- adt2bt 7y agoCan you explain in layman’s terms what this might mean?
- sandworm101 7y agoIt means they are trying to contact it using the most powerful antennas available. It hasn't phoned home yet.
- kappi 7y agothey established a lock and were sending data at 11kW to the lander.. maybe trying to do some kind of recovery...but no communication back from the lander
- foxyv 7y agoIt means they could hear the radio signal they were sending reflect off the probe, but the probe was like "Nah ain't talkin!
- Trias11 7y agoThat singal strength is like barely above photonic noise
- mzs 7y agoI'm guessing it's a false positive from noise amplification instead.
- HenryBemis 7y agoI apologize for not reading ALL 500+ Comments (stopped halfway as the politics and history took over). This may have been mentioned. In some occasions when an event is being broadcast live, a 10-30-60 seconds delay is added to the signal "just in case". Is there any chance that the Probe crashed on the moon and India's gov/space agency cut the feed while YouTube, live TV, etc. was on this +60 seconds? I remember when the 3 of SpaceX rockets were doing the concurrent landing (2 at land, 1 at sea), the sea platform link had "a problem" and went down. Then miraculously once the situation was assessed another video surfaced from a nearby camera some time later and we saw that the rocket tilted and fell at sea. With that said I hope all (peace driven) space exploration efforts go well and we end up with a Star Trek TNG society in 300-400 years.
- dang 7y agoAll: please don't take this thread, or any other HN thread, into nationalistic flamewar. It breaks the site guidelines and is off topic here. If your comment might contain flamebait, please edit it until it clearly doesn't.
- vikasg 7y agoIs it considered "nationalistic flamewar" when people comment that maybe certain countries shouldn't even try to explore space? Just asking.
- aey 7y agoYes. There is no country that couldn’t use the funds to solve humanitarian problems, and there are no humanitarian problems where money is the only solution.
- sriram_sun 7y agoYes it is. Those comments will be voted out. Asking this question in a separate thread is feeding the trolls. We as a community should know and act better. I am downvoting above comment as well.
- lisper 7y agoYes. The phrase "certain countries shouldn't even try" is a pretty big clue.
- la6470 7y agoJust a half serious question. Why can’t we just descend these landers on the moon with a steel cable slowly?
- meesterdude 7y agoThis is a great thing for the people of India - I mean, hopefully. The science we expel is a reflection of the cultures that created it. In space, everyone has had failures. And I hope this failure offers reflection and improvement and that they can grow from it. But even still, this is otherwise part of a narrative change for the people of india, and something "so simple" can have a huge impact on future generations and what people tell themselves on an individual level.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoSpace is hard. I wish India all success in their next try.
- rajeevw 7y agoI wish them success in feeding their poor
- nikhil5 7y agoThey should try to feed starving people first
- nnq 7y agoOne can enable the other: space programs keep top engineers in the country, and this has big network effects that push up the entire economy... So you end up with more money to feed starving people from! (...not that you'd do that with the $, but anyway). Like it or not we engineers like to work on interesting problems and don't really give much thought to social issues, so if you want the super smart engineers to meaningfully contribute to a society and economy instead of emigrating or refactoring themselves into oligarchs you need to give them interesting science and technology problems to work on. Once you have a richer economy, the problem you wanted to solve in the first place gets waaaay easier!
- jsilence 7y agoEvery country in the world has a lot of issues to fix. If we as humanity had followed this general advice, we'd probably still be sitting in caves, figuring out the perfect cave heating system instead of leaving the cave and exploring. Harking on humanitarian issues of other countries is awkward for, assuming you are from the US, a country where life expectancy is falling, real income is falling, millions are without health insurance and freedom of press is declining. There is a plethora of other issues touching human dignity and humanitarian topics in the US and yet no one tells them to fix them first before doing X. Sorry to be blunt, but your comment is ignorant and arrogant.
- leon1717 7y agoIt's in the moon with Moonman.
- nikhil5 7y agoI have spent many years in India, and I know that the poorest of its people do not support these kinds of financial adventures (or in this case disasters)
- ggm 7y agoAlmost no economy in any context, developed, developing, self-reliant, dependent ever has everyone happy with how public funds are spent. It typically falls on the arts, or defence (different opponents) but can hit science and industry funding too. The belief that the funds were ever going to be targeted to relieving poverty is unjustified. Not unreasonable, and not without some basis in need: The simple observation that the source of funds is not actually tasked with that goal, and the nature of state funding admits that money can (and will) be spent to goals other than those somebody, somewhere wants. The exception to the rule is "hypothicated" taxes. In Australia, our medibank levy is fully hypothicated to funding public health, and cannot (by law) be used any other way. TL;DR Indian poverty was never going to be alleviated by the money spent on this project. The money simply wouldn't have been applied to that purpose, had it not been spent on this mission. second TL;DR The same can be said for any NASA or like activity.
- sbmthakur 7y agoDo all homeless people in developed countries support their respective nation's space program?
- wtdata 7y agoHomeless people in developed countries, are in almost every case (perhaps with the exception of the USA, I'm not sure) homeless due to mental issues and because they don't want to go into community housing. They aren't homeless due to a general lack of resources.
- newsgremlin 7y agoIt's not always a lack of resources but access to resources. They need an address, along with a long waiting list the accommodation they have access to is shared, often with other homeless with said mental health issues. That itself is a scary and a dangerous place to be, they are also targeted by drug dealers that prey on any addictions, trying to get them addicted.
- rajeevw 7y agoSo all that money was wasted. I wish they hadn’t even tried, and had used that money instead to feed the poor or to fix their insane environmental problems.
- anjalierangas 7y agoIt’s sad that with so many people starving, India would rather waste money on this.
- anjalier 7y agoPlease do not downvote or flag me. This is not supposed to be a flame post. I’m not one of those people saying “India shouldn’t explore the moon before they feed all their poor people.” Indeed, India should work on everything at the same time. However, it is not healthy for communities like HN to remove every post where someone brings up the possibility that exploring the moon may not be in the interest of India’s poor population. It’s important to voice this point of view, because India’s poor do not have a voice on HN. If we want to be open to all opinions without bias, then we must consider that this disregarded viewpoint may conflict with our own. Recognizing this is healthy for the HN community and others. It’s not always about labeling things as right and wrong. Sometimes acknowledging that there is space between right and wrong is valuable. Thank you for reading this.
- thewhitetulip 7y agoIn other news, govt reduced salaries of ISRO staff just before launch of this satellite https://hwnews.in/news/national-news/govt-cuts-back-incentives-isro-scientists-just-chandrayaan-launch/105709 https://hwnews.in/news/national-news/govt-cuts-back-incentiv...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- happy-go-lucky 7y agoLatest update... looks like they've found the location of the lander on the lunar surface, the orbiter has clicked a thermal image of the lander, and they're trying to establish a contact with it. Don't know how reliable this source is: https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1170610654232731648 https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1170610654232731648
- plibither8 7y agoEdit: This is a fake account. My apologies. From the ISRO Chief himself: https://twitter.com/KailasavadivooS/status/1170612975582887937 https://twitter.com/KailasavadivooS/status/11706129755828879...
- happy-go-lucky 7y ago> https://twitter.com/KailasavadivooS/status/1170612975582887937 https://twitter.com/KailasavadivooS/status/11706129755828879... It's a fake account :)
- plibither8 7y agoThanks for pointing it out!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- imtringued 7y agoThis is a boring comment section. Only the top 40 comments are actually about the space mission. 130 comments respond to the same parent about a world government and the rest of the comments are flagged... I personally am sad that this mission has failed. Exploring the permanently shadowed craters of the moon is necessary to find whatever sliver of ice remains on it. The satellite industry is growing but there is still no economic case for going to the moon and this mission could have changed that.
- brentis 7y agoUnexpected condition.