4 ms·
I skeptical that this system can scale to decent power output. A 100W conventional turbine is not a threat to birds either, because it's tiny. Modern wind turbi
by adrianN 7y ago
I skeptical that this system can scale to decent power output. A 100W conventional turbine is not a threat to birds either, because it's tiny. Modern wind turbines produce something like 10MW. That's 100000 times more power. Even small residential turbines are in the kilowatt range.
- whazor 7y agoThe small size makes it ideal for putting some in your garden. Probably comparable to solar panels. Transport of electricity is also expensive so there are some benefits.
- atoav 7y agoAnd the bird threatening factor of one wind turbine compares to one cat (at least in Germany).
- kgabis 7y agoCats don't kill large migratory birds. But wind turbines do.
- shakna 7y agoThere was a 2007 legal case that, though the jury ended in deadlock (as to whether or not the shooting of a cat was legal), suggests that cats do in fact kill migratory birds. Stevenson v Galvestone, I believe.
- j88439h84 7y agoThat's interesting, and I'm curious why someone would know this. Are you in the field?
- tomohawk 7y agoInitially, or later, when the large, mechanical apex predator has cleared the area?
- atoav 7y agoI am quite convinced that the areas where there are wind turbines in Germany don’t intersect much with the area where there are cats. Germany e.g. has a many offshore wind parks and cats can’t really swim that well. And I wouldn’t call something that rotates completely unimpressed of flying criters a “predator”. Maybe you could call it a trap. Or a hazard. Are glas windows considered a predator?
- OskarS 7y agoYeah, I'm skeptical too, but I still think it's a worthwhile investment to see what comes out. Probably nothing, but we need as much investing as possible in climate-friendly power sources. This bet might not pay off, but you do enough of them, one might pay off big.