5 ms·
> By extending a line, anchored on the moon, to deep within Earth's gravity well, we can construct a stable, traversable cable allowing free movement from the v
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
> By extending a line, anchored on the moon, to deep within Earth's gravity well, we can construct a stable, traversable cable allowing free movement from the vicinity of Earth to the Moon's surface. With current materials, it is feasible to build a cable extending to close to the height of geostationary orbit, allowing easy traversal and construction between the Earth and the Moon.
If we still need rockets to reach the bottom of the cable 36,000 km above Earth's surface, doesn't that negate the point of a "space elevator"?
- radford-neal 7y agoYou'd need to reach the height of 36,000 km, but not the velocity needed for geosynchronous orbit - only the velocity needed to match the angular motion of the moon, which I think would be 28 times less.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mynegation 7y agoI’m not very good at physics but - intuitively- would not attaching a payload that have not reached geostationary velocity pull this space line thing to the side and down with the force for which it was not designed
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- radford-neal 7y agoAttaching the payload would indeed pull on the line, since the payload wouldn't have the velocity to maintain itself in that orbit, and so would need an upward force from the line to not fall down. The line would of course need to be designed to handle that, as well as the increased load as the payload is hoisted up to the moon.
- banku_brougham 7y agoWhy is it less energy expended to hoist a load on a line than to use rocket propulsion?
- radford-neal 7y agoWell, whether it takes less energy would obviously depend on how the hoisting is done. But one advantage is that you can hoist slowly if that's advantageous, whereas you can't do things slowly with a rocket, at least until you've achieved orbit. Also, if we start with a rocket+fuel on earth, and end with a rocket on the moon, there's an inevitable input of energy to move the rocket to a location of higher gravitational potential, that would have to be provided with hoisting as well, but there's also be a lot of rocket exhaust (formerly fuel) that's now zipping around the solar system, carrying away energy.
- mynegation 7y agoTo attempt a generalized version of sibling comment from radford-neal, the energy that goes specifically into changing the position of the payload is the same, but how much of the total energy spent goes into that, depends on the method. For the rocket energy goes into so many things other than lifting the payload: kinetic energy of the exhaust, high temperature, sound, and - most importantly - lifting the fuel itself, quickly. Or to think another way think of all the challenges with human powered helicopter where the record is reaching 3.3 meters in 64 second flight, whereas any moderately physically fit person can climb the same height on the rope much faster and hang out there indefinitely, because they did not have to lift the weight of the helicopter and send the big masses of swooshing air down from the blades just to combat the force of gravity.
- Tepix 7y agoYou don't need to carry rocket fuel to do it. You can use solar energy.
- Terr_ 7y agoSo it's more like "use the moon as part of a non-rotating skyhook." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_(structure) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_(structure)
- opwieurposiu 7y agoAppendix B calculates a fuel savings of ~25% vs using only rockets to get to the moon. The saturn 5 rocket weighed 3,000 tons and was 96% fuel. Even if we only save 10% fuel, that's an extra 300 tons we can get to the moon.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago25% fuel saving seems like a small saving compared to the cost of building such cable. And of course, the saving up to geostationary orbit would be zero... I don't think you have your maths correct, either.
- pavel_lishin 7y agoSure, but imagine that 25% repeated over and over again.
- Someone 7y agoThis got downvoted, but it is correct. This cable won’t be a net gain if you want to go to the moon once, twice, or even ten times, but _if_ you want to, say, build a moon colony housing thousands, and you need to launch thousands of rockets, it likely will be. A concern would be how fast this line would wear down, and what would happen if it broke. Does it destroy your lunar colony, take out a zillion satellites in earth orbit, or just float down onto the moon, and burn down in the earth’s atmosphere?
- juliangoldsmith 7y agoThe Saturn V could transport about 50 tons to the moon. If it could transport another 300 tons, as GP said, it would be able to move 7 times as much payload.
- marcosdumay 7y agoThe GP's value is for 10% savings, the article says it saves 25% of the fuel, what means 750 tons extra, or 15 times as much payload.
- hateful 7y agoCouldn't we build another space elevator (or many) to orbit? Then we would just wait there, or move toward the moon's elevator?
- cellular 7y agoI like Issac Author's "orbital ring" idea. He is on YouTube. If you like space and futurism you need to see this guy's ideas! Also checkout my project: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/poly-wants-a-cracker/poly-wants-a-cracker-robot-controller-for-bricks/description https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/poly-wants-a-cracker/po...
- skykooler 7y agoIt still makes it easier to get raw materials to space; the difference is that in this case, the materials are mined on the Moon rather than Earth.