2 ms·
Ok, but city governments are frequently very large, which means bringing in an outside contractor will be very expensive. Remember that every level of contracto
by olliej 7y ago
Ok, but city governments are frequently very large, which means bringing in an outside contractor will be very expensive. Remember that every level of contractor adds additional overhead in the form of city funds being shifted into company profits.
For a small city, then yeah outsourcing might make sense. For a large one? Probably not.
The maths for cost is very simple: every person the contractor brings in is being paid for by the government, but now in addition to paying those employees, you also have to pay for a separate set of managers, and executives, and finally the business markup for profit.
If your org is large enough there is no way outsourcing is cheaper - it may be “easier”, but it inherently must cost more.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoNew Bedford city government has no reason to be that large though. Boston and some of its most urban suburbs maybe, but certainly not New Bedford or any of the other small cities in MA.
- jmclnx 7y agoI have to hand it to New Bedford, it is a poor City and they know how to run an IT dept, esp. compared to what larger cities do. So they should give their IT dept a nice bonus and maybe educate other gov. entities.
- zelly 7y ago>If your org is large enough there is no way outsourcing is cheaper - it may be “easier”, but it inherently must cost more. I would agree with this if you were talking about a real business, but this is government. An island full of 14 year olds can't be trusted to operate a power plant, even if they outnumber the employees of Pacific Gas & Electric. It's not a choice between outsource vs insource security, it's a choice between security or none at all.
- olliej 7y agoYou're missing the point - there is a company that has employees that can [ostensibly] do the job you need. It's a free market so you could directly employ those people, and in that case you get the same level of expertise and you aren't paying for the outsourcing company's overhead. Obviously employing those exact people may not be possible, but theoretically a large enough city can draw others of similar skill.
- chillacy 7y agoWhy are we talking about large cities? New Bedford is under 100k people, and the parent post said "rag tag city governments" not large cities.