9 ms·
> So, this (lousy, but interesting) study is basically "fasting by using drugs." That sounds to me like a big deal, given that most people find fasting difficu
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
> So, this (lousy, but interesting) study is basically "fasting by using drugs."
That sounds to me like a big deal, given that most people find fasting difficult (and unpleasant).
- ArtWomb 7y agoAgreed. Programmatic control of the "metabolic switch" at the cellular level is kind of a Holy Grail ;) Cellular metabolic reprogramming controls sugar appetite https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/704783v1.full https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/704783v1.full
- arcticbull 7y agoFasting is easy and fun, you just have to work up to it. You can just go from zero to not eating for a week. Building up your tolerance to it takes a bit, like anything else, but when you do it improves mental acuity, gets you a general sense of well-being and energy too.
- stickfigure 7y agoYour idea of 'fun' and my idea of 'fun' are wildly different.
- jvagner 7y agoThe idea of fasting and the reality of fasting are different. The idea is more painful than a committed effort. Once you accept and embrace the fast, it’s freeing. Like running every day.... once you know you’re going to do it, the resistance withers.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoI run and I fast. I enjoy the benefit. The actual act of doing these things are antithetical of fun for me. I do them because they work. If I lose motivation in life, it's the first thing I stop and the hardest to start up again (been many years that I've worked on self improvement) Good on you that it feels that way to you. No, I will never feel that way. People are different.
- pmiller2 7y agoAs someone who's gone multiple days in a row without eating non-voluntarily, you're never going to convince me that fasting for extended periods is fun.
- username90 7y agoThat is like judging sex after only having experienced rape, consent matters a lot in how enjoyable things are.
- luckylion 7y agoI've done both alternate day fasting and longer fasts (voluntarily) and I'm also in the same boat. It's not fun. If it didn't provide a health value to me, I wouldn't do it.
- badestrand 7y agoAfter doing intermittant fasting for half a year I think you shouldn't generalize too much from your own experience. Yes, it gets easier but it stays painful and requires a lot of willpower ime.
- yhoneycomb 7y agoI’ve been doing it for about a year and a half, just skipping breakfast each day and lunch one or two workdays a week. At this point, most days it’s not even hard. When I’m hungry I just realize that the hunger is temporary, and it’s honestly unrelated to the degree to which I need food. And tbh nowadays I can tell when my body actually feels weak and needs food, and when it’s just whining. I think of it like getting sleepy. Just because I feel sleepy doesn’t mean I should just take a nap right there and then.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> I’ve been doing it for about a year and a half, just skipping breakfast each day and lunch one or two workdays a week. You call that a fast? As someone who's lost and kept off about half their body weight, I feel qualified to tell you that skipping a meal here and there is not fasting. In fact, if you're eating every day you're not fasting. Fuck, I mean, I only eat about 1.5 meals a day as a requirement of merely maintaining my current weight (and even that doesn't always work).
- qnsi 7y agothis is just different definition of what fasting is. What he's doing is time-restricted eating but it is a form of fasting. You are just doing longer fasts. No need to gatekeep
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoSo is it a fast just whenever you're not eating?
- all2 7y agoThere are facets. Yes, you feel hungry. But, once you're there you are also laser focused (at least I am). My morning productivity and ability to sink into problems lasts all day, instead. I haven't got the other part, the ketogenic diet, yet.
- jokowueu 7y agoOh man you have to feel that fasting euphoria hitting you in waves before you say that
- mayankkaizen 7y agoThere was a time I wouldn't wake up early. I enjoyed sleeping till late morning. At that time I was kind of unable to feel why people who wake up early insist that it is more enjoyable than sleeping till 9 AM. Then I develop this habit of waking up early. Initially I wasn't very comfortable but now I too can say it is more enjoyable. I guess you get the point.
- balfirevic 7y agoDamn, I had to do a double take on this. 9 AM is super early for me, noon is normal and 2-3 PM is sleeping late. What is appealing and tolerable will not be the same for everyone and sometimes it's not just a matter of getting used to something. It's hard to say in advance.
- tempest345 7y agoExactly the same hours for me. Parent confused me!
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoWhen does that kick in? I've been waking up at 6:00am every morning for the past decade and still hate it.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoYou may not be able to force it. For years, I slept as late as possible, and hated waking up early. Something changed this summer, wherein I suddenly began waking up super early of my own accord, and then going to bed early to compensate. And I enjoy waking up early now. I'm still unsure if this will be the new normal, or if it's a phase that will go away as suddenly as it began...
- kharak 7y agoUh, do you mean two weeks of only water? Do you do this for weight loss? Do you work out? I would be very afraid to mess-up my metabosm. How do you prevent that?
- arcticbull 7y agoI've done up to a week before, it doesn't really change much IME, but I'm no doctor.
- nikkwong 7y agoLong term or repeated fasting should actually decrease your body's metabolism rate; which is a good thing if you want to age slower. (I.e. think about species who have slow metabolisms, turtles, for one, who live very long lives). I do alternate day fasting (48 hour fasts, every other day) and realized I now need far fewer calories to get by than I used to. Obviously anecdotal but I feel great!
- ianai 7y agoHow did you work up to fasting?
- all2 7y agoI typically get back into it by skipping breakfast for a week. Then I also start skipping lunch some days. Right now I do a 24 hour fast (dinner to dinner) about once a week.
- nikkwong 7y agoIt’s just another challenge in life like all the other ones. Once you’ve started dipping your toes in you slowly realize the state of homeostasis starts to feel a bit perverse. Obviously it feels good to be fed, but, like in other areas of life, if we never chose to find what our next frontier is and push our limits we won’t grow personally. Some people are fine with that obviously, but I’ve always been one to push my limits. Concretely though, I started with 16/8 then narrowed it down to like a 3 hour eating window then just decided I could go all out alternate day fasting. Now I do something like a 45 hour fast with 3 hour eating window, perpetually; and a 72 hour fast once a month.
- RandomTisk 7y agoHave you experienced additional mental acuity/focus first hand? Fasting for 24-36 hours for me isn't bad. But days 2 to 3 when I do a 3 day fast I find it extremely difficult to concentrate/focus on anything difficult. By day 3 my energy is usually shot as well and I just don't want to do anything but watch tv. If anyone has advice beyond sugar I'd love to hear it.
- arcticbull 7y agoYeah, I've done up to 7 days before, but I do drink huge quantities of black coffee every day and that by no means ends when I fast haha.
- nikkwong 7y agoAre you supplementing with electrolytes? You need magnesium citrate + salt + potassium. Without that I can't achieve fasts longer than 48 hours.
- arcticbull 7y agoThat's definitely true, electrolytes make it much easier.
- ilkan 7y agoWater-only fasting was popular in sanatoriums and weight loss spas in the late 1800's/early 1900's... practice was stopped after lack of electrolytes caused several patient deaths from heart arrhythmias.
- gwynplaine 7y agoCan you recommend any good sources to find out more about this need for electrolytes while fasting? I have been unable to find articles or books that seemed credible to my uneducated eye.
- joe_the_user 7y agoMy body weight puts me barely above underweight when I eat as much as I feel like. I don't think regular week long fasts could be very healthy for me.
- vilaca 7y agoSounds like you could successfully fast very easily by eating the same amount of food in shorter period of the day, like 16h fasting and eating in the remaining 8h of the day. Without changing the amount of daily calories you wouldn't experience weight loss. Obviously saying 'could' is not the same as saying 'should' and it's not very safe to do drastic changes to your diet without consulting a MD.
- webmaven 7y agoEating the same amount of food in a much shorter period is also a great way to train your stomach to accept (and unfortunately, expect) more food before feeling full.
- tptacek 7y agoIs that a well-documented truth, or just something you think seems right? The opposite has been true for me for the last few years of sort of informally fasting: I hit uncomfortable satiety faster when fasting.
- codyb 7y agoI will add my personal anecdote to that. Generally after not eating for a long time I’ll be pretty hungry, but a lot of times things won’t seem appetizing. And when I do eat I usually fill up quick. And have to wait a bit to eat anymore.
- rjf72 7y agoThe Hadza in Africa are an interesting people. Quite a lot has been written about these hunter/gatherers. [1] The have the physiques you'd expect of hunter/gatherers, but not the lifestyle. They work around 2 hours a day in mostly low energy tasks. And their leisure time isn't exactly spent running marathons - the most common past times being gambling and simply relaxing. Part of the reason they've been reluctant to adopt agriculture is because they think it'd take too much work. You can do an imagine search for pictures of their well known people. Suffice to say, you're not gonna find many love handles. Stories like this are part of what convinced me to give fasting a go. And after going on 2 years of it now, I've had the exact opposite experience of that which you describe. In particular I don't eat the same total amount of food/calories, I eat substantially less. And somehow I have substantially more energy. The reason I decided to try out fasting is because it seems evident that we're eating far more than we need, as the absurd rates of obesity/overweight attest to. Blaming the lack of exercise is somewhat nonsensical as can be shown from more ancient peoples. But it can also be shown numerically. I now bike around 5k a day and that burns about 100 calories. That's 15 minutes of biking to burn the equivalent of about a third of a slice of pizza. Exercise is of course important, but not for the calorie burning. If you eat poorly (or too much) it doesn't matter if you spend hours at the gym - you're gonna get fat. I think the actual truth is that in modern times we've trained our bodies to expect far too much food. Fortunately this is really easy to reverse. It just requires accepting a discomfort that fades somewhat quickly over the months. [1] - http://rewild.com/in-depth/leisure.html http://rewild.com/in-depth/leisure.html
- rootw0rm 7y agoWell, I'll at least agree that fasting is easy. It's a habit I picked up in jail. My ex recently told me that she also picked it up in jail (we were arrested together). I think being in such an environment, with little to no control over anything else, controlling your eating habits becomes a natural way to restore some balance.
- Kaiyou 7y agoWhat is fasting anyway? Some people tell me they "fast" by drinking no alcohol. Others say they fast by only drinking water and not eating anything at all. Why does everyone have to use the word so differently..
- newnewpdro 7y agoI have never heard someone refer to abstaining from alcohol as fasting. Cleansing, or detoxing, yes. Fasting, no. The people around you are simply misusing the term.
- Kaiyou 7y agoI've also heard it in relation to not eating meat, not eating candy and not eating various other categories of food. Never have I heard it in a meaning of not consuming anything at all, however.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- newnewpdro 7y agoMaybe it's common in a religious context? Fasting meaning abstinence from food is fairly well-established. Breakfast is literally break-fast, with the fasting period being overnight while you slept.
- Kaiyou 7y agoYes, I mostly hear it in a religious (catholic) context. Fasting lasts a couple of months for them, I think.
- laurex 7y agoIt is also ill-advised for women, and this study, like many on fasting, only used male subjects.
- chiefalchemist 7y ago> "That sounds to me like a big deal, given that most people find fasting difficult" They also find hospitalization "difficult" but that doesn't stop them from OD'ing on sugar and junk food. It's not a matter of difficulty. It's a matter of priority. We (in the USA) live in a culture that devalues the personal responsibility to personal health.