7 ms·
How social networks can be used to bias votes
- tqi 7y ago> We initially assume the payoff to the losing team is positive, b > 0, which reflects a ‘compromise worldview’: it is preferable to reach some decision than to end in deadlock. This payoff scheme captures the common practical value of broad consensus in collective decisions, even as individuals pursue partisan preferences12,13. There is ample evidence that large majorities of Americans, for example, adopt a compromise worldview in their attitudes towards political decisions14. However, others adopt a ‘zero-sum worldview’ in which they prefer deadlock to their party losing, that is, b < 0. The behaviour of people with a zero-sum worldview is simple: they act as zealots, meaning that they always vote for their preferred party regardless of the poll that they see. We begin by focusing on players with a compromise worldview, and then we study groups with a mixture of compromise and zero-sum players, including zero-sum bots. In the context of voters in our modern politics, does the "compromise" viewpoint even exist?
- jcranberry 7y agoThey do, but they're decreasing in number. They're also kind of boring so they don't get coverage the way highly vocal 'zealots' do.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bt848 7y agoData on political polarization in America is really interesting. One feature of the data I find fascinating is that in 1994 many people were not "consistently liberal" because they opposed gay marriage. With the big shift toward acceptance of gay marriage these people are now considered "consistently liberal" and by Pew's reckoning this means that liberals have become "more polarized". In my opinion there is no morally defensible compromise position on whether homosexuals deserve their natural rights, so I find this quirk of the survey interesting. If you look at the ten questions of the Pew survey, it seems to me that anyone who can answer on the conservative side of all ten questions (in order to earn the "consistently conservative" epithet) must be the biggest jerk on Earth, whereas someone who answers on the liberal side of all ten has sensible and morally justifiable views, hence I take all the hand-wringing over polarization with a grain of salt. https://www.people-press.org/2014/06/12/political-polarization-in-the-american-public/ https://www.people-press.org/2014/06/12/political-polarizati...
- oh_sigh 7y agoI don't want to nitpick, but I don't see how gay marriage in this context is a natural right, since really it is just a government actively providing a service(marriage licensing). A natural right might be more like the right for two gay people to cohabit, or a religious marriage joining two gay people in marriage.
- bt848 7y agoThe actual question on the Pew survey is "Homosexuality should be discouraged by society." agree/disagree. The fraction of people agreeing with this statement has fallen greatly in the last 25 years, mostly due to demographic replacement.
- oh_sigh 7y agoYou can discourage something(which is a natural right of free speech), but still think people have the right to practice it - you might just think it is a bad idea for individual or social health(e.g. You can discourage people from becoming hermits, because a society of hermits isn't much of a society at all)
- aglavine 7y agoWhy Social Media (Facebook, Twitter, etc.) isn't willing to work with local media and communities? Maybe off topic but genuine question. We have traditional media that failed to transition to Web. Same stuff in different package, instead of collaborative approach. And we have social media that fails to deliver the promise of communities. Fails in the transition from virtual to real world. From my experience, success in Facebook is closed groups. They are the ones with most activity and the ones that achieves real social events. Both players (traditional media and social media) have what the other one lacks. I'm really scratching my head on why they aren't working together.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI think Facebook's biggest strength is local communities. It seems to be the best place to generate interest for events and new businesses and it seems effective. I can't imagine local newspapers are anywhere near as effective.
- aglavine 7y agoLocal newspapers are in-site and can contribute with the roles of leader, moderator and organizer, as well as adding genuine content. All of these Facebook Users usually don't achieve in an articulated way
- Nasrudith 7y agoWork with how? What would that entails? What is stopping them from getting their own right now?
- whatshisface 7y agoIf only this level of scrutiny was applied to traditional mass media over the last century. All of these techniques are just updated versions of handing the anchorman a biased script.
- rossdavidh 7y agoMy thoughts exactly. You know what else can bias voters? Expert testimony, even in fields outside their expertise. Religious leaders. Teachers. Flyers. Advertisements. In fact, just about any form of communication by anybody. Without comparing the size of the bias to other forms of influence, this is a nearly contentless statement.
- tj-teej 7y agoI don't think it's contentless, because for a long time there was an idea that Social Media would free the general public from manipulation by a small group of wealthy/powerful individuals/corporations. This article is effectively implying that Social Media is no different to the influences you cite.
- ekianjo 7y agoWhy would it be different? It is about how the brain works, and it applies across several forms of media.
- mattnewton 7y agoI personally held the (probably mistaken) belief that by democratizing publishing information, it would be harder to create a false signal. Ie, if everyone has a printing press, then nobody can control the entire narrative, the way a handful of newspaper barons could. Instead, it seems to me now that giving everyone a printing press made so much noise that we still rely on centralized authorities to sort, rate and surface those that we want to read. And it made it cheaper, in terms of both reputation cost and money, for someone to create a bunch of false signal. The parallel to the printing was misleading, and the true outcome is much more complicated and mixed. The scale really changes how these things work, in terms of the incentives created and the sheer amount of content possible to consume.
- shay_ker 7y agoIt's an interesting study in terms of how they conducted it, but isn't it obvious? If political ads didn't swing votes, no one would run them.
- tqi 7y agoThis study would also indicate that political polling has the ability to influence elections?
- Nasrudith 7y agoI thought everyone knew that already given that push polls are a thing.
- ekianjo 7y agoOf course, anything that brings focus potentially changes the final metric.
- tqi 7y agoI would agree, but I think most political reporters and pollsters view themselves as impartial observers rather than active participants...
- ekianjo 7y agoWhat they view themselves as does not change the fact that they skew things in one way or another. The only observer that is neutral is the one that is not seen and not heard of.
- gwern 7y agoIt's not at all obvious that political ads (or ads in general) work. The correlation of political ads (and all other kinds of political stumping) with success is confounded by donations (because more popular candidates are able to get more donations), and looking at randomized political interventions, we see tiny effects - you might've seen some coverage of "The Minimal Persuasive Effects of Campaign Contact in General Elections: Evidence from 49 Field Experiments", Kalla & Broockman 2018 https://web.stanford.edu/~dbroock/published%20paper%20PDFs/kalla_broockman_minimal_persuasive_effects_of_campaign_contact_in_general_elections_evidence_from_49_field_experiments.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/~dbroock/published%20paper%20PDFs/k... which says bluntly: "a systematic meta-analysis of 40 field experiments estimates an average effect of zero in general elections." Political scientists often find minimal effects of advertising spend in general (how much did Trump spend compared to Hillary? to use a particularly pointed example). And to the extent that some kinds of ads do work, they may be self-negating ('advertising wearout' and political examples in https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/25/business/what-advertising-history-says-about-the-future-of-fake-news.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/25/business/what-advertising... ). Ultimately, 'if people don't want to go to the ball game, how are you gonna stop'em?' More broadly, there are many experiments on online advertising showing that the correlational biases are huge and you get wildly misleading estimates if you use anything but rigorous randomized experiments, and the actual causal effects appear to usually be, again, close to if not indistinguishable from zero, which I link in https://www.gwern.net/Ads#discussion https://www.gwern.net/Ads#discussion It is extremely easy to fool yourself in this subject. For an even broader argument that we greatly overrate the manipulability of people, see Mercier 2017's "How Gullible are We? A Review of the Evidence from Psychology and Social Science" https://www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/2017-mercier.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/2017-mercier.pdf .
- jcranberry 7y ago>All data necessary to reproduce the results are available at https://github.com/jplotkin/InformationGerrymandering https://github.com/jplotkin/InformationGerrymandering >For example, when just a few yellow-party zealots were deployed strategically among a larger number of undecided players in the purple party, these bots were able to sway the majority opinion towards the yellow party. This was true even when the parties had exactly the same number of members, and when each player had the same amount of influence. I'd like to know a little more about the experiment, specifically how much information was available to individual voters. Did they know the votes of specific other voters? Of their party specifically? Or just the overall polling situation? Were they allowed to communicate, like through a chat box or something? Without knowing these details I'm finding it a little hard to understand how these few 'planted' zealots were able to influence the result that strongly.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rolph 7y agoi think this might cross over to something like: Election campaigns can be used to bias votes. That being said social media has a great potential to be used for campaign violations.
- return0 7y agoElections considered harmful.
- ilaksh 7y agoVotes are biased by worldview and worldview is tied to group identification.
- ultrablack 7y agoAdvertising works. News at 11... Here, all the polls are skewes towards whoever the polsters support. And have been for many years.. At least they can’t blame Trumps victory on this as the polls showed Hillary in the lead until after the election.
- maggotmagnet 7y agoYes, it all comes down to money. Money = the means to influence = power. It is interesting to note that citizens have been self-inflicting political bubbles upon themselves this for hundreds of years by surrounding themselves with similar-minded people (i.e., people who aren't going to argue with their politics).
- jessaustin 7y agoIt's impossible to tell from TFA or the abstract what precisely is meant by "information gerrymandering". One imagines some sort of graph theory or "six degrees of Bacon" argument. "This node should only influence some number of other nodes, but in fact if you count second- and third-order connections it influences some higher number of other nodes!" Presumably they've picked out some particular criteria for differentiating justifiable influence from unjustifiable influence. The criteria are probably fine; since we don't know them the point is moot. Even if one accepts all of that, one still can't follow TFA to its conclusion of "...voters really can be manipulated in the digital age. Legislators and regulators must take note." We've been working on this "giant graph of nodes influencing each other" problem for decades now. That's just SEO. That's the basic thing that Google does. Any network has these properties, even the "snail" networks of pamphlets and broadsheets that kept our founding fathers informed. It was completely appropriate for late-18C pamphleteers to publish and distribute according to the dictates of their own best judgment. It's completely appropriate for today's social network operators to do the same. It's completely appropriate for users to do just exactly as they please, whatever the TOS say. What is not appropriate is for "legislators and regulators" to imagine they have a damned thing to say about this process. 1A is not ambiguous on this question. The government don't get to forbid the public from hearing Trump describing to Billy Bush his techniques of seduction. They don't get to forbid the public from hearing Clinton tell bankers they should be able to regulate themselves. [0] It's a conversation because they don't get to decide everything that gets said. For three years now, a segment of the "intelligentsia" have wallowed in a mode of magical thinking about networks and bots that has left them completely uninterested in real things. If this research can help them break out of this rut, one welcomes it. However, that seems unlikely... [0] https://www.thedailybeast.com/leaked-podesta-emails-show-bernie-was-right https://www.thedailybeast.com/leaked-podesta-emails-show-ber...
- FredrikMeyer 7y agoThere is an ongoing controversy in Norway right now, where a TV show during one month tried to manipulate the results of "school elections" (basically mocks of the real elections, where one votes for the real parties - the results are often used as an indicator for the real election results some weeks later). The goal of the show was to show how election results can be manipulated, which created some outrage: some of the students are old enough to vote in the real elections, so they might have manipulated real results. Norwegian news source: https://www.nrk.no/norge/folkeopplysningen_-slik-forsokte-de-a-manipulere-skolevalget-1.14688590 https://www.nrk.no/norge/folkeopplysningen_-slik-forsokte-de...