4 ms·
> Yes, index investors are free riders, but this is the way most markets work. We don’t go to the grocery store to bid on prices of oranges against one another
by gnicholas 7y ago
> Yes, index investors are free riders, but this is the way most markets work. We don’t go to the grocery store to bid on prices of oranges against one another to set an equilibrium. The market does that for us.
Actually, our behavior does shape the price of oranges. If we go to the store and they're less expensive, then we are more likely to buy them. The analogy breaks down because he's comparing indexes and oranges, not stock indexes and food indexes. Imagine if 14% of people went to the grocery, picked up a sack of pre-selected items that were best sellers last week -- all in the name of efficiency and reducing overhead. That would be quite weird indeed, and some people would point out that if enough people did this it would create market inefficiencies and potentially cause a glut or crash of certain food prices.
- IshKebab 7y agoPeople more or less do do that. I've often searched for something on Amazon and bought the most popular result.
- gnicholas 7y agoSure, but do you buy a bundle of goods this way? That’s the analog of index investing.
- thekyle 7y agoWhat's the difference between going and buying 10 top goods individually and buying a bundle that contains those same 10 top goods.
- yifanl 7y agoNothing, but the analogy would be buying the Amazon top-seller of every product category. It doesn't make sense, you aren't going to use any of those products, you don't even care what most of them are.
- IshKebab 7y agoSure, when I buy a crate of wine, or a box of chocolates. Stretching the analogy somewhat but I think the point still stands that it doesn't require the entire market to actively invest to keep everything priced very close to the same price they would be if index funds didn't exist.
- maerF0x0 7y agoWe bid on a basket of groceries by choosing a store to shop at though. The price of oranges is mostly immaterial when compared to the greater pricing of the collection of goods purchased in a single trip. This is why loss leaders make sense. They entice you in w/ a distorted price and then recoup the loss across your basket.
- gnicholas 7y ago> * We bid on a basket of groceries by choosing a store to shop at though* I'm not sure I agree with this. Most grocery stores stock the same food, so it's not as if going to Lucky instead of Safeway shapes what you can/will get. You're right that if you go for particular sale items, you're more likely to get those. But does that have a basket-level impact? I'm not sure it does. Also, consider that when you go to a grocery store, you probably purchase about .05% of the items they sell. It's not like we go to Safeway and buy most of the things they sell there.