6 ms·
Fundamentally, Google's initiative on differential privacy is motivated by a desire to not lose data-based ad targeting while trying to hinder the real solution
by ocdtrekkie 7y ago
Fundamentally, Google's initiative on differential privacy is motivated by a desire to not lose data-based ad targeting while trying to hinder the real solution: Blocking data collection entirely and letting their business fail.
In a world where Google is now hurting content creators and site owners more than it is helping them[1], I see no reason to help Google via differential privacy when outright blocking tracking data is a viable solution.
[1] https://sparktoro.com/blog/less-than-half-of-google-searches-now-result-in-a-click/ https://sparktoro.com/blog/less-than-half-of-google-searches...
- benologist 7y agoIt's like the push to keep loot boxes legal by Microsoft and Nintendo. The EU is on the verge of outlawing their use because they encourage kids to gamble. MS and Nintendo hope that if loot boxes reveal their 0.00000001% odds they no longer resemble $5/spin slot machines.
- criddell 7y ago> In a world where Google is now hurting content creators and site owners more than it is helping them I have a hard time believing that because so few sites opt out of Google indexing.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThe problem is you have no choice. If Google is slowly killing you via starvation, but it's still feeding you crumbs at the moment. Nobody's answer is going to be to refuse the crumbs.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI don't see why you have no choice. Google doesn't stop you from using all the other mechanisms that exist to promote your site. In fact, I'm not sure I found any of the sites I regularly visit through Google.
- awakeasleep 7y agoI was very hostile to your take, but after thinking about it for a minute, this is an interesting point. I don't think it holds up for commercial sites, but for news, hobbies, and blogs (which have been hit hardest by Google's vampire advertisement business) your statement is true for me!
- moopling 7y agoYou are not the average user: https://www.nngroup.com/articles/computer-skill-levels/ https://www.nngroup.com/articles/computer-skill-levels/
- la_barba 7y agoWhat other ways exist to run a successful ad campaign?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoOff the top of my head, Facebook and Taboola have significant reach.
- pixl97 7y agoHeh, then you're not the average user that types 'facebook' in chrome to pull up the website.
- DanielBMarkham 7y agoYup. I've spent some time researching this and watching and contributing to a lot of conversations with technical folks. We can't instrument websites and applications. Data, once collected, never dies and nobody can be sure of where it will end up. We have to stop. The model itself is broken. Now it's up to the public policy folks to figure a way to get us out of this mess. I am not optimistic in the short run.
- skybrian 7y agoThis announcement is about the release of an open source library. Using it doesn't help Google.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoWide acceptance of this practice legitimizes it for Google.
- cromwellian 7y agoDifferential privacy is a tool for doing many useful computations in ways that provide value to end users beyond advertising. Apple uses it too. It's like saying "wide acceptance of end to end encryption legitimizes it for Google". Do you want your phone to give you real time traffic jam information without giving away your position? Do you want to better recognize and classify photos with ML while keeping your photos private? That's differential privacy. The rest, an implication of a desire for Google to fail even if the entire business model were based around privacy preserving techniques, makes the privacy saber rattling seem disingenuous and a means to a different end.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoMy phone can give me real time traffic jam information by traffic cameras which are placed along highways which can gauge the motion of the traffic without tracking me or my phone at all. I actually don't want anyone for any reason to be applying machine learning to my photos. Again, differential privacy is about finding excuses to justify the existence and protection of a company that is actively harmful to society. And we need to stop pretending your employer cares about it for any reason but protecting ad revenue.
- kalleboo 7y agoTraffic cameras can read and track license plate numbers, how is that private?
- joshuamorton 7y agoIf differential privacy solutions lead to things consumers want more, like better products (think: more accurate search results without uniquely targeted tracking), then is blocking all tracking viable?
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoCan we not pretend your employer wants to use this for better search results and be up front that it's about better ad revenue, which isn't beneficial or desirable to consumers?
- kalleboo 7y agoAs an independent developer I really want to know what features of my app are actually being used (and what devices they're using it on, OS versions, etc). I try to talk to my users but you only hear from the loud annoying ones, not the silent majority and the conclusions are inevitably wrong. I'd love a tool like differential privacy to gather statistics in a provably anonymous way. Without a tool like that, only companies with shedloads of money (like Google, Microsoft, Apple) can afford the market research (or the amount of spaghetti to throw at the wall) to compete.
- summerlight 7y ago> which isn't beneficial or desirable to consumers? Why? They're paying moneys through conversions, which is a pretty significant commitment and proof of its usefulness. You can argue that there's no real incrementality here, but I can tell you that at least half of ad revenues in general very likely have causal relationships from my observation.
- l0b0 7y agoYes. Millions are already doing it. Considering how much press privacy enhancements such as ad blocking gets, and how basically nobody is discussing how their search result quality went down afterwards, it seems pretty clear what people have chosen.
- JohnFen 7y ago
- summerlight 7y ago> Fundamentally, Google's initiative on differential privacy is motivated by a desire to not lose data-based ad targeting while trying to hinder the real solution: Blocking data collection entirely and letting their business fail. We don't usually call something infeasible "a solution", especially it means a fundamental structural change without giving a viable alternative to power a 300B market. So tell me, what is your proposal to give an approximately similar amount of efficiency to the market? If you don't have the one, that's fine but your criticism doesn't really resonate since at least Google tries to improve the status quo.
- specialist 7y ago"...a 300B market." Which market are you referring to? Advertising? Search engines? Other?
- summerlight 7y agoDigital advertisement? If you count the overall value produced by online ads, it's probably even bigger.
- specialist 7y agoI'm asking you. It's your rhetoric. What are you referring to? Update: Bueller?
- JohnFen 7y ago> at least Google tries to improve the status quo I don't see Google trying to do that at all. I see them trying to ensure that the status quo will never change.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]