4 ms·
Honestly, my biggest question is: Why did this get its own Unicode block? It's weird that symbols found on literally one object in history have gotten their own
by ocdtrekkie 7y ago
Honestly, my biggest question is: Why did this get its own Unicode block? It's weird that symbols found on literally one object in history have gotten their own unique Unicode assignments.
- amelius 7y agoBecause the archeologists need these glyphs in their papers.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoWhy not a vector image for super niches like these?
- tempguy9999 7y agoProb because a vector image would have visual content but no semantic content. That is to say, no identity (a number), no collation (ordering), no abstract representation ("PHAISTOS_PUNK_WITH_LONG_NOSE_AND_MOHAWK")[0]. Also if you already had unicode machiinery, which you will if you're writing a paper, you'd now need a 2nd mechanism for rendering; the SVG you mentioned. Unicode is meant to be universal so it makes sense to me. [0] which is indeed on the disk, although the minoans likely didn't call it that.
- AceJohnny2 7y agoDo the potential users of that codepage know to use it?
- tempguy9999 7y agoI'm sorry, I don't understand the question. it's unicode so AFAIU codepages don't apply. Am I misreading you?
- AceJohnny2 7y agoSorry, I misused "codepage" but meant the unicode block that includes these characters. My question is whether, considering these glyphs were included in Unicode for the purpose of usage as you described, those who would use it be technically sophisticated enough to actually do so? i.e. we built it, but will they come?
- tempguy9999 7y agoIf I gave the impression I was a unicode expert, that was a mistake. I have only done some reading. But from that limited position, such characters are just numbers in the unicode spec. If the appropriate font is installed on the document creators' and document readers' machines, it will render just like any other character such as the unicode you're reading here. If the font isn't present you'll probably get the number printed \u12345 or something similar. But I am not an expert and if one wants to chime in here, please do.
- ken 7y agoWhat semantic content is conveyed by assigning Unicode codepoints, though? The article says it's not even clear that it's a script. How can you make out numbers, or ordering, or meaning? Are there proposals to create a Unicode block for, say, the Voynich Manuscript? There's been much more written about that than this disc.
- tempguy9999 7y agoWell, as I described here. Whatever semantic content we assign to it. I think I see your point - you mean the semantics of the script's creators? Yes, good point, and no not that cos we don't know anything about what they meant, nor likely ever will. Any semantics we assign to it are a number (unicode value), possible collation (ordering), and the name (possibly other stuff, I don't know). So if we found more phaistos disks with punky-mohawk-guy on that, and we decided they were intended by the original creators to mean the same 'character' on all disks, all those glyphs would get the same unicode character. Scholars could then index them by the same 'character', look for relationsips between those characters they've established are the same. More concretely, what a letter is in english doesn't link much to how it looks. For example, the uppercase letters here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gebrochene_Schriften.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gebrochene_Schriften.png are all english but to my eyes, each taken individually, are grotesques and some (like the capital 'H' in Textur font), are illegible to me. Literally I would not guess what letter it is. Yet they're all your common or garden alphabetical letters. So the semantics are, whatever the 'H' looks like, we know what it is, how to sort with it, where to find it in an (english) dictionary, etc. HTH (and IANAExpert)
- joaomsa 7y agoThe Proposal for encoding the Phaistos Disc characters[1] lists the motivation behind including it (and rebutes some counter arguments). Principally, lots of publications discussing the Phaistos Disc would use it: > Phaistos Disc characters, whether syllables, or letters, or board-game dingbats, have historical and cultural significance, as attested in the large number of publications dealing with it. As noted above, the Wikipedia has articles about the Phaistos Disc in ten languages. The 30+ documents listed in the bibliography in this proposal are by no means the only documents printed which deal with the Phaistos Disc characters. The English Wikipedia article gives Phaistos Disc characters inline in text as well as in tables (Figure 8). Other documents exist which present the Phaistos Disc characters either inline (Figure 8) or in tables (Figures 1, 2, 5, 6, 7). It is true that the image of the Phaistos Disc itself is easy to represent with simple drawing (see Figure 3) but the discussion of its characters inline in Latin text is not. [1] https://www.unicode.org/L2/L2006/06095-n3066-phaistos.pdf https://www.unicode.org/L2/L2006/06095-n3066-phaistos.pdf
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThanks! I was poking around trying to figure it out, but did not find this.
- NKosmatos 7y agoThe undeciphered Linear A [0], related to the Phaistos disc, as well as many other languages have their own Unicode block [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_A [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unicode_block https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unicode_block