5 ms·
If I understand HK law correctly there are 2 offences: taking part in a an "illegal assembly" and "rioting". Rioting involves violence and I don't see the gove
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
If I understand HK law correctly there are 2 offences: taking part in a an "illegal assembly" and "rioting".
Rioting involves violence and I don't see the government budge on that. The fact that the protesters' demands mention a blanket amnesty and use the term 'riot' makes the demand unpalatable.
Regarding illegal assemblies there might be leeway in how strictly people are charged, or whether charges are dropped in many cases.
- JumpCrisscross 7y agoHong Kong almost passed a law allowing extradition to China, a country lacking the rule of law. This is why the legal code failed to mollify the population. It was the law itself the protesters were protecting.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoSome western countries have extradition treaties with mainland China. Beyond the obvious lack of trust the issue with such treaty is the procedure. Indeed it could give a say to HK courts or it could simply create a simple procedure where HK courts have no say beyond checking that the right forms were filled. I don't know how the bill was drafted. In general, it is not unreasonable for HK to have extradition procedures with the rest of China at large (mainland, Taiwan, Macau) but again, the devil is in the details. (Note that HK is formally part of the PRC, so saying "HK extradition to China" may ruffle some feathers).
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Some western countries have extradition treaties with mainland China Few, and with strict legal and political supervision [1]. The proposed law would have single-handedly smothered Hong Kong’s rule of law and stability. It was a stupid, unnecessary move pursued solely for Xi’s political concerns. > HK is formally part of the PRC Hong Kong is Chinese territory from a military perspective. Civically, legally and administratively, it is separate. Hong Kongers used to identify as Chinese. But due to Xi’s hamfistedness over the past few months, that is no longer the case. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extradition_law_in_China https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extradition_law_in_China
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe list does not strike me as "few", which is by the way irrelevant to the point... As I said the devil is in the details, not the principle. HK is part of the PRC, that's what many people miss. It is granted special status within the PRC by a national law. Hence the official name "Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China". This is quite different from what, e.g. British people might expect. For example HK was never part of the UK and Gibraltar today is not part of the UK. The point being that opposing "HK" and "China" as is often the case in western media is inaccurate and perhaps not productive as it sometimes seems intended solely at annoying the Chinese government.
- Aeolun 7y ago> intended solely at annoying the Chinese government This seems enough reason to me. Did you ever read about their antics in regards to Taiwan? They deserve everything that’s coming to them.
- SECProto 7y ago> Few, and with strict legal and political supervision The strict supervision is the key here - there could not be true supervision of an extradition treaty with China when the executive is appointed BY mainland China.
- verall 7y agoIn all English news and the first article it's literally called an extradition bill, what would you call it instead?
- spacehunt 7y ago> Rioting involves violence and I don't see the government budge on that No it doesn't. It's ridiculously easy to be charged for rioting. Here's the legal definition: http://www.hklii.hk/eng/hk/legis/ord/245/s19.html http://www.hklii.hk/eng/hk/legis/ord/245/s19.html
- mytailorisrich 7y ago"breach of the peace"... Considering that the legal system is descended from the British system (and actually this law dates from British rule), this means: "when a person reasonably believes harm will be caused, or is likely to be caused, to a person or in his presence to his property, or a person is in fear of being harmed through an assault, affray, riot, unlawful assembly, or some other form of disturbance" [1] This is legal speak to mean violence against people or property. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breach_of_the_peace https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breach_of_the_peace
- spacehunt 7y agoRead it more closely. - Violence doesn't have to be actually carried out. - Once a "breach of peace" is declared, everyone in the general vicinty can be charged with rioting.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIn general, behaviour that is threatening enough to cause alarm is considered violent. This what this law says, which is fairly standard. If you take part in a riot/violent protest you may be charged with a criminal offence. This is the way it works in most countries, including the UK. There is nothing extraordinary there. Being arrested or even charged is also not the same as being convicted. Note that the definition also includes unlawful assembly, so the people involved would already be in the wrong. I think some people are trying a bit too hard to excuse violent protests as if HK was somehow a special case.
- spacehunt 7y ago
- throwaway1997 7y agoIt's referring to a specific event on June 12th where police referred to a peaceful protest as a riot.