14 ms·
Crystalline nets harvest water from desert air, turn CO2 into liquid fuel
- cbanek 7y agoThis is really interesting! As someone who lives in the desert, I would want one of these. But nothing comes for free - it seems like the output would be dependent on the humidity level of the air. If everyone was running these, would it be as effective? My gut says yes, just due to how much airmass there is, and even the heat from the ground should provide some mixing. But I am not sure of the napkin calculation, which I'm sure they've done. Also at higher temperatures, the air can hold _more_ water vapor. This is why humidity is relative to the maximum amount of water the air can hold. The CO2 capture potential is also really impressive. [edit: got it backward as to temp vs holding capacity, doh.]
- laurencerowe 7y agoIt's the other way around, at lower temperatures the air can hold less water vapor. That's why you see condensation forming on cold things.
- cbanek 7y agoDoh, you're totally right. Although still, in the desert, there isn't much water in the air even if it's really hot. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/moisture-holding-capacity-air-d_281.html https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/moisture-holding-capacity...
- quickthrower2 7y agoEasy to get confused because humidity % tends to be higher at a lower temperature (morning dew for example).
- elevenoh 7y agoWhy is this?
- grzm 7y agoSay you have a given amount of water vapor in the air. Relative humidity as a percentage reflects the amount of water vapor in the air compared with the maximum amount of water vapor the air could hold at that temperature (and pressure). The amount of water vapor the air can hold depends on the temperature, with higher temperatures able to carry more water vapor. As the temperature goes down, the amount of water vapor stays the same while the amount the air can carry decreases, so the relative humidity goes up. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relative_humidity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relative_humidity
- newnewpdro 7y agoI believe it's simply a matter of colder air increasing in density so there's less space for the water vapor. When the air heats up, it expands and can hold more vapor in the increased volume.
- mnw21cam 7y agoThere's more water vapour in the air in the middle of the Sahara desert than there is in the air in the middle of Greenland while it's actually snowing.
- mdorazio 7y ago"Supported by a solar panel to power a fan and heater, which speed the cycles, the device produces up to 1.3 liters of water per kilogram of MOF per day from desert air." This is pretty good, but not yet amazing. It's more energy efficient than a compressor-based dehumidifier, but probably still less efficient than trucking water in from somewhere a few hundred miles away where it's plentiful. Either way, the big question to me is how well it will hold up over hundreds of cycles - there's no report here that I see on whether or not the MOF will also trap dust particles and other things that are likely to decrease efficiency over time.
- j_m_b 7y ago>but probably still less efficient than trucking water in from somewhere a few hundred miles away where it's plentiful I think the convenience and self-sufficiency factor might outweigh the raw efficiency considerations. Petrol and trucks aren't readily available to every villager. With this, there is no more worry about meeting the water truck and doing without. A big concern is what the lifespan of MOFs are. If it can be used for decades with minimal maintenance, it could be a game changer. If not, it would be back to the water truck!
- coderintherye 7y agoYou have to keep in mind that trucking in water isn't feasible in a lot of places. Sure, in developed nations there is a good road infrastructure, but it's rarer the further out you go. And it's usually the further out you go that water is more needed. Then, even if you do have a road, have to consider the water truck breaking down, the driver not showing up, etc. Even in developed nations, a water truck doesn't always work, for instance dirt roads with steep inclines and sharp turns.
- magduf 7y ago>Then, even if you do have a road, have to consider the water truck breaking down, the driver not showing up, etc. Or militants shooting the driver, hijacking the truck, etc.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago
- tangue 7y agoSeems logical to see that after all these Dune related posts on HN.
- liability 7y agoIt seems everybody wants to be a moisture farmer, but these "novel dehumidifier in the desert" schemes have thusfar always failed.
- Gustomaximus 7y agoSo did building flight machines for quite a while...
- liability 7y agoOn one hand, it's important to keep an open mind. On the other hand, when you're dealing with a subject that's been a scam magnet for decades, more than a little skepticism is warranted. Airplanes worked out, but 'dehumidifiers in the desert' is close to flying car territory. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moller_M400_Skycar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moller_M400_Skycar)
- elevenoh 7y ago>Airplanes worked out, but 'dehumidifiers in the desert' is close to flying car territory. why do you see that remaining the case in the coming couple decades?
- liability 7y agoBayesian reasoning? How many times do you touch the stove before you get cynical and expect hot stoves to hurt? Desiccant/absorption dehumidifiers are nothing new. I've been around the block enough times to recognize the hype cycle. The motivation of the inventor seems pure, and the first order analysis seems to make sense. Dehumidifiers do indeed pull water out of the air, so it seems plausible that this tech could one day be used to quench the thirst of people living in deserts. The moller skycar scam has gone on for decades in no small part due to how reasonable it sounds. We know machines can fly, so why not a road-worthy aircraft? On the surface it makes sense, so the scam finds plenty of marks. But the devil is in the details.
- 7y ago
- elevenoh 7y ago> Last year, he formed a company called Water Harvesting that this fall plans to release a microwave-size device able to provide up to 8 liters per day. The company promises a scaled-up version next year that will produce 22,500 liters per day, enough to supply a small village. “We’re making water mobile,” Yaghi says. “It’s like taking a wired phone and making a wireless phone.” Any ballpark estimates on the cost for a residential use unit? i.e. 200L-1000L/day Also, is it feasible for this to markedly effect downstream areas? i.e. If there's eastwardly wind flowing through Nevada where machines are extracting humidity at an extreme scale, how might the 30%+ humidity-requiring plants (i.e. that Jamaican Yerba) in Utah hold up? water wars 2.0, version: air. humidity credits & humidity sink surveillance with humidobfuscation 'consultants'.
- ac29 7y ago>Also, is it feasible for this to markedly effect downstream areas? > i.e. If there's eastwardly wind flowing through Nevada where machines are extracting humidity at an extreme scale, how might the 30%+ humidity-requiring plants (i.e. that Jamaican Yerba) in Utah hold up? There is a LOT of water in the air, 12,900 km3 [0]. As a comparison, the US uses 1.2 km3 of water per day (all uses combined.) [0] https://www.usgs.gov/special-topic/water-science-school/science/how-much-water-there-earth https://www.usgs.gov/special-topic/water-science-school/scie... [1] https://www.usgs.gov/special-topic/water-science-school/science/total-water-use-united-states https://www.usgs.gov/special-topic/water-science-school/scie... Interestingly in that second link - the largest category of water usage is for thermoelectric power generation, actually using more than irrigation. I wouldn't have guessed that, and as we start to rely less on burning things for power, that number should come significantly down.
- sbierwagen 7y ago>and as we start to rely less on burning things for power, that number should come significantly down. Nuclear plants also need cooling towers. Also note that heat exchangers can also use seawater, though with higher maintenance costs from biofouling.
- 7y ago
- aaron695 7y ago> Crystalline nets harvest water from desert air, turn carbon dioxide into liquid fuel It's like we are stacking crazy, onto crazy, onto crazy. You can't get water from air in deserts or places needing water of any practical, non military use - Here's a start - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EGTRX6pZSns https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EGTRX6pZSns We don't need to turn CO2 into fuel, just make fuel/energy without fossil fuels that's also used, and you're solving global warming in a amazing way. It's worth trillions, so it's always AMAZING to see some school kid or amateur scientist or researcher who just needs a little more research beat the multi nationals. It's a shame the multi nationals are to dumb to not hire school kids and these smart ideas people. Just shitty people who spend years studying at university then years working in the industry doing hard work to gradually make change.
- dimes 7y agoI want to hear more about the bit mentioned at the end: > At the meeting, Thomas Rayder, a graduate student at Boston College, reported building on the idea. He encapsulated a pair of enzymelike catalysts in a zirconium-based MOF to drive a series of reactions that convert gaseous CO2 to methanol, a liquid fuel. > When they were unprotected by the MOFs, Rayder found, the two catalysts didn’t produce any methanol because they were quickly deactivated, likely by reacting with each other. But safely ensconced in the MOFs, they could make methanol at temperatures and pressures far below those used in existing methanol plants, offering a potentially cheaper and greener way to make the fuel.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoThe paper probably isn't out yet. But there is quite some previous research on using MOFs to make fuel from CO2: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=MOF+co2+methanol&btnG= https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=MOF+... The challenge in that regard is always: turning CO2 to fuel takes at least as much chemical energy as was released from burning the fuel to CO2 in the first place. If you have that (presumably emissions-free) energy available, it's infinitely better to not burn the fuel in the first place and use the emissions-free energy for something else.
- qeternity 7y agoUnless you don’t have storage that is competitive with the energy density of carbon fuels.
- reissbaker 7y agoCould you put a nuclear power plant far away from human civilization, and then use nuclear power to convert excess atmospheric CO2 to liquid fuel, and ship the liquid back to civilization? Reduces the NIMBYism (and risk) of nuclear, while also reducing atmospheric CO2.
- icebraining 7y agoI'm not sure there's a place far away enough, while still relatively free from regular natural disasters (and human disasters, like war). It's not like high-voltage transmissions lines are very lossy, so if putting plants far away was enough to assuage the nuclear fears, we'd probably have them already.
- Mirioron 7y agoIt's a cool idea and all, but how do the calculations look for actually moving enough air through the "net"? One cubic meter of air at 100% humidity and 25C only holds 22g of water. For the 8 liters per day value it doesn't seem like an unreachable amount: 363 cubic meters of air need to pass through the filter. You probably need to more than double that number due to relative humidity not being at 100% and we probably won't get all the water in the air, but it seems reachable. On the other hand, 22500 liters per day seems quite crazy. I'm interested to see how they're going to tackle this.
- ggm 7y agoIt's a cool idea and all I see what you did there...
- kwhitefoot 7y agoAt 100% humidity and 20 C air holds 18 g H2O per cubic metre so to deliver 22 500 kg of water per day they must entirely dessicate 1.25e6 m3 of air. Air is about 4 kg per m3 so this means moving 5 000 tonne of air through the system. If the energy cost of moving the air is equivalent to lifting it is, say, two metre then the energy required to do this is 5e6 * 9.8 * 2 joule, about 2e9 J or 555 kWh so it would need something like 250 m2 of solar panels at 20 5 efficiency for 10 hours. At higher temperatures 100 % is more water but that only changes the yield by at most a factor of about three. Of course the humidity in the areas where this would be used is much lower so the amount of air to be processed is correspondingly higher. I'm not saying it can't work, or guaranteeing that I haven't slipped a decimal place somewhere but these figures suggest to me that it would be very expensive and might be outcompeted by piping in water from desalination plants.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- danbruc 7y agoNot to mention the energy you need to remove 14 MWh of energy from the water in order to condense 22,500 kg of it.
- mendelmaleh 7y agoI wonder what impact will this have on the desert itself
- briga 7y agoSeems like a good way to eliminate a lot of life in the desert. Presumably that air moisture gets cycled through the plants and animals in that environment. No water = no life. Mind you, humans have already drastically altered the deserts by rerouting rivers and building dams, so it wouldn't be the first time an environment has been changed by technology
- Haga 7y agoNestle will buy and sit on this.
- beautifulfreak 7y agoI wonder if the MOFs self assemble. I just started searching, but if any experts here know how they're made, please explain. I found an article that says the organic linkers are "ditopic or polytopic organic carboxylates (and other similar negatively charged molecules)," but MOFs are crystalline, so do they have to be baked? I get the impression that they're pretty easy to create, and can be designed to have affinity for any molecule. I really wonder if hydrogen storage will ever be solved. https://science.sciencemag.org/content/341/6149/1230444 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/341/6149/1230444
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bayindirh 7y agoSo, is this the first step of making windtraps[0] a reality? [0]: https://dune.fandom.com/wiki/Windtrap https://dune.fandom.com/wiki/Windtrap
- Swannie 7y agoYeah, my first thoughts too!
- pard68 7y agoWhat about he environmental impact of sucking the small amount of water present in the air out of it? I am sure some animal or plant depends on it. Don't get me wrong, I would let an animal die to save a human any day, but is this needed? Seems people having been making due in these climates for thousands of years. If this is as good as they claim this will only attract people to these locations instead of places which already have an abundance of water, since people generally find arid climates more comfortable than humid ones.
- thinkcontext 7y agoThe amount of air that can pass through a microwave size device is miniscule compared to the amount of air over a desert.
- mc32 7y agoHow much more effective are they versus low tech alternatives like: https://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/world-driest-desert-chile-harvests-water-fog-article-1.1304082 https://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/world-driest-desert-c...
- pojzon 7y agoLooks like the next "crowd funding scam" we see alot lately. Ill wait some time for someone to do a napkin math to debunk that as a valid product.
- TheGallopedHigh 7y agoIt’s published in a reputable journal, I’d say it’s more than a crowdfunding scam.
- imvetri 7y agoNow set a restriction on pollution or kill it so there is no trace. Else this man's water will be polluted. Thats how you pay respect, not by using more of your intellect.
- pvaldes 7y agoI would love to be wrong and stupid, but can't fall to think in another Theranos when I read this. Maybe is the style of the writing, dunno. Of course sucking all the water from the desert air would have a profound impact on its vegetation and fauna. Unless we are talking about coastal waters, importing trucks of water from areas with more vegetation and water excedent seems a more economic and sensible solution.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoprobably I'm paranoid but I worry this could be one of those kinds of inventions humans are good at that in small amounts are really beneficial but when scaled up start to have unintended harmful side effects only by then it's too late or too big to stop.
- SturgeonsLaw 7y agoI'm not sure it'll be scaled up to the point where it would affect things in a big way. We've had technology that can extract water from air with electricity for well over a hundred years (vapour compression refrigeration) and so far it hasn't caused any issues. The ocean is a huge source of water with a massive surface area which would constantly provide a source of humidity, and the lower vapour pressure caused by removing water from air in substantial amounts would encourage further evaporation. That said, local effects would be more pronounced than global effects.
- Ghostboccia94 7y agoWow
- ollie87 7y agoHeh it's the Lars Moisture Farm
- corodra 7y agoThere's plenty of people here who have done some fantastic math that throws red flags at this "I'm going to save the world" project. And each of you are beautiful people. What gets to me, these overly complicated dehumidifiers keep popping up every 6 months and make a big buzz. And each time, "Look at this brand new thing that no one has ever thought to do!" That's the part driving me crazy. It's the same investment sham, over and over. Slightly different method, but the same idea "We tested a dehumidifier in a place with high humidity. We collected water. Throw money at us." I give it props for at least being done in Arizona. But Arizona has higher humidity than a lot of the other water problem areas in the world. But I'm the asshole because I don't say "I'm curious how they're going to overcome the humidity problem." No, they're not going to solve it. They're going to disappear. Why? Because they took the money and ran. Like the hundreds of other assholes who keep coming up with these middle school "I know how to save the world" ideas.
- ravenstine 7y agoThere's a sucker born every minute, and we've done almost nothing to change that. The economy in its current form would probably crash if all the suckers disappeared.
- jenkinstrigger 7y agoI feel the same way about blockchain healthcare startups. If you put PHI on a blockchain it will get distributed, and one day cracked and shared. Modern cryptography is not a silver bullet that will last forever as-is. By then the founders (who we see these days on Techcrunch taking money for these sham projects) will be long gone.
- whamlastxmas 7y agoWhe modern cryptography is cracked 50+ years from now I'm not really going to care about people having my medical info. I'll be dead anyway
- magduf 7y ago>I give it props for at least being done in Arizona. But Arizona has higher humidity than a lot of the other water problem areas in the world. It does? Have you ever lived there? I'm not sure about actual humidity number comparisons between there and other deserts, but during the summer it's so dry that whenever I spilled water on the floor, I didn't even bother cleaning it up, because it would evaporate in seconds while I was watching it. Seriously, if you're trying to test a device like this within the US, I don't know any lower-humidity place to go than the Sonoran Desert of Arizona.
- underscoremark 7y agoThe thermodynamics of this rarely matches peoples' optimism about it. https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=thunderf00t+water+busted https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=thunderf00t+wat...