5 ms·
It's hard for me to get on board with the David vs. Goliath framing here. These people are running businesses - two of the three restauranteurs quoted even own
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
It's hard for me to get on board with the David vs. Goliath framing here. These people are running businesses - two of the three restauranteurs quoted even own a whole chain. If they want to cancel their food delivery service or demand better terms, more power to them, but it seems manipulative to try and make their pricing negotiations a social movement.
- danpalmer 7y ago> but it seems manipulative to try and make their pricing negotiations a social movement One restaurant leaving the platform will likely be much worse for that restaurant, but many leaving the scheme will be worse for the platform. No one restaurant has much bargaining power to demand better terms, but many together may be able to bargain better. It seems to me like this is exactly how they demand better terms and change the balance of power in the relationship. One could say that the platform putting such strain on the restaurants is manipulative because they know that it's very difficult for any restaurant to say no. I think it's just how the market works and think it's great that the restaurants are managing to push back somewhat.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoRight, but without the framing that the restaurants are the little guy standing up to the system, what you're describing is just monopoly behavior. (Imagine all the grocery stores getting together and saying "hey, potato farmers, we decided your prices need to go down".)
- crdoconnor 7y agoIt won't be a monopoly unless every restaurant signs up to their movement. It seems somewhat distasteful to argue that the pricing power of the rich, powerful party should not be countered by the weaker, poorer party improving their pricing power - especially on a moral basis.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cat199 7y ago> manipulative to try and make their pricing negotiations a social movement. Aren't the apps negotiating terms essentially a 'manipulative social movement' with a single app/VC backer/organizer (each)? why shouldn't the restaurant owners organize in order to increase their bargaining power to match?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIf they want to get together and form a group dedicated to the principle of "give us more money", that's cool (to the extent that Indian antitrust law allows it) and I have no objections. But they won't get much media traction that way. What they're doing instead is telling the media they've been cheated - that they deserve more money, and Zomato's acting unethically by giving them the advertised service for the agreed price. I'm not sure that's an honest way to look at the situation.
- stratelogical 7y agoIn the US, this - "They made a pact to pull out of Gold and other discount programs for a few days." is collusion and is illegal. If FTC allows restaurant owners (or any group of businesses) to create pacts like this against their suppliers or customers, next time, they will make similar pacts against you (the customer). "hey, what say, let's all make a pact together and increase the price of that dosa to $50?" In reality, some industries (most famously airlines) do this kind of collusion through winks and nods anyway and is bad for consumers (very good for the industry as a whole though).