6 ms·
The hilarious thing is that so many modern appliances are moving towards variable frequency drives and pile on even more waveform synthesis. Would be nice if t
by jcims 7y ago
The hilarious thing is that so many modern appliances are moving towards variable frequency drives and pile on even more waveform synthesis. Would be nice if they could just accept direct DC input.
- DoctorOetker 7y agothis is certainly true, but in the mean time there are still a lot of appliances in current operation, just rolled off the assembly line, and still coming off assembly lines that do not accept DC input. a lot of the material effort that was put in to them would be wasted if we replace them before they break down and if we keep using them, and keep opting for the single AC outlet inverter, we are wasting energy storage elements at volume of 0.01 Joule per Watt (think of the total PV energy production at least in residential solar [I would be uncomfortably surprised if commercial solar parks don't use this already, but then again that would require the grids to be split in an in-phase grid and out-of-phase grid, which would also be new knowledge for me...]) this also affects adoption, as less expensive storage-less inverters would decrease the time until the solar set-up pays itself back!
- kragen 7y agoLarge-scale power generation, including solar parks, is invariably three-phase, which has a more constant total absolute voltage than the two-phase system you're suggesting.
- DoctorOetker 7y ago... except I am suggesting a 4 phase system: 2 outlets with each the usual 2 phase AC! consider 4 phases in 90 degree turns (I wish HN had a button to render LaTeX or so when a reader wants it on demand): V_0 = V/2 sin(w t + 0 pi / 2) I_0 = I sin(w t + 0 pi / 2) V_1 = V/2 sin(w t + 1 pi / 2) I_1 = I sin(w t + 1 pi / 2) V_2 = V/2 sin(w t + 2 pi / 2) I_2 = I sin(w t + 2 pi / 2) V_3 = V/2 sin(w t + 3 pi / 2) I_3 = I sin(w t + 3 pi / 2) Now outlet "in" (in-phase to avoid clashing with "I") is across terminal 0 and 2, and outlet "qu" (quadrature) is across terminals 1 and 3, so the current and and voltages are: Vin = V/2 sin(w t + 0 pi / 2) - V/2 sin(w t + 2 pi / 2) = V/2 (sin(w t) - ( - sin(w t) ) ) = V/2 (2 sin( w t) ) = V sin(w t) Iin = I sin(w t) Vqu = V/2 sin(w t + 1 pi / 2) - V/2 sin(w t + 3 pi / 2) = V/2 (sin(w t + 1 pi / 2) - ( - sin(w t + 1 pi / 2) ) ) = V/2 (2 sin( w t + 1 pi / 2) ) = V sin(w t + 1 pi / 2) = V cos(w t) Iqu = I sin(w t + 1 pi / 2) = I cos(w t) and the powers flowing through the outlets are: Pin = Vin Iin = V I sin(w t) sin(w t) = V I sin^2(w t) Pqu = Vqu Iqu = V I cos(w t) cos(w t) = V I cos^2(w t) so the total power is Ptot = V I (sin^2(w t) + cos^2(w t)) = V I constant total power out, just like constant DC power into the inverter so no need for storage capacitors / inductors. QED It makes sense for solar parks to use 3 - phase because the back-bone power distribution of the grid is 3 phase. Do you know if the inverters from solar park panels to 3-phase use storage capacitors to convert to 3 phase? Do you know if any residential inverters are commercially available that split into 4 phase (2 AC outlets) like I describe, without unnecessary storage capacitors / inductors? according to: https://www.energycentral.com/c/cp/solar-photovoltaic-pv-power-europe-report-2018 https://www.energycentral.com/c/cp/solar-photovoltaic-pv-pow... >China now leads in total solar energy capacity followed by Europe with 114 GW. >Remarkably, 64 percent of solar systems in the EU are installed on rooftops, 26 percent of them residential, 18 percent commercial and 20 percent industrial. so residential solar in Europe is 26% of 114GW = 29.64 GW so a line frequency of 50Hz in europe implies single AC outlet inverters need an energy store of 0.01 Joule per Watt (in the US only 0.008333... J per W, because they have 60Hz) This amounts to 296.4 MJ (mega joule) of capacitor / inductor energy storage, elements whose raw materials must be sourced, must be built, must be bought by the consumer aand which are potential points of failure (what is not present can not break down). That could have been avoided. Which we still can avoid for future inverters, without replacing all our consumer electronics with DC consumer electronics.
- kragen 7y agoconstant total power out, just like constant DC power into the inverter so no need for storage capacitors / inductors. Whoa, you're right! Assuming a perfect power factor and perfect balancing on the loads, of course. Your four-phase scheme is very ingenious! I'm sorry I didn't appreciate this at first. But here's a thing I'm not understanding: yes, the powers sum to a constant. But the way an inverter produces real sinewave power (as opposed to modified square wave) is to PWM an H-bridge to ramp the voltage up and down, filtering it with an inductor (and usually a capacitor, and maybe more than one of each, but those are inessential). An inductor's time integral of voltage, and thus its average voltage drop (disregarding losses to winding resistance, hysteresis, eddy currents, etc.), must be zero to keep its current finite. So the output side of the inductor has the same average voltage as its input side. So, for example, a 25% PWM duty cycle produces 25% of the full-scale output voltage. However, in your four-phase scheme, when one of the phases (let's say in) is at ±25% output voltage and thus 6.25% peak output power, the other (qu) is at 93.75% output power and thus ±96.8% peak output voltage. This implies that, during that part of the wave, the active in MOSFET needs to be on 25% of the time, while the active qu MOSFET needs to be on 96.8% of the time. That means that between 18.7% and 25% of the time, both MOSFETs are on, so the two phases are actually shorted to each other (though not on the load side of the inductors). Is that okay? I guess it means that the current generated by the solar cells is being shared between the two phases during that time. Still, it makes me worry that an imbalance of loads or power factors between the four phases could produce some kind of hazardous condition. You say that the four-phase system doesn't need any energy-storage elements. To a first approximation you're right, again assuming well-balanced, power-factor-corrected loads on the phases: there's no need to store energy harvested close to the zero-crossing for, assuming 50 Hz, the average 5 milliseconds until it can be released close to the peak. 5 milliseconds is a long time, so these storage or filtering elements need to be quite large, 5 millijoules per watt (I think you dropped a factor of ½ in your calculation there, presumably calculating for a full half-cycle instead of a quarter cycle). By contrast, if you're PWMing a sine wave with a PWM frequency of 100 kHz --- a reasonable thing to do with modern IGBTs or power MOSFETs --- the filtering elements only need to store the energy for a maximum of 10 microseconds, and less if the PWM duty cycle is above the minimum. 10 microseconds is 10 microjoules per watt, 500 times smaller. So you only need 0.2% of the energy storage elements you need for what you're describing as typical current systems. (All that happens if your power factors or loads are imbalanced is that the inverter isn't drawing a consistent amount of current, so potentially the panels become less efficient.) A thing I'm not sure about is the junction capacitance of photovoltaic cells. A photovoltaic cell is a diode, reverse-biased in normal use, and reverse-biased diodes have a junction capacitance; we'd expect their enormous junctions to have significantly larger junction capacitance than the pF-scale capacitances we see in small-signal diodes. How large is the ½CV² = 50 nJ/microfarad (at V=0.316 V) energy-storage capacity of the PV panel itself? In particular, is it much larger or much smaller than the 5 mJ/W = 5 ms number you'd need for a single-phase inverter to not be wasteful? As for your questions about the current designs of power-generation inverters and residential inverters, no, I don't know about them. Typically, in both the US and here in Argentina, one side of a normal power outlet is "neutral" (see http://amasci.com/amateur/whygnd.html http://amasci.com/amateur/whygnd.html for the reasons around this) and violating that expectation might cause some problems --- notably, electric shocks from the outside of Edison-screw-type lightbulb sockets. However, I don't think you need to violate that expectation; you've described a four-phase system, but I think you get the same advantages with a two-phase system, with the phases in quadrature just as you proposed, but with the two phases sharing a neutral wire. The voltage from neutral ("ground") to the in terminal would be V sin(ωt), much as before, while the qu terminal would be at V sin(ωt + ½π), which is to say, V cos(ωt) --- both relative to the neutral wire. In effect you need only a single H-bridge with four MOSFETs (or IGBTs) and two inductors to produce the two voltages, controlled with a scheme slightly different from the usual H-bridge scheme, because it makes sense to have one side of the H-bridge turned on (in, say) while the other side is turned off.
- childintime 7y ago> Would be nice if they could just accept direct DC input. The thing is, lots of appliances do accept DC input (most electronics and probably all inverter-based stuff like washing machines and aircos). If only there was a standard for DC they could adhere to. Then they could add yet another adhesive to proudly proclaim the feat.
- swiley 7y agoYou still wouldn’t want to, especially if your house is fairly large. DC transmission line losses are actually pretty big over distances you might think are short.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoI'm not sure that's correct. My understanding is that for a given voltage the transmission losses are basically the same (actually possibly slightly better for DC since they don't suffer from the skin effect). The problem comes when you try to get the same power down a low voltage DC circuit which naturally requires high currents.
- michaelt 7y agoMy understanding is AC is safer at higher voltages than DC - and if you have a choice between 12v DC and 120v AC, the latter needs radically smaller cables. I haven't seen any truly high quality data on voltage safety, due to the obvious ethical issues with performing properly controlled experiments. It's possible the reason you see 120v in every home but 120v DC almost nowhere is inertia rather than safety.
- rrss 7y agoRegardless of relative safety, it's really easy to kill yourself with 120 vac (170 v peak). It's probably also easy to kill yourself with 120-170 vdc. AC in houses is an artifact of the difficulty (until recently) of stepping up/down voltage for DC.
- rb808 7y agoDC power would be great in most households. Nearly everything plugged into the walls are DC now, just vacuums, hair dryers, anything else?
- rrss 7y agoBut currently every appliance has it's own inverter, so running a fixed voltage add through the house would do little good since every DC appliance wants a different voltage.
- geggam 7y agoDC to DC is less lossy
- mikepurvis 7y agoAll those modern lightweight wall warts are switching DCDC converters anyway—they just have a rectifier and capacitor on the front end to get an approximate DC waveform to start from. That's also why modern power supplies are almost always universal for 240@50Hz or 120@60Hz. The frequency is irrelevant and the DCDC can adapt to a huge range of input voltages because the ratio isn't locked in by the wiring in a transformer. Modern power electronics are not just more flexible, smaller, and lighter, they're more efficient as well.
- kragen 7y agoVacuums and hair dryers invariably use universal motors that run the same on ac or dc. AC motors aren't that common in household appliances because their speed is set by the powerline frequency, which is slow. Typically you find them in microwave oven fans. They're more common in industrial equipment, but a lot of them there are being converted to run off VFDs, which of course internally run on dc.
- drcross 7y agoUSB-C Power Delivery has great potential in this regard.