47 ms·
That is actually what taxation-based solutions do. They make travel cost more, so fewer people do it. People aren't happy about it though, so promising to remo
by onion2k 7y ago
That is actually what taxation-based solutions do. They make travel cost more, so fewer people do it.
People aren't happy about it though, so promising to remove the taxes is a way to win votes at the next election. The incentive becomes a voter bargaining chip rather than an practical long term solution.
We need a solution that actually stops a majority of people wanting to fly so much, then removing the taxation isn't a way to win votes, and consequently it remains in place as disincentive to those who do want to fly.
- sokoloff 7y agoRather than chasing a goal of changing what luxury everyone wants, I’d favor chasing technical solutions like carbon neutral fuel. Take renewable energy and synthesize (non-fossil) jet fuel from atmospheric CO2, then burn that in conventional jets. We have all the key tech elements now except for scale. Tomorrow’s emissions (of CO2 anyway) are offset by today’s sequestering. If you tax CO2 emission (and credit sequestering), this might be financially competitive. (Obviously, if you tax it enough, it would be.) I see scaling up existing tech as far more possible/plausible than changing everyone’s desires.
- onion2k 7y agoTomorrow’s emissions (of CO2 anyway) are offset by today’s sequestering. Sequestering is useful but it tends to assume it doesn't matter where the CO2 is released so long as it's captured. There could be a big difference in the impact between CO2 released at ground level and CO2 released at 40,000 feet from a 747. NASA launched a satellite in 2014 to examine this exact issue - https://ocov2.jpl.nasa.gov/ https://ocov2.jpl.nasa.gov/
- sokoloff 7y agoAgreed that they could be different. Whether they are or aren't, I think it's a huge win to re-emit today's carbon tomorrow than 80 million year old carbon tomorrow, regardless of where it's emitted.
- amelius 7y ago> We need a solution that actually stops a majority of people wanting to fly so much Perhaps we could remove all comfort from airplanes and airports. Aluminum seats. No windows. No flight attendants. And a poster on the back of every seat saying "flying hurts the planet" (similar to the graphic warning labels on cigarettes in many countries).
- noobermin 7y agoOr we can offer a nicer alternative to flying, for example, actual trains like every other country.
- ekianjo 7y agoTrains are not practical for long distances and lines cost a huge amount of money to build thru existing land.
- noobermin 7y agoThen people will fly, or drive, and continue to contribute to GHG's. You either think this is a species ending emergency or you don't. Throughout Europe, you don't need to fly. It's not impossible by any stretch of the imagination.
- ekianjo 7y agoSomething that will happen progressively is not the definition of an emergency.
- grimjack00 7y agoPlease tell me where I can get a train from the US to Europe.
- noobermin 7y agoYou're not wrong. The point is to reduce flying, specifically for travel within the continent. There will be cases where people will still travel by airplane. A major reduction of use of any resource doesn't mean it need to go directly to zero.
- rjsw 7y ago> We need a solution that actually stops a majority of people wanting to fly so much The TSA seems to work quite well at doing that.
- darawk 7y ago> People aren't happy about it though, so promising to remove the taxes is a way to win votes at the next election. The incentive becomes a voter bargaining chip rather than an practical long term solution. Maybe, but that hasn't really been how most other taxes have worked. Cigarettes for instance are heavily taxed, but you don't see a lot of people running on reducing those taxes. > We need a solution that actually stops a majority of people wanting to fly so much, then removing the taxation isn't a way to win votes, and consequently it remains in place as disincentive to those who do want to fly. It seems to me that raising the price of travel will stop people wanting to fly so much. I think the problem with flight right now is it got just cheap enough that the upper-middle class can afford to do it quite frequently. And once that happens, it starts to permeate the culture in the way that you are now seeing. If you double the cost, it will start to fade back out again. Additionally, while leisure travel might be the most visible to a lot of people, there is a tremendous amount of business travel, and that probably makes up the majority of all air traffic. If I had to guess, i'd say 80% of that business travel is unnecessary. For instance, I work at a financial firm, and that firm employs analysts who study companies. Periodically these analysts fly out to go to "investor days" and do things like meet with company management. The marginal utility of them being physically in the same space as these people is probably quite close to zero. If the cost of flights were substantially increased, my guess is that they would stop this practice entirely, or curtail it quite a bit.
- throwaway287391 7y ago> Maybe, but that hasn't really been how most other taxes have worked. Cigarettes for instance are heavily taxed, but you don't see a lot of people running on reducing those taxes. At the risk of pointing out the obvious, <25% of Americans smoke cigarettes, while >75% of them have taken a flight at some point in their lives. If 75% smoked, I guarantee people would be running on eliminating cigarette taxes. I'm personally in favor of carbon taxes on flights but I'd imagine "under my administration, flying would be affordable for the middle class again" could be a pretty effective message.
- darawk 7y agoA much higher percentage of the population used to smoke cigarettes, before the taxes were levied: https://i2.wp.com/www.prb.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/usteensmoking.gif?w=570&crop=0%2C0px%2C100%2C333px&ssl=1 https://i2.wp.com/www.prb.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/ust...