4 ms·
There were plenty of small samples in the various Snowden powerpoint slides of stuff NSA incepted from the pipes. It seems a ton of mobile apps are sending inf
by dmix 7y ago
There were plenty of small samples in the various Snowden powerpoint slides of stuff NSA incepted from the pipes.
It seems a ton of mobile apps are sending information with identifiers over HTTP (the ID is a key part for them legally to pick it up and store it in a DB, forever). I notified one developer that was sending real-time GPS data + an email address highlighted in one of the PPT slide's (just a screenshot of a spreadsheet-like table) and never got a response from the developer. It was a small Canadian company with an app with a few million downloads, so I told Citizenlab about it (don't remember the name, had something to do with sports IIRC).
This is a chart of TLS traffic sent via Chrome and across Google:
https://transparencyreport.google.com/https/overview?hl=en https://transparencyreport.google.com/https/overview?hl=en
2014 = ~50%
2019 = 94% of traffic encrypted for Chrome users which is great.
Linux users currently have the lowest when using Chrome with 86%. I'm curious why this is.
Again mobile apps seem to be the biggest problem right now and there was no red HTTPS sign when they sent your sensitive information over cleartext:
> Mobile devices account for the vast majority of unencrypted end user traffic that originates from a given set of surveyed Google services. Some older devices cannot support modern encryption, standards, or protocols.
Maybe Google PlayStore should start punishing apps for not using HTTPS? Just like how Google is trying to make the internet faster by ranking performant/mobile friendly sites higher.
The app testers should put fake identifying information in the various app forms + automatically measure the outbound HTTP traffic for cleartext versions of the IDs.
- icelancer 7y ago>> Linux users currently have the lowest when using Chrome with 86%. I'm curious why the is. They probably browse quite a few old sites for documentation and tooling that are just not updated for HTTPS. A forum I post on to this day is still served over plain ole HTTP and they have no interest in changing.
- lousken 7y agoNot always true, if you message them directly and ask them nicely they'll switch to https. I've even messaged a few to switch from TLS 1.0 to 1.2 as it will be soon obsolete. About 80% of those I asked switched so I am calling it a success, especially compared to companies, I barely get a positive/any response there.
- ben_jones 7y agoIsn’t it more likely to be low grade android devices in poor countries with outdated government, banking, and education portals? I doubt kernel hackers make up a large enough demographic to skew the metrics...
- toomanybeersies 7y agoAndroid is separate from Linux in the report. Developers and tech people make up a significant (if not majority) share of Linux users. A lot of popular Linux and developer related pages are HTTP only. I did a quick Google search for some Linux related tasks, and found plenty of sites that don't use HTTPS. e.g. man7.org, linuxhowtos.org, linuxcommand.org The report does break down HTTPS traffic by country, and you're right that lower income countries do have a lower share of HTTPS traffic.
- dmix 7y agoAll the major wikis seem to be using HTTPS: Ubuntu, Fedora, Archlinux, Debian, Majaro, WineHQ, Gnome, KDE, CentOS, OpenSuse Wikis arent the problem!
- nxc18 7y agoI'm curious about stats for iOS, with its app transport security being enforced for store submissions. There are exceptions, but I certainly hope that Apple is verifying that those are actually necessary before allowing them. I'd love it if Apple took a step forward and warned periodically for http use (similar to how it periodically reminds you that apps have location permissions). Aside: I know at least for some orgs, ATS was helpful in convincing the older 'why isn't http good enough?' folks to finally get their act together. It may be shocking, but some people are quite resistant to typing in that extra 's'.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoThe app store itself doesn't encrypt downloads. A MITM can see which apps you download. https://www.wired.com/story/itunes-downloads-https-encryption/ https://www.wired.com/story/itunes-downloads-https-encryptio...
- wp381640 7y ago> Linux users currently have the lowest when using Chrome with 86%. I'm curious why this is. This doesn't surprise me when you consider that package management over HTTP is considered ok since it's separately authenticated and verified is a very common view That this view would also spread to not requiring HTTPS on documentation and other sites would also not be surprising The Linux world really needs to get it's act together with providing confidentiality via SSL/TLS
- raxxorrax 7y agoIf I develop web endpoints, I usually use http until I know the target domain and have acquired the needed certs. In a lot of cases this is one of the last steps in deployment.