5 ms·
This occurs at 2 million bar (pressure). From an engineering perspective, what does it take to contain such pressures, and would it be possible to make 'wire'
by londons_explore 7y ago
This occurs at 2 million bar (pressure).
From an engineering perspective, what does it take to contain such pressures, and would it be possible to make 'wire' consisting of a pressure-maintaining jacket surrounding the conductor?
Anyone want to do the maths? How much Kevlar are we talking...?
- aqme28 7y agoI believe these experiments are run in a diamond anvil (basically two diamonds pushed together onto a point). I'm skeptical that you could make a wire at this pressure with anything else -- even all the Kevlar in the world.
- priansh 7y agoFrom what I understand this is required to create the pressure, but a sufficiently strong material may be able to maintain the pressure, although I may be incorrect.
- peteradio 7y agoCould the pressure be fairly neutral with current=0 and the current itself create the pressure?
- annogram 7y agoYep the article itself mentions that the tests are done in the anvil
- Svoka 7y agoI think hope is that structures formed at such high pressures would be quasi-stable at atmospheric pressure. Such behavior is no unheard of. Such pressures is not something our materials can handle on macro scopes. Yet. But they are naturally occurring outside diamond anvils, like deep I gas giants, etc. It’s facing that such super high pressure chemistry may be more common than our low pressure one, because of the abandonment of raw materials in big planets.
- DoctorOetker 7y agowhile what you describe is imaginable, I don't think this is the case, as physicists would then speak of "superconductivity at temperature T for a material in phase X formed at pressure P", not "[ ... ] superconductivity at megabar" Perhaps you also think the claim states room temperature conductivity, and one only needs 260K temperature to form this phase? When the title is phrased like it is, it usually describes a point or region for the equation of state
- elcritch 7y agoGood point on the state. One good thing from such research results even if impractical itself can yield good targets for future research. If it’s a matter of geometry or crystal lattice spacing from the pressure an alternate formulation might be able to make a meta-stable structure that induces superconductance. Perhaps there’s another part of the state diagram that could be modified.
- Svoka 7y agoIndeed. It is important to pursue research even if there is no immediate benefit from it. In this case it is even touching on a gateway technology I would call marvellous. Stable high temperature superconductor material would change so much.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoWhat you need is a material with very high ultimate tensile strength. Carbon nanotubes might do it. Let's check. To compute the burst pressure of a pipe, we can use Barlow's formula: P_max = S * T /R where T is wall thickness, R is radius of the outside of the pipe, and S is ultimate tensile strength. Here T=R is the limit where the inside radius is zero. So the best case is P_max = S/1.0000001 Carbon nanotubes are the highest strength material, with a theoretical S=100 megabar. So not possible, sadly.
- MayeulC 7y agoBut 2 million bars = 2 Mbar. Surely 100 Mbar is enough, or did I miss something?
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoBah, I messed up the Pascal-bar conversion in the text. Carbon nanotubes have S = 100 GPa = 1 Mbar. Too late to edit now. Thanks for catching this.
- davidhyde 7y agoThanks for these numbers! Can such pressures be attained by other means rather than permanent confinement? For example, the near wall pressure of a collapsing ultrasound bubble reaches about 100 MPa. Three orders of magnitude too little but can this technology be used to achieve much higher pressures? If so I wonder if maintaining an aggregate of material at high pressure (a high pressure foam as it were) would be sufficient to achieve bulk superconductivity.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bArray 7y agoThis is far outside my wheel house, but... Surely it's the pressure differential that dictates the burst pressure? So if you had multiple sleeves, each decreasing in pressure as you get closer to the outside, this could be possible?
- namirez 7y agoYes, it's possible but it requires a thick jacket. the formula for a thin-shell cylindrical pressure vessel is \sigma = rp/t, where sigma is tensile strength of the material, p is pressure, r is radius, and t is wall thickness. For thick-shell jackets, the formula is slightly more complicated [1] but you get the idea. For Kevlar, max \sigma is 3.6GPa. So it's possible to maintain an internal pressure of 200GPa (2MBar), but the wall thickness must be much larger than the inside radius. [1] https://tge.readthedocs.io/en/latest/content/mechanical/thick_wall_pressure_vessel.html https://tge.readthedocs.io/en/latest/content/mechanical/thic...
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoWe quoted the same formula, but AFAIK the radius is the outside radius, right? So you cannot go above t/r = 1.0?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y agoWouldn't that mean that we can get a 1 mm radius almost-room-temperature superconductor with a wall only 55 mm thick? That seems like it would almost be practical.
- vlehto 7y agoIf you use the formula for thick walled cylindrical pressure vessel, you hit practical limit with outside diameter being twice the inside diameter. When this happens and you also take into account fatigue, usually about half of the yield strength of the material is usable. Your best bet is using thin shells of maranging steel wrapped around each other with thin layer of pressurized non-compressible fluid in between. The pressure control of the fluid is then absolutely critical. Alternate with 0,5mm thick fluid and 1mm thick steel sections. Rinse and repeat. The total thickness would not be all that crazy, but the pressure control would be incredibly expensive. EDIT: Did some calculations. Using roughly that system I described earlier you would only hit 10 GPa with roughly 50 meters thick piping system, that would have 75 alternating layers of pressurized oil. And each layer would have different pressure from all the other 74 layers of pressurized oil. So not possible. If you try using single thick wall in your cylinder, increasing the wall thickness means that your max stress gets closer to the internal pressure reading. So you would need material that can deal with 200 GPa of stress.