12 ms·
Entropic Gravity
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoWould like to draw the reader's attention to the criticism section: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_gravity#Criticism_and_experimental_tests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_gravity#Criticism_and... And a relevant xkcd: https://www.xkcd.com/1758/ https://www.xkcd.com/1758/
- ColanR 7y agoIt looks like the criticism boils down to, 'its really hard to test, so let's look at other theories for now'. Anything I missed?
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoThat interpretation of the criticism text is at best wishful thinking and at worst willful ignorance. Take off the rose colored glasses and read it again - there are several fundamental problems brought up.
- ColanR 7y agoI don't have any rose colored glasses. I read the section, found it tough to parse, stated what I understood, and asked for input. You have no reason to get rude.
- kgwgk 7y agoIf you think the only criticism is “it’s hard to test” it seems you have missed all the paragraphs in that section after the first one.
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoI think the data from voyager kind of sinks the whole thing... unless it's just not far enough away.... ...
- ncmncm 7y agoIt's not. According to the article it needs to get 12 to 13 times as far away (lg2(3000)).
- dilawar 7y agoIt's hard to tell apart physics and SciFi these days. Or may be it's just me.
- kingbirdy 7y agoI get the premise (gravity becomes linear at large distance), but I don't understand any of the terms used in the article, and their respective pages didn't do anything to help. Could someone give an ELI5 of entropic forces, anti de-Sitter space, and the rest of the opening paragraph?
- sklivvz1971 7y agoBasically, from the "derivation" in the page: 1) Two point-masses at a distance subtend a sphere with the radius equal to the distance 2) That sphere has a radius and a maximum capacity for holding information (in bits) depending on the area and the Planck constant 3) If we treat the bits as particles in a gas, we can derive the temperature of that gas based on the mass of one of the two point-masses and Einstein's equivalence 4) Assuming that the temperature is due to Unruh effect, we can calculate the acceleration that would cause it 5) Lo and behold, this is the same acceleration due to Newton's law of gravitation
- cryptonector 7y agoWithout endorsing it, and presenting it here without comment, http://physicsfromtheedge.blogspot.com/ http://physicsfromtheedge.blogspot.com/ has explanations of the theory preferred there (which I think can be labeled an entropic theory of inertia, or perhaps an information-theory-based theory of inertia) that might be an ELI5. The following is my attempt at casting McColloch's idea as an ELI5. McColloch's idea is that inertia is a result of asymmetric Unruh radiation pressure resulting from acceleration causing the Hubble horizion sphere around the accelerated body to not be symmetrically spherical. The idea is that when you accelerate, then the Hubble horizon "behind" you gets much closer to you, which then disallows some Unruh radiation behind you, thus causing there to be more Unruh radiation pressure in front of you. A more fundamental idea underlying this is that Unruh radiation emanating from the Hubble (and, indeed, any) horizon has every possible discrete wavelength that would fit between the horizon and the particle surrounded by that horizon, so as the distance to the horizon changes, so does the longest wavelength that could be visible -that could exist-. Now, as accelerations tend to zero, the idea is that the number of Unruh waves that are disallowed by the horizon behind is much smaller than at higher accelerations, and therefore inertia drops at lower accelerations, leading to gravity feeling stronger. I believe all entropic gravity/inertia theories are at least as controversial as dark matter theories or more so. McColloch's has the benefit of having a physical explanation that can be explained, if not to a 5-year old, then to a 10-year old. However, keep in mind that it could be a simple explanation that is just wrong.
- choeger 7y agoSo far my absolute layman understanding of dark matter is: "Well, the observations do not fit the theory. But if there was this huge amount of matter that we just cannot see, it would work out well." Whereas the alternative theories boil down to: "Well, we do not know how gravity works over there, so maybe it just works like this." Whereas the usual answer is: "No it cannot work like this, because [OBSERVATION/FORMAL ARGUMENT]." Did I get this (roughly) right? So from my perspective: Is there any prediction that would prove the existence of dark matter? Preferably something that could be invoked repeatedly?
- lvncelot 7y agoThere have been observations where the observed additional matter 'lagged behind' colliding galaxies, because dark matter only interacts gravitationally. If gravity itself were to behave differently, and the additional mass would always come from the observed matter, the dark matter should have been observed right where the colliding galaxies were, but since it didn't, it's a good indicator for the actual existence of gravitationally-interacting dark matter. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- knzhou 7y agoPhysicist here. It's roughly right, but it's kind of the picture we had 50 years ago. 50 years ago, dark matter and modified gravity were both reasonably equally good hypothesis. Then we got a treasure trove of astrophysical, galactic, and cosmological data from nearly a hundred distinct experiments. The results of _all_ of these experiments do not fit with the naive theory. And they each can be fit perfectly by adding in dark matter. But that's not important; the crucial point is that all of them can be _simultaneously_ fit perfectly by adding in the _same_ amount of dark matter. That's practically the definition of what a good scientific theory should do. Put in a single parameter and explain a hundred observed results. Meanwhile, modified gravity theories have fared extremely poorly -- they were originally designed specifically to fit galaxy rotation curves, and accordingly it is very difficult to massage them into fitting anything else. Usually if you get the rotation curves right, the astrophysics and cosmology come out disastrously wrong. You could probably get it right if you added a pile of ad hoc parameters, but that would be bad science. Unfortunately every discussion of this subject ever just hyperfocuses on the nearly 100 year old galaxy rotation curve observations... probably because it's easy to understand. > Is there any prediction that would prove the existence of dark matter? If dark matter interacts in a non-gravitational way, and is present near the Earth, then the smoking gun would be directly detecting it in an terrestrial experiment. (People also work on indirect detection, by looking at possible products of its decay or annihilation elsewhere in the galaxy, but this is less definite because such products could be made by something else.) Of course in all these cases, the specific kinds of predictions depend on what you think dark matter is made of. Unfortunately, its good scientific properties (i.e. fitting a lot of data with remarkably little input) also mean that we have very little to go on here. Practically any kind of new "stuff" that interacts weakly electromagnetically could work.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoGravity is weird. On the face of it, it seems to directly contradict the second law of thermodynamics, that overall entropy in the universe must increase. Entropy generally involves "spreading out." It eliminates gradients, it doesn't fill them up. It is weird that there is a way to increase overall entropy by bringing diffuse parts together. Despite the term "entropic gravity", I still don't understand how this or other versions of gravity do not violate the second law. Does anyone here?
- username90 7y agoEntropy is not just about position, but about temperature as well. Objects with higher temperature have higher entropy since you have more options with how velocities are set, hence entropy increases as things gets pulled together by gravity and energy gets spread out among the particles, at least with a classical interpretation of gravity.
- vanderZwan 7y ago> Objects with higher temperature have higher entropy That surely must be a bit too oversimplified, since that would imply that the beginning of the observable universe had more entropy than the current one (given that it was way hotter than the present)
- cgio 7y agoNot necessarily more. It could be the same.
- hvidgaard 7y agoWe know that early universe was low entropy - that is the explanation for the 2nd law of thermodynamics. That is known as the past hypothesis. The laws of physics dictate that the most likely state to come from and go to, is higher entropy because there are vastly more high entropy states than low. That directly violates the 2nd law, but is not unreasonable. Imagine 2 boxes of gas with 10 gas molecules in side A and B. They are separated by a wall with a single small hole in it. Every now and then a gas molecule with go from one side to the other, A to B, without one going the other way. We just went from a high entropy state to a lower entropy state in a closed system. But, coming from a high entropy state does not fit with the world we see, so we're pretty sure that the past hypothesis is true. One of the leading theories about the early universe and how it lead to the world we know today, is inflation. In that theory "stuff" is basically created out of nothing, meaning that the early universe was small, hot, and with (relatively) few particles in a specific configuration. The inflation and reheating dramatically increased the entropy. In other words - there was much less stuff, and it needed to be in a particular configuration to expand into the universe as we know it. That is low entropy. Note: I am not a theoretical physicist, so the above is my layman understanding of the topic.
- Beldin 7y agoFrom a comment deleted as i was writing this: > 3) this predicts missing masses in specific places Not quite... It predicts that either 1. the observations were incomplete (so, not enough data was fed into the model, hence the model's predictions are off), or 2. The model itself is wrong. Dark matter is about option 1, modified Newtonian dynamics is about option 2. And is great that both are being investigated. Imagine dark matter had been proposed in 1900: the deviations in Mercury's orbit (from Newton's model of gravity) could have been attributed to dark matter. No need for general relativity... Hence, both aspects should be researched: improving our observational capabilities to detect the oossible unknowns (including putting limits on their mass etc); and attempting new models that address these issues directly.
- renox 7y ago>Imagine dark matter had been proposed in 1900: the deviations in Mercury's orbit (from Newton's model of gravity) could have been attributed to dark matter. No need for general relativity... You should have a look [here](https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-200-year-old-mystery-of-mercurys-orbit-solved-1458642219 https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-200-year-old-mystery-of-mercurys...): TLDR: they looked for a 'Vulcain' planet which could cause Mercury's precession, but they didn't found one. And for the dark matter, you're right that both aspects should be researched, and both ARE researched but dark matter currently fits better the experimental data as already said. Of course until we know exactly what is dark matter, there will be room for other theories..
- Bootwizard 7y agoDoes this entropy of gravity theory lend itself to the possibility of modeling the expansion of the universe?
- Double_a_92 7y agoCan somebody explain to me how my "internal" imagination of gravity is wrong? For some reason I started imagining it as a "consequence" of different space densities. I.e. if some particle randomly moves a bit, it tends to automatically move towards where there is "more" space to be in. Imagine a piece of paper with many small dots on, symbolising places where a particle could be. If a particle randomly jumps to neighbouring dots wouldn't it eventually get trapped in areas where there are a lot of dots? (Also somehow the presence of particles increases the amount of dots?)
- chousuke 7y agoI think that intuition would imply that objects could randomly escape even black holes, even if the sequence of random jumps required would be very unlikely. Also it would mean that matter somehow affects the distribution of those dots. If the transition between dots is a quantum event, it sort of sounds like what imagined quantum gravity could look like, but I have no idea how you'd translate the thought experiment into actual maths.
- m4r35n357 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_gravity#Criticism_and_experimental_tests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_gravity#Criticism_and...
- yiyus 7y agoThe theory has its problems, some of them are serious problems. I attended a talk by Verlinde and he is well aware of them, but I liked his answer. He basically said that even if this theory was not a valid alternative to dark matter and was eventually proven wrong, some of their results looked very interesting and could develop into different theories, so he thought that it was worth to keep going further with this line of research. Nevertheless, you could feel that he still had some hope they could fix these problems in some way. But it looked to me like this feeling was more a personal desire than real scientific expectations.
- cryptonector 7y agoWhy would you like such an answer? If proven wrong, then it's wrong -- why continue studying it? A better answer is that dark matter is itself not free of problems either, so maybe some effort should be devoted to not-dark-matter theories. The entropic gravity theory space costs very little to fund by comparison to dark matter, so it's a reasonable thing to continue funding some of it for now.
- yiyus 7y ago> Why would you like such an answer? If proven wrong, then it's wrong -- why continue studying it? Because things are not black or white. It is never clear what we get from the advancement in physics theories, but many times we get more profit from the journey than from the final results. If Einstein equations can be derived from thermodynamic laws, this may have some very deep meaning, even if we still need dark matter to make cosmology models work. At this point, we have no perfect theory, you could say that all they have been proven wrong in some way or another, and yet, many of them are useful. I do not know enough about physics to know if this is the most practical way to spend funding, but from the personal viewpoint of Verlinde, I think it makes sense to keep working on his theory until a totally unsolvable problem is found. But this is only my impression after attending a layman talk, I am far from being expert.
- brnt 7y agoOT: I remember reading Verlinde's paper when he posted it to Arxiv (I was a student where he taught, and the fact he posted it went around like a wildfire). I was surprised how absolutely straightforward and simple that paper was, it was easy for me to grasp as a physics undergrad. I can recommend grabbing it now if you're interested, it's not much more complicated than some hard scifi books.
- PavlikPaja 7y agoI like to think of gravity as an anti entropic force. Logically the maximum entropy possible would be with each particle placed randomly with random momentum, but gravity makes that impossible on cosmic scales, as such a system would soon collapse because of gravity pulling the particles together. We could see gravity as an entropic limiting force, with entropy increasing statistical forces increasing entropy on the microscopic scale being contradicted by entropy limiting gravitational effects on the super-macrostopic scale.
- parasense 7y agoA very bad analogy is air pressure. Because air pressure is really not a force in of itself, it's just the presence of air at certain measures, but we observe the effects of air pressure as we move through the atmosphere. That drag coefficient changes depending on air pressure, and influences the aerodynamics..... you get the idea. In orbit around earth the drag of upper atmosphere is enough to decay orbits, even though it's so minute it's practically a near vacuum. That is something like gravity's inverse square law, or put another ways we have been obsessing on the measured effects of gravity, but not truely understanding.... like we used to not understand air pressure centuries ago. Anyways, it goes without saying air pressure emerges from lots of air concentrated in a space, just like gravity emerges from the presence of mass in a concentrated space. Gravity is the air of the universe.
- foxhop 7y agoSince it seems to attract, instead of repel, Gravity is like the _inverse_ air pressure of the universe.
- cainxinth 7y agoFry: Usually on the show, they came up with a complicated plan, then explained it with a simple analogy. Leela: Hmmm... If we can re-route engine power through the primary weapons and configure them to Melllvar's frequency, that should overload his electro-quantum structure. Bender: Like putting too much air in a balloon! Fry: Of course! It's all so simple!
- kgwgk 7y agoI wouldn't say that's a very bad analogy, considering that pressure is a good example of entropic force: https://johncarlosbaez.wordpress.com/2012/02/01/entropic-forces/ https://johncarlosbaez.wordpress.com/2012/02/01/entropic-for...
- wwarner 7y agoQuite happy to see entropic gravity discussed here. One thing I really like about EG is that it ought to be very testable. For example, there are a few observations of very diffuse galaxies that exhibit very little if any dark matter behavoir. These represent a direct challenge to EG, as gravity ought to emerge from any concentration of mass, whereas under DM we can say there simply aren't any DM particles there (of course why this is the case is still very important). Similarly, with EG there should be testable pedictions at smaller scales. Microscopically under EG, there should be no gravity ever between fundamental particles, no matter how massive, for the same reason that a single atom cannot be warm.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- r34 7y agoIn my opinion black holes emit space just like stars emit light. That is why galaxies are getting further and further from each other - because more and more space is emitted. Stars settle around black holes just like planet settle around stars - due to some balanced equilibrium. Space is a substance - I can't imagine it any different due to existence of gravitational waves. If something vibrates it's substantial.
- danielsju6 7y agoIn the wise words of my college physics professor, "Great, now use your grown-up words (formal logic)."
- r34 7y agoIn the wise words of many people, it's good to keep your inner child alive (and happy!). My logic skills are good enough to predict down-voting of my little story ;) Anyway, I think logically it is quite coherent.
- chousuke 7y agoThe problem with having "opinions" about reality is that reality doesn't care what your opinion is, at all. If you actually formalized your idea that black holes create space, I'm fairly certain you'd find out that it's not a good description of reality. It might make for some decent sci-fi, but don't confuse a cool story with understanding.
- r34 7y agoI started my opinion with "In my opinion", so it should be rather clear. I would rather claim that due to epistemological reasons we cannot "understand" reality. And i think that "The problem with having "opinions" about reality is that reality doesn't care what your opinion is, at all." - is a great example of opinion (in my opinion) :)
- 7y ago