7 ms·
Good. Not only does this ensure that the students enjoy privacy, monitoring children in school with surveillance systems could have come straight out of foucaul
by Barrin92 7y ago
Good. Not only does this ensure that the students enjoy privacy, monitoring children in school with surveillance systems could have come straight out of foucault's discipline and punish.
Maybe we should think about how we make schools spaces of freedom for our children rather than turning them into the next panopticon.
- Avamander 7y ago> Maybe we should think about how we make schools spaces of freedom for our children rather than turning them into the next panopticon. Especially considering that kids have poor judgement, tracking things in school that could be in any way used later against the individual is dangerous.
- variable11 7y agoAgreed, and I would also like to see punishment for the administrator, Jorgen Malm, who put this into place. At the very least, he should be removed from his job due to his obvious and public disregard for the privacy and safety of the children under his care. If I was on a jury, I would happily vote to put him in prison.
- moksly 7y agoI work in public digitalisation in Denmark, and I can’t think of a single reason of why you would ever even want this. What’s the use case? Automatic student registration? If it is, and I can certainly imagine some HR consultant going “weeeeeell we can squeeze five minutes of extra education in if we remove this teacher-student interaction of registration, that’s a gazillion hours of extra education a year!”. I know this is a strawman of my experience, but it’s frankly the only way it would happen at my place. Which would be crazy considering the primary focus of Schools in Scandinavia is to educate democratic citizens, and automating something as meaningful as presence registration is damaging to that focus because the “AI” won’t be able to have a conversation about the usefulness of attendance. So I absolutely agree with you. This is completely crazy, but what I really wonder is why no one asked “why?”.
- pkz 7y agoI would love to know more about how this discussion is in Denmark. Also how the Danish public sector is talking about GDPR/Cloud Act in relation to O365 and similar services.
- msla 7y ago> Also how the Danish public sector is talking about GDPR/Cloud Act in relation to O365 and similar services. "Microsoft says it. We believe it. That settles it." Really, there's no other option: Even if they magically got the ability to audit source code, the whole point of a cloud service is that the code can be changed at any point. Even if you extract a promise from Microsoft that the code won't be changed... well, see Figure 1. You're operating on trust that Microsoft will abide the agreement, and trust that you'll be able to magically tell if they don't.
- moksly 7y agoI’m not personally aware of any facial recognition projects for attendance. Never seen it debated either. We have thousands of schools though, so who knows. As far as the GDPR goes it actually didn’t have a huge technical impact on the public sector. We’ve had stricter local laws for decades, and have build our systems accordingly. We also don’t track you for advertising. So for us the GDPR has mostly been a bureaucratic change, and you’ll notice that’s also the majority of violations. It’s not that data aren’t protected, it’s that no one knows where the contract is, or that we haven’t documented elaborate procedures for whatever. 95% of the GDPR impact on the public sector had been law and legalisation. So the GDPR actually doesn’t impact O365 94 public cloud at all as long as you go to iso27000 certified vendors who provide privacy shield or whatever it’s called these days. That’s not to say that we aren’t debating public cloud. Because we are. This has more to do with national laws though, we have war-time contingency plans from the cold-war era. Like I said, we had much stricter policies before the GDPR was even a thing. The issue is that it makes public cloud illegal, but we can’t operate the most digitalised public sector in the world without public cloud. So far everyone is moving to AWS and Azure, pretending the flawed bureaucracy will eventually go away, but our politicians and national digitalisation agency has been refusing to give any meaningful heading, so who knows? At some point though, someone is going to ask if the privacy bureaucracy is really worth the money it’s costing. At our place you could hire 10 extra teachers a year, just to cover the bureaucratic processes that don’t actually increase security, because a contract or a nice incident plan isn’t actually going to stop anyone from hacking you.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bigiain 7y agoTo be fair "checking attendance" fundamentally erodes privacy. That's not the issue (at least as I see it). The big questions in my head include "Who's storing the biometric data? How are they securing it? Who has authorized access to it, and what processes and mechanisms are n place to ensure they only use it in authorized ways? What are authorized uses of the data? How is it ensured that authorized uses will ot be increased in scope? What process or mechanisms are in place to detect attempts or successful cases of some authorized 3rd party obtaining that data? What penalties are there for unauthorized use of the data and to whom will they be applied? What penalties are there for inadequately securing the data and to whom will those be applied? What processes mechanisms or policies are in place to ensure unauthorized access or failures to secure the data are detected and disclosed? How are those processes mechanisms or policies measured to ensure they're working?" Pretty much _anyone_ dealing with EU citizen's data should already have the answers to those (and related) questions written down. (If you do not, think about how sure you are that the answer to those " .. to whom will the penalty be applied?" questions will not be "Who's responsible for the data breach? Oh, that'd be Barrin from the dev team. Here, let me give you his full contact details and their HR file! BTW, they'll be fired and marched out before close of business, might be best if you call them on their personal cell phone."
- sverhagen 7y agoIs that a thing, developers being personally responsible for the company that was not in compliance and that they, at some point, worked for?
- fridek 7y agoI wouldn't be surprised if you could chase someone for gross negligence, if it was a result of, for example, consciously prioritising features over security, or "I know the rules but they are BS" thinking. You can do that with doctors, and they often make mistakes because the hospital overworks them, or simply allows bad behaviours to continue.
- pkz 7y agoTo be fair, they did the following: - Data and analysis was done at a server in the class room (locked in a cabinet) - All parents signed a consent form before the trial started. - All data was erased after the trial ended. The Swedish DPA decided that: 1. Consent is not valid of there is a power difference between the subject and the requester. 2. They should have documented a PIA (Privacy impact assessment). 3. They should have contacted the DPA before starting the trial.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Iv 7y agoSchool is the most authoritarian experience one typically experiences in a democracy. Here is a place where a strict hierarchy is enforced, through means of parental and peer pressure, anxiety over your future. Your schedule is planned by the minute, even peeing requires an authorization. Chatting is banned except on very limited time spans. The fact that we have kept a part of middle-age inside our modern societies keeps fascinating and frightening me.
- lwkl 7y agoSince I was a teenager I never asked to pee or drink in school. I just got up and told them: „I’m going to pee now.“ I see these things as my basic human rights. And nobody should accept having them restricted. In the country where I live the school has the authority by law to be more restrictive and enforce their own rules. Which I see as necessary to some point. But I think we should teach kids and teenagers to make decisions on their own and take responsibility for their actions. And not just enforce arbitrary rules.
- cbluth 7y agoYes, "discovering" that path is difficult when you're forced-fit into school at such a young and impressionable age.
- noir_lord 7y agoWhen I was 9 I had an absolutely awful teacher (to the extent she'd refuse kids using the bathroom to the point where they'd pee themselves (it was the 80's)), I told my mum about it and her response was "If you need to go ask, if she says no, go anyway and I'll deal with the fallout". It was my first lesson in dealing with unjust authority and that most authority relies on the principle that most people under it will do as they say most of the time. A useful lesson and after that I saw asking to use the bathroom as a courtesy because I was going either way.
- m0xte 7y agoI was one of the kids who peed himself in class due to one of those teachers. I had asked three times to go. Ripe age of of 12 no less. It destroyed my fear of and respect for arbitrary authority instantly so I look back on it as a good thing today. I realised that rather than my peers turning on me on a shame basis they turned on the teacher because it was going to be them next. It also positioned me well for dealing with the somewhat backwards ideals in my own childrens’ school.