3 ms·
The issue with the GDPR as worded and this ruling is that they remove the possibility of informed individual decisions. In this case it seems that all involved
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
The issue with the GDPR as worded and this ruling is that they remove the possibility of informed individual decisions.
In this case it seems that all involved were informed and OK with it but that did not matter.
I would also think that knowing where pupils are at all times is quite a legitimate aim for a school.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ziddoap 7y agoDo you have any evidence that all parties provided informed consent? i.e. The consent form detailed out what could happen in the (somewhat likely) event the data is breached and how the data may be used? What other parties have access to the information and how that information is stored? How the information is transmitted? And they understood it all, with the attached implications? Considering the only words the person who oversees both high schools had to say on record was that the technology is "fairly safe", I am somewhat doubting that the parents had a fully formed view of what the potential downfalls of the program are if/when it is breached or misused, or even malfunctions. I think when we are dealing with advanced tech such as facial recognition it is analogous to the informed consent issues doctors face. How can someone possibly obtain informed consent from non-experts over something that requires years of schooling to understand?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThis is going over the top. It was just about using facial recognition in a school, not about having brain implants in children... Schools already have pictures and detailed personal details of all pupils. This new technology can have real benefits. For example it could be used to locate a pupil that does not show up in class when they should, or to trigger an alert if a pupil leaves school when not expected to or when someone unknown is detected. To me the law should protect but not prevent useful applications that people agree to, and I think that this specific case shows that, as they stand, the GDPR can be over-restrictive.
- ziddoap 7y agoAre you arguing that informed consent is over the top and restrictive? That's... Bold.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoPlease refrain from misrepresenting others' comments, and I hope there can be a mature discussion instead of this sort of attack.
- ziddoap 7y agoIf I misrepresented your comment, apologies. I thought since I put: "Do you have any evidence that all parties provided informed consent?" And you said "This is going over the top." That you were replying that it is over the top. I'd be happy if you could clarify what you meant.
- rndgermandude 7y agoEverybody was informed and OK.... Except for the students they tracked, nobody asked them. Sure, they are still minors, and it's up to the parents to decide what goes and what not. But by law the parents in Sweden (and a lot of other places around the world) have an obligation to act in the best interest of their children to their best ability. I'd argue exposing their children to mass surveillance in school and face recognition was not in the best interest of the child. I'd go further and argue that the parents violated the GDPR themselves, by mishandling or allowing a third party to mishandle with parental consent the data of their kids. This was at least grossly negligent. If I was making the decisions about fines, I'd have fine the parents a minor fine, too, just enough to make them (and other parents reading about it) think about such things next time somebody comes around with an indecent proposal to collect their kids data. Also, we place, in my opinion rightfully so, certain restrictions on individual choice and decisions. For instance, you cannot kill your neighbor for your pleasure even if they gave you informed consent. These restrictions are of course not set in stone, as e.g. the assisted suicide discussions show, or gay marriage. There are certain areas that seem benign at first, like e.g. health care providers getting you to wear "health" monitoring devices for a reduction in premiums... until the reductions become so severe that you cannot really opt out anymore, if any health care provider will even take you after you opt out. Or "voluntary" drug tests to get a job, or when already employed. Everybody knows these dejure voluntary tests are defacto mandatory. I'd argue that mass surveillance and even biometric processing in schools falls in this category too; looks somewhat benign in the beginning, until it isn't.
- a1369209993 7y ago> Everybody was informed and OK.... Except It's not clear (and honestly, not likely) that that was true either, but if it was: > I'd have fine the parents a minor fine, too This is child abuse, and should be prosecuted accordingly, including jail time.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThis is turning into a religious war, with facial recognition being branded absolutely evil. As I already wrote, I think that being able to locate pupils at all times is a legitimate concern for schools, and parents. Certainly schools already work hard to achieve this especially with younger children. I think facial recognition can bring real benefits without many drawbacks if used properly. An effective blanked ban is not productive or based on reason.
- jdietrich 7y agoRecital 38: "Children merit specific protection with regard to their personal data, as they may be less aware of the risks, consequences and safeguards concerned and their rights in relation to the processing of personal data." Recital 43: "In order to ensure that consent is freely given, consent should not provide a valid legal ground for the processing of personal data in a specific case where there is a clear imbalance between the data subject and the controller, in particular where the controller is a public authority and it is therefore unlikely that consent was freely given in all the circumstances of that specific situation." A school cannot rely on consent as a lawful basis for processing the personal data of pupils. https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-38/ https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-38/ https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-43/ https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-43/
- gwright 7y agoThank you for surfacing this language. In the more general case, I was under the impression that informed consent was sufficient to authorize a data controller to collect/process private information and so the ruling didn't make sense to me. I'm using "informed consent" here as a short hand for all the applicable GDPR requirements on consent (reasonable language, etc). It isn't clear to me from this language in Recital 43 though how a data controller with an "imbalance" relative to the data subject could easily get clarity on any particular use case. It also seems strange that in this case there was deemed an imbalance between the schools and the parents (I'm assuming here that parents are indeed authorized to give consent in their role as parent/guardian). If parents are in an imbalanced situation regarding school attendance, then pretty much all government relationships are imbalanced. If the school/parent relationship is considered imbalanced and the imbalance language isn't specific to a government data controller, then it would appear that every data controller (government entity or not) is in danger of having their relationship deemed "imbalanced" and the data collection subject to analysis by the data authority at any time. It seems like this ruling destroys the clarity of "consent" and replaces it with "(consent AND balanced relationship) OR (imbalanced relationship AND legally adequate reason AND prior approval from regulator AND consent)"
- jdietrich 7y ago
- ganzuul 7y ago> I would also think that knowing where pupils are at all times is quite a legitimate aim for a school. For a prison, it is. A school's purpose is to educate.
- xxs 7y agoA school performing face recognition is a joke when it comes to privacy. Coming from billions dollar business, storing document copies, required by law for certain type for contracts, securely is a HUGE burden and liability (aside the permission management, etc.) alongside the necessary audits - both internal and external. Having footage and training data on kids would be a resounding 'no' from me (both as a parent and engineer). Schools would never, ever have enough resources do to it properly. In this particular instance they need one bit of info: "present" and that should be it all. The fine is well justified, considering someone won a contract to install the system without any oversight from the school.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoFacial recognition can raise privacy concerns but it does not necessarily erode privacy. Schools have a duty to provide a safe environment, including keeping track of who's on school premises, where pupils are, and whether pupils are let to leave premises when they are not expected to. Obviously the younger the pupils the stronger those duties. For example, facial recognition could tell the system that you are in the library but doing so would not erode your privacy in the library at all.
- xxs 7y agowell, until the technology is trusted "enough", there should be audit logs - pretty much destroying privacy. Again, with the current technology and literacy level, I'd not trust a school to be able to afford to employ proper security policies. It's already hard for businesses that actually spend substantial effort and resources.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoAudit log do not destroy privacy for the exact reason I have explained in my previous comment.
- pbhjpbhj 7y ago>knowing where pupils are at all times is quite a legitimate aim for a school // Does continual surveillance improve educational outcomes such as life-fulfillment and academic achievement? Why is it a legitimate _aim_ for a school?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoI'm sure you know that schools have an extensive duty of care over the minors they have on their premises.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoThere's a difference betwwen "X is in attendance" and "X spent 12.3 s at the water fountain in the company of Z, P, R" though.