3 ms·
Pretty nice. It looked weird when Seth was playing it, but I realized that's because the keys that you would normally close with your right hand did not seal.
by jrockway 16y ago
Pretty nice. It looked weird when Seth was playing it, but I realized that's because the keys that you would normally close with your right hand did not seal. So he was restricted to the three or so notes that you can play with your left hand.
Also, the article says: the flute itself sounds beautiful acoustically when played by player Seth Hunter.
Personally, I think it sounds like those plastic recorders that you got in 3rd grade music class. But that's not the point; it shows that 3d printing can produce something that used to take a skilled craftsperson days.
This will be great for applications like elementary school band, though, because kids can lose interest quickly, and a $5 mass-produced instrument is perfect for learning. Once you know you are going to stick with it, then you can pay the $2000 for the real thing :)
(And yes, I do play the flute!)
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>because kids can lose interest quickly, and a $5 mass-produced instrument is perfect for learning It took 15 hours to print and had to be manually cleaned. Sure the process will improve but then how much does it currently cost to make a basic flute? The cheapest retail I found after a very brief search was $70, http://amzn.to/dQGdzI http://amzn.to/dQGdzI (aff link); so I'm going to guess $35 direct manufacture costs. Mind you it gets very poor reviews whilst $100 gets you a Hisonic one with pretty good reviews (http://amzn.to/eV9a6q http://amzn.to/eV9a6q). The only price I found was $50,000 USD for the printer - even if it ran everyday for 5 years without breaking or needing materials or maintenance that's $20 or so of your $5. It is awesome though how it prints composite pieces and the way the removable scaffold materials are used, love the concept of these things.
- jrockway 16y agoIt's not $5 today. It will be $5 tomorrow.
- jonah 16y agoI don't think 3D printers will ever beat molding for mass production. Where they win is short-run and prototyping.
- kragen 16y agoYou're probably right, but keep in mind that mass production imposes some costs of its own. There are the up-front costs you allude to when you say "short-run" --- even if you're cutting your mold from aluminum, that's an expensive way to make five instances --- but there are also costs associated with the "mass" nature of the production. First, mass production must be geographically centralized. This means you have shipping costs. For fragile or bulky objects, the shipping cost can sometimes exceed the material cost. Second, mass production involves inventory at every stage of the supply chain, although you can cut inventory down quite a lot from what we used to do 60 years ago. Maintaining inventory is expensive. So it's possible that 3-D printers will beat molding for mass production. It's just not likely in the foreseeable future. Molecular nanotechnology will, of course, make 3-D printers beat molding.
- jacquesm 16y ago> Molecular nanotechnology will, of course, make 3-D printers beat molding. It will? Fiction and facts don't mix in the same discussion, molecular nanotechnology if it will ever be a reality will possibly make 3-D printers beat molding. Injection molding is very fast, extremely cheap and can be used for very large runs. We do not know any of those parameters for nanotech yet assuming that we can can actually implement it.
- kragen 16y agoWell, I didn't mean to imply that it was a certainty that MNT would exist, and of course it's possible for it to exist but only in some limited form, with limits we can't easily predict today. So you are correct: everything about it is uncertain. On the other hand, it seems very likely that at some point we'll have flexibly programmable universal assemblers capable of relatively rapid self-reproduction (say, less than three months) and of making materials at least as strong as the cheap thermoplastics we use in injection molding out of relatively common elements. There are a lot of different avenues that could get us to that goal. The intrinsic cost of making something consists, as I understand it, of amortized capital costs, marginal raw material costs, marginal energy costs, and marginal labor. Self-reproducing assemblers eliminate the physical part of the capital costs; automated manufacturing of any kind eliminates marginal labor, leaving only the labor component of the capital costs; and the raw material and energy costs probably will be about the same for artificial molecular assemblers as they are for natural ones such as potatoes. The labor component of the capital cost is simply the R&D required to automate the making of the thing. It seems very likely to me that this will be similar to what we do today for injection molding, a guy building 3-D models in a CAD/CAM system, but with much less in the way of concerns about taper and the like. I recognize that you know a great deal more about modern manufacturing than I do, so if I am wrong about something, please do not hesitate to correct me.
- nickpinkston 16y agoIt costs about $1.2/cc, if you own the machine. A tube of: 40cm length, 3cm OD 2.5cm ID - ~80cc, $96 - which is the absolute bare minimum this would probably cost to 3D print. Also - I'd bet the yield would be low - meaning you'd need to print a few times, and it'd break pretty quickly. The Objet rubber is not functional for prolonged use. Still though - awesome project!
- relix 16y agoOff-topic: I played flute for 7 years, stopped when I was 17, and I had no idea they were this cheap! We always had to rent or borrow one because we couldn't afford to buy one at home, but with these prices, I might just buy one and pick it up again. After 8 years I won't remember how to play it, but for $100 I'm willing to risk trying to get "it" back on my own. Thanks for renewing my interest in an old friend of mine
- jamii 16y agoIt may not be able to compete with traditional instruments but you could fill a shop with exciting designs like the multi-pipe trumpet and quickly cover the cost of the machine.
- scotth 16y agoBy my count, you're able to play 15 or 16 notes with the left hand alone on the flute (without considering alternative fingerings), ignoring the use of the right hand's pinky finger for all but one of them (fourth octave B). I wasn't particularly impressed by how it sounded either. But man is it cool.