4 ms·
Forgive me a great deal of cynicism here. I suspect that a more accurate statement is "he learned that it works well for him to argue that every plane crash ca
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Forgive me a great deal of cynicism here. I suspect that a more accurate statement is "he learned that it works well for him to argue that every plane crash can be traced back to a single, simple cause."
We don't ask lawyers to do surgery. We don't ask them to design bridges. And we don't ask them to do root cause analysis. We leave all of those things to those who actually know what they're doing in those areas.
- SilasX 7y agoYeah, but the work of lawyers has often forced industries to do things differently, even when the best science says they shouldn't do it that way. For example, lawsuits over botched baby deliveries that argued "you should have c[aesarean]-sectioned" resulted in extreme overuse of the procedure in the US, with higher resultant risks. So ... I wish it worked like you described.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI suspect the reasons for increased c-sections are manifold. When we medicalise pregnancy and childbirth, then fill hospitals with profit driven policy, and surgeons who fear malpractice accusations, is it any wonder c-sections can become over used? Fear of malpractice alone can’t explain it all, as it some other lawyer could demonstrate c-sections are over used and lead to complications.
- jfnixon 7y agoI don't think the parent is arguing malpractice fear explains it all. But clearly, that fear is a significant element in many decisions.
- amelius 7y agoYou don't need to be able to analyze causes in order to count them.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoNo. But I've (as an amateur) looked at crash investigation reports, and they usually state more than one cause.
- atoav 7y agoNo, but if you want to prevent future incidents, it usually helps to have a more systemic view of failure. E.g. questions like: “what kind of management lead to decisions that made such misbehaviour possible?” are usually completely uninteresting for a lawyer, as they either play a legal role or not. In real life a incident may be the emergent behaviour enabled by complex circumstances and a certain culture, all culminating in one crystalized point of failure. Think of causal chains: Managment pressures engineers and fires experienced older engineers, engineers are clearly not up to task, do something. Qualitt control might catch it but is circumvented by other managers who fake documents. The thing is not up to speck but wouldn’t have failed if the pilots... etc. This is what I mean by systemic emergent behaviour. All of these things were wrong or wreckless, but pinning it to one cause isn’t doing reality a favour here.
- philjohn 7y agoAnd that's all well and good ... but his role isn't about preventing future incidents, it's seeking restitution for the victims and their families, nothing more, nothing less. It is the job of regulators to figure out how to prevent future incidents, and it seems that the EASA will be taking the hardline lead on that as there seems to be a general mistrust of the FAA this side of the pond.
- klingonopera 7y agoWe don't ask lawyers to do surgery No, but when they're in a court debating about e.g. doctor's negligence, we do expect them to have a rudimentary understanding of what's going on.
- vkou 7y agoGenerally, they find, and pay for an expert to argue whatever point they want. The great thing is, if you pay enough, you'll find an expert being willing to argue anything you want.
- klingonopera 7y agoYes, but that works for both parties, though. The expert more capable of conveying their message will be the one who gets the most credibility, and this often (though unfortunately not always) aligns with the expert telling the factual truth.
- Gibbon1 7y agoFriend of mine pointed out. Scientific facts aren't the same animal as legal facts. And I'll add not the same as political and engineering facts either. Root cause analysis facts are social and engineering facts.
- markdown 7y ago> learned that every plane crash can be traced back to a single, simple cause. That's silly, but if I were playing that game, I'd say the single, simple cause was a failure of Boeing and the CIA to keep abreast of A320new development. Boeing were caught flat-footed by the launch of he A320neo and, facing a loss of potentially thousands of sales, were forced to quickly develop and release a modified 737 rather than create a new plane altogether. Corporate espionage would have prevented all this.
- distances 7y ago> Corporate espionage would have prevented all this. I believe Boeing knew exactly what was going on with Airbus. US does corporate espionage to favor domestic companies, and creating a new plane is such a big project that there's no way to miss that.
- graphicsRat 7y ago> US does corporate espionage to favor domestic companies, and creating a new plane is such a big project that there's no way to miss that. Pardon my ignorance but I thought the Chinese government was the one doing this sort of thing. Surely the US government does not engage in espionage on behalf of it's companies