4 ms·
I've been living with hurricanes my entire life, and have been through many (the largest was Hugo in '89). The problem with all these cones is when they extend
by matwood 7y ago
I've been living with hurricanes my entire life, and have been through many (the largest was Hugo in '89). The problem with all these cones is when they extend them beyond 72 hours. At that point, if we used your suggestion, the entire east coast could be in the cone. That means either no one pays attention, or everyone evacuates and next time ignores the warnings.
What officials (and the news) need to do is tell everyone to hold tight until 3 days out, and then start making decisions.
People also need to understand their personal situation. If an area floods during a summer rain storm or simply when the tide is high, then they need to be extra cautious.
The other problem is that many people simply have no idea what it's like to go through a hurricane. The mass migration to the coast means large parts of the population do not have the experience to make informed decisions. This goes back that officials and the news need to do a better job at informing.
My personal rule to consider evacuating is a cat 4+ predicted direct hit or just south and it is less than 48 hours out.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ukyrgf 7y agoI feel like the news and government response has been to very strongly err on the side of caution lately. The moment the path was updated to move to a direct hit of north Florida yesterday, grocery stores and gas stations were flooded with people preparing a week in advance. 10 or 15 years ago you'd hear a lot of "well a storm hasn't hit here in 100 years" in the region, but nobody fucks around like that anymore.
- lonelappde 7y agoEvacuation should be done relatively late/certain. Preparation should be done weeks to months in advance. Frankly I wish stores would have random "everything costs 2x" days all the time to teach people the importance of stocking up on necessities.
- jnbiche 7y ago> My personal rule to consider evacuating is a cat 4+ As you know well having lived through Hugo, the S/S category pertains to the wind speed. However, it's the flooding and storm surge, not the wind, that are by far the most deadly features of a hurricane. I'd be much more wary of a big, slow moving cat 2 arriving right at high tide and full moon than I would be a small, fast moving cat 4 arriving at low tide and a new moon, unless I have some particular reason to fear the wind and not the water (eg I'm in a mobile home on high ground). Source: lived through or evacuated for multiple hurricanes.
- mnw21cam 7y agoNote for the record that large tides (spring tides) are associated with full moon and new moon. Smaller tides (neap tides) are associated with half moons.
- jnbiche 7y agoYou're absolutely right. I've been living away from the coast for too long now (~15 years).
- matwood 7y agoAbsolutely agree on the flooding angle being the biggest danger. It's why I mentioned that people need to be aware of their personal situation.