9 ms·
This quote: "Ecologically, these Archaic hunters and gatherers had moved one entire link down the food chain, thereby eliminating the approximately 90-percent l
by chrisco255 7y ago
This quote: "Ecologically, these Archaic hunters and gatherers had moved one entire link down the food chain, thereby eliminating the approximately 90-percent loss in food value that occurs when one feeds on an animal that is a plant-eater."
This is just completely false. All meat consumed is bioavailable protein and nutrients. Even more so when it's cooked. Plants have reduced bioavailability due to high oxalate, phytic acid, and lectins.
Humans would have never evolved the ability to eat meat if it didn't confer a natural advantage over foragers.
- solotronics 7y agoAlso, animals can digest many forms of plant that are useless as human food such as plains grasses and tree leaves. Vegetarianism is elitist in that many people on earth cannot afford to foregoe any availible source of protein and food, there are starving people already and telling someone in Africa they shouldn't eat a chicken that forages near their house is pretty narrow minded. I tend to eat vegetarian on my own but this is only possible because I am privileged in my income.
- bilbo0s 7y agoI agree with everything you said vis-a-vis elitism. Having mentioned that, I just wanted to point out that for the poor in certain parts of Africa, meat is pretty hard to come by. There are a lot of people on this planet who have to eat plants or fish not for any perceived health benefit, but literally because it is the only food available to their families. It's certainly gotten much better in Africa, when I was younger there were certain places where there was no food, and you'd bring in aid that was basically all plant and legume based. Over time, I came to realize this practice probably did more harm than good but that's orthogonal to the point. Point is, there are a lot of non-elite vegetarians. Lots of people who eat such a diet simply to survive.
- HNcantBtrustd 7y agoVegetarian is lower cost and better for the environment. Protein per calorie doesn't seem comparable.
- liotier 7y ago> Vegetarian is lower cost and better for the environment Depends on the biotope. In fertile European fields, less meat is much more efficient. In the arctic steppe or in the Sahel, animals are the more efficient way to extract calories from the land (though it doesn't scale to high population densities...)
- ptah 7y ago> doesn't scale to high population densities that's where we are right now so anything that doesn't scale is practically irrelevant
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoGiven the climate of our world, we have a certain amount of arctic tundra etc. The best way to extract nourishment from that is foraging by e.g. reindeer. That holds irrespective of the population density. Also, reindeer is one of the most ethical ways of modern husbandry. Animals live out in the wild, supported by humans e.g. adding feed when there is little to eat, protecting them from carnivores etc, and then they are slaughtered in a sustainable way after living close to how they do in their natural state.
- ptah 7y agothat is a very long chain of ifs, any of which can evaluate to false EDIT: there is also no precedent for what you propose and if we go by the partial match of grass-fed beef, the yield will be so small compared to the population as to be pointless
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoThere's almost 2 million domesticated reindeer worldwide, compared to 1.4 billion cattle, so it's tiny for sure. But in most of those regions, it's regulated such that only first people/native inhabitants/etc. are legally allowed to work reindeer.
- spodek 7y agoWhat does being vegetarian have to do with telling other people what they should or shouldn't eat?
- nyolfen 7y agolifestyles are typically packaged with identities, which are packaged with values
- edoceo 7y agoI think the comment is built from the assumption that vegetarian push their ideas on others around them - like zealots
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThe old joke: "How can you tell if someone is a Vegetarian? They'll tell you."
- dredmorbius 7y agoHow can you tell if someone is a meat eater? They'll complain that you're a vegitarian.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoHm. Its pretty different. I don't come to a table and say "Hey! I'm a meat eater! Better supply me with meat in this meal, or I'm going to walk away!" Clearly, on one side, we have omnivores. On the other, extra rules about food type and preparation. Its almost always more complicated to feed one, than the other.
- gdubs 7y agoThe world’s wealthiest (eg, the American middle class) have the largest carbon footprint, and would make the most immediate impact by eating less meat.
- dredmorbius 7y agoA set of mid-sized though significant quibbles. The United States no longer has the largest total national carbon footprint. That title now goes to China, which has exploded past the US. The total carbon emissions title, since 1970 (roughly half, probably somewhat more, of the total since the Industrial Revolution, given ~30-ish year doubling rates), remains the US, though China are on track to surpass this within a few years. Per capita, US residents still have a larger carbon footprint than China. It's not the largest in the world, though, with that title going, depending on how you allocate, to petroleum exporting regions (e.g., Saudi Arabia), fueling and bunkering centres (e.g., Gibralter), ammonia fertiliser production (e.g., Trinidad and Tobago), or, if you're looking at direct local consumption rather than exports, largely Scandinavian countries with very large heating requirements. Emissions by country, graph, 1970-present: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions#/media/File%3AWorld_fossil_carbon_dioxide_emissions_1970-2017_six_countries_and_confederations.png https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_... 2017 national vs. per-capita emissions: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions#/media/File%3ATotal_CO2_emissions_by_country_in_2017_vs_per_capita_emissions_(top_40_countries).svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_... Cumulative emissions, 1970-2017: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions#/media/File%3ATotal_Emissions_CO2_for_the_period_1970_to_2017_and_2017_emissions%2C_by_country.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_...
- gdubs 7y agoI’d say when we’re talking about a dietary choice an individual makes, looking at carbon on a per capita basis is the right way to look at it. Especially given that the US consumer is a very influential one in the world. China is set to put a substantial chunk of global emissions under a carbon tax in the near term, which should prove to be a market force which drives down meat consumption, among other things. The US agricultural system has global implications — from tooling and process, to subsidies and what poor countries grow. A fundamental change in the American diet would have an enormous ripple effect across the globe.
- dredmorbius 7y ago"What can" arguments are frequently blind to "what is" facts. The bulk of present livestock animals raised for food either directly consume feed which could be eaten by humans, or consume feed which grows on land that could be used to grow foods eaten by humans. Net grazed livestock, especially in the US, is rare. Where such livestock do exist, they tend to be on already marginal lands -- if something better could be grown there it would be. The consequence being that its carrying and feeding capacity is highly limited. And even historical herd-keeping practices have proved highly damaging to long-term land quality, helping in the destruction of forests through much of the middle east, as an example. "The pines of Lebanon" is not just an allegorical phrase. The split between animals which do effectively forage and those which don't, I'm not immediately aware of, though
- eigenloss 7y agoAre you sure you're replying to the right post?
- suzzer99 7y agoIt's in Part 1.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- samvher 7y agoThe idea that a piece of meat is more nutritious than the same mass in plant matter is not in conflict with the idea that an ecosystem can feed more vegetarians than omni/carnivores.
- squish78 7y agoExcept in the winter in temperate climates when you can't harvest enough calories or protein to survive on a vegetarian diet
- ahelwer 7y agoWhen you eat an animal, you are consuming (in this analysis) all nutrients it has consumed over its entire life, of which 90% are wasted vs. just eating those nutrients yourself. It isn't talking about bioavailability or whatever.
- andreitp1 7y agoHow exactly would they be "wasted"? Seems to me that they would just end up back in nature and deeding other organisms as part of the food chain.
- kurthr 7y agoExactly, what if the animal just dies without being eaten... are 100% of it's nutrients wasted? Or did it lead a full life and return from which ot came?
- dredmorbius 7y agoThis is where scavengers and decomposers come in. It's relatively rare that living organisms die without being part of some further biological change, though that does happen. Fossil fuels are formed through lack of biological decomposition, as are precursor materials: peat bogs, kerogenated biomass, abiotic methane. Deaths in desert, arctic, or alpine conditions may simply dessicate and degrade rather than being eaten. The entropic channel may pass through biological mechanism, but there's no obligation that it must.
- Diederich 7y ago> How exactly would they be "wasted"? Increased entropy mostly in the form of heat.
- perl4ever 7y agoCompared to not eating it, or compared to the animal never having existed? I can't follow how, either way.
- 7y ago
- __MatrixMan__ 7y agoI agree that the claim about "food value" is in need of rewording, but it's context makes it clear that we're talking the total number of meals that the ecology of the region can provide, and not the percentage of any given meal that happens to be bioavailable. It's not about running faster than your vegetarian rival, it's about whether your tribe collapses because there isn't enough food. Yeah, not all plant matter is food for humans, but if you only had, say, 100 square miles, and you wanted it to support as many humans as possible, how would you allocate resources between hunting and gathering? The point is not that one choice is better than the other, it's that those who happened to make the right choice at the right time were the ones that survived.
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y ago> This is just completely false. All meat consumed is bioavailable protein and nutrients. I think you're missing the point entirely. It's about the calories needed to feed the animal, and the 10:1 ratio is the usual number quoted for this.
- Gomer1800 7y ago“Humans would have never evolved the ability to eat meat if it didn't confer a natural advantage over foragers.” Is this really true though about evolution in general. Evolution happens because of adaptations due to selective pressures. This doesn’t necessarily mean that evolutionary changes are beneficial.
- dredmorbius 7y agoEvolutionary changes are virtually solipsitically beneficial, by definition. They may be a local optimum, or adaptations to circumstances which existed at one time, but no longer, or be the result of a long chain of path-dependencies (effectively: multiple local optima jumps, a/k/a "the adjacent possible"), or even non-heritable benefits, such as "don't be under that big sky rock when it comes down" (luck plays a selective role, but features little if any heritable characteristics). All that said, I'm not making any argument for or against meat eating, other than to note that the evolutionary support of it suggests that it was certainly useful at least at some point in the past.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThe reference is to trophic levels and caloric loss. Plants, in net, capture about 1-3% of available solar energy and convert that to equivalent biomass. Food conversion -- the parts you can eat -- are a small fraction of that. Herbivores and predators each convert about 10% of the food energy they eat into body mass, for a 90% reduction (approximately) at each trophic level. Grazers lose 90% of the primary plant food energy, first-order predators lose 90% of the herbivore food energy, second-order predators (rare, but they do exist), lose 90% of the first-order predator food energy. This is known as the trophic or ecological pyramid: https://www.britannica.com/science/trophic-pyramid https://www.britannica.com/science/trophic-pyramid Yes, eating something that can eat what you cannot is a net win. Eating something that eats what you can (most contemporary livestock) is not.
- beat 7y agoTechnology changes that game. Grains are the core of the human diet, and have been since the dawn of civilization. But they are only edible because of civilization - the grinding, fermentation, and cooking breaking them down into something our bodies can use. In the US and other wealthy countries, we might feed grain to livestock, but it's also often parts of grain that we can't really eat (hulls, etc). And in poorer countries, livestock are often open-grazed on grasses that are inedible for us. And non-grazers like hogs often eat garbage, food waste that we don't consume. When farming, the questions are even more complex. The livestock generates manure that fertilizes the fields, so much of that "lost" energy is recovered.
- philg_jr 7y ago> When farming, the questions are even more complex. The livestock generates manure that fertilizes the fields, so much of that "lost" energy is recovered. Which is why grassfed > cornfed in pretty much every situation except for the extra fat/flavor you might get from cornfed beef. Having cows that consume grass is a win-win. The grass absorbs sunlight instead of reflecting it back into the atmosphere like a feedlot does, the grass is digested better, and manure fertilizes the grass. And when the cows are moved to different pastures and chickens are brought in, they help to agitate the manure into the soil to help that fertilizing process along. I wish the grassfed beef industry was embraced more instead of people attempting to swear off beef completely.