6 ms·
What prevents us from using traditional selective breeding on humans? Why can't women just go to a sperm bank and buy premium DNA?
by imtringued 7y ago
What prevents us from using traditional selective breeding on humans? Why can't women just go to a sperm bank and buy premium DNA?
- SEJeff 7y agoI believe the term you're looking for is Eugenics. If you google it for some background, it has been tried before and uh, didn't end out so well.
- cookieswumchorr 7y agoonly thing that actually speaks against it is being associated with [godwin's law]. As far as everyone involved is consenting this shouldn't be an issue.
- SEJeff 7y agoTrying to make better babies through breeding / genetics feeds right into the white supremacy narrative however. It is a really slippery slope, one I'd rather we not try again. Will we inevitably have "designer" babies at some point in the future morals / legality be damned? Probably so. Is this a good thing? Not necessarily. The area I can see it being acceptable is fixing congenital defects or genetic abnormalities. "We've made your fetus 10x less likely to develop vascular disease or we've prevented cyctic fibrosis in your baby" vs "We made super strong soldiers who don't feel pain".
- asdkhadsj 7y ago> Trying to make better babies through breeding / genetics feeds right into the white supremacy narrative however. It is a really slippery slope, one I'd rather we not try again. So.. we'll make them non-white, and sidestep that issue? I mostly kid. Yet, it's a shame that even a fairly tame discussion about selecting sperm based on DNA has to be dragged through the mud with racism and godwin-eugenics. At some point humanity needs to stop being so anti-racist-racist. I'm not saying I don't understand where you come from, I just long for the day when we can discuss DNA selection without someone bringing up skin color.
- SEJeff 7y agoGiven the current situation (here in the US at least) where white supremacy is very much on the rise, I feel it is very important to politely discuss, so we don't repeat the past. Just because I'm a privileged cis white male doesn't mean I think it is easy for everyone else.
- asdkhadsj 7y agoIt would be interesting to start a eugenics-esque program, but focus on DNA superiority combined within equal races mixed in. Ie, fully embrace "melting pot". It's of course a silly dream to promote all skin colors equally. While I'd like it, it would immediately cause problems with the people who prioritize skin color over all else. It's such a tiring state of the world.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> but focus on DNA superiority combined within equal races mixed in “Superiority” is always subjective; the fact that the phenotype you are maximizing doesn't happen to be the same ideal sought by white supremacists doesn't really make a difference to the ethics of such a eugenics program (the steps you are taking to advance it might be a legitimate differentiator, but the purpose would not.)
- asdkhadsj 7y agoIs superiority subjective? We have hundreds of fatal flaws in our genetics. Would someone defend that those are superior? I'm not talking about subjective traits like hair. I'm talking about scientific markers of health, disease, retardation, death. Not advancing this technology because of how it could be used seems awkward, like not making medicine because it could save bad people. Cutting our nose off to spite our face.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Is superiority subjective? Pretty much by definition. > We have hundreds of fatal flaws in our genetics. Pretty much by definition, we (living humans) have no necessarily-fatal flaws in our genetics. We may have some that are fatal when they combine in certain ways or in certain circumstances, but the fatal effects in those conditions aren't the only effects they have.
- gingabriska 7y agoWhat is a premium DNA?
- izzydata 7y agoPresumably sperm from a donor that had desirable traits.
- astrodev 7y ago> What prevents us from using traditional selective breeding on humans? Traditional values, norms, religions. Those are pretty much gone by now, anyway. > Why can't women just go to a sperm bank and buy premium DNA? Ever heard of Tinder?
- gingabriska 7y ago>What prevents us from using traditional selective breeding on humans? It's happening, just that we do not acknowledge it. People are always selecting for the traits they see as favourable either consciously or subconsciously. Women do not date me because I look scary (as terrorist as some woman put succinctly) it means they are selecting for man who look less scary. Some women also told me that I do not respect women, so they are selecting for men who respect women. I am cool with that because I also select for a woman who is comfortable with me without I changing myself completely.
- Merrill 7y agoIt goes the other way in countries where matches are based on sexual attraction. Families decay when bright, successful men choose women for their beauty. In societies where matchmaking is done by parents or by recognized matchmakers, the outcome is likely much better in terms of creating and maintaining high achieving strains.
- gingabriska 7y agoMen select for youth, fertility, beauty and agreability. Even in countries where there is arranged marriage, successful men are matched up with more beautiful women (but within equal cast and somewhat equal socio-economic status) >Families decay when bright, successful men choose women for their beauty. I don't follow how family decays when beauty is selected. Women can be beautiful and successful at the same time. >In societies where matchmaking is done by parents or by recognized matchmakers, the outcome is likely much better in terms of creating and maintaining high achieving strains. It might lead to a stable family on average but it doesn't mean people in such setting are happy. What I've observed is that countries were arranged marriage is common, women when they are young have lovers in college but they flush down their social media, dress more conservative when time for arrange marriage come, often they also take up a job for short duration to signal independence/education. In west, where there is more freedom. Young women date handsome men but if such relationship doesn't last long, their priorities change and they look for financially stable average looking men, though if they are lucky they might also get handsome and financially well off man. It's quite rare for a woman to marry a man who doesn't make as much money as her if not more.
- aaron695 7y agoWe've done traditional selective breeding of humans in many cultures for different traits for thousands of years and it's worked. We've also done premium sperm bank services. Which should have worked, but I've yet to see studies either way, but no reason to think otherwise. But breeding is slow, and especially if it's your kids you care about now, not generations in the future which is why we need genetic engineering.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoConfused. This happens all the time. Sperm banks. They don't hand out random stuff. There's a rigorous screening and selection process.
- sverige 7y agoI'm not at all convinced that sperm banks have procedures that are in any sense "rigorous." For example, there's a Dutch man who fathered 200 children through a sperm bank. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/nov/24/sperm-donor-man-who-fathered-200-children https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/nov/24/sperm-donor-...
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoWell, they purported to be. Questionaires to select donors; catalogs for the recipients to peruse and choose. In many banks other than the strawman provided, it meant that 'eugenics' was alive and well most places.
- sverige 7y agoNot really a strawman. In reality, sperm banks are not regulated closely at all. Most of the laws have to do with parental rights, not "quality control." Even self-regulation is just that and nothing more. The idea that people choosing donors from a catalog amounts to eugenics assumes that the people choosing the donor (in the case of anonymous donors, which is only a portion of all artificially inseminated children) have some rigor in choosing; i.e., that marketing doesn't influence them somehow. Most of the supposed rigorous screening is nothing more than checking boxes for physical characteristics such as height and eye color, education level attained, and family history of certain diseases. There have been quite a few sperm bank scandals, including one where the proprietor of the sperm bank used his own seed even though he told his cutomers they were selecting someone else's from a catalog. The Dutch case is notable because it violates one of the recommendations (no law in the U.S.) that limit a donor to 25 births per 800,000 population. [0] But it is certainly not the only case. [0] "The closest thing to a regulatory body overseeing sperm donation throughout the U.S. is a nonprofit called the American Society of Reproductive Medicine. The ASRM has a set of recommendations that physicians, fertility specialists, and sperm banks are encouraged to follow." "The ASRM also recommends setting a limit of 25 births per donor within a population of 800,000, in order to lower the risk of accidental incestuous relations. In many other countries, there are laws putting caps on the number of births per single donor within populations of a certain size, but the U.S. doesn’t have any such law." https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/07/sperm-donations-emotional-consequences/564587/ https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/07/sperm-don...
- samgtx 7y ago>Why can't women just go to a sperm bank and buy premium DNA? They can. High end sperm banks that do thorough background checks and create profiles on donors already exist.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> What prevents us from using traditional selective breeding on humans? Much human breeding is traditional selective breeding (whether using sperm/egg donors or more ancient methods, pairings are often selected based in part on the expected genetically-determined qualities of any offspring), but it's just not a program maintained over many generations with consistent selection criteria, outside of conspiracy theories and science fiction (e.g., Heinlein’s Howard Families.) Shorter term (usually not by intent) eugenics programs have been tried, and they are usually moral disasters tied to movements that are rapidly (sometimes violently) rejected, or at least the eugenics portion of the program is abandoned before long.