3 ms·
No, what we need is a proper permissions model for desktop applications. The idea of permissions being per-user is almost useless in this day and age where most
by taneq 7y ago
No, what we need is a proper permissions model for desktop applications. The idea of permissions being per-user is almost useless in this day and age where most desktop machines have one user (or a small number of users sharing files) and where most applications are downloaded from untrusted sources.
We need proper automatic sandboxing of native apps, restricting file, network and resource access without prior permission from the user.
- jasonvorhe 7y agoLike iOS then? Oh, evil golden cages, right?
- taneq 7y agoFalse dichotomy. A cage restricting the rightful owner of a computer is not the same as a cage that the rightful owner can use to restrict untrusted software.
- socceroos 7y agoHow do you think Apple are allowed to exist in China? Who gave you the impression that they're the exception to the rule for independence from the government's "oversight"?
- baroffoos 7y agoThere is no reason why sandboxing needs to be evil. In fact this is already proven by the sandboxing efforts on linux where there is no mandatory repository and the user is always in control, its the applications that are not.
- TekMol 7y agoThat is being worked on. On many fronts. Linux containers are getting better. iOS is sandboxing applications to some extend. Android too and is slowly adding finer and finer sandboxing settings. ChromeOS also does sandboxing. I don't know about Windows, but I guess something similar is happening over there. My money is on the Browser. Because it has proven (via survival of the fittest) that it is the best platform for the modern age. It has what, 100% market share? Everybody I know can use websites. Even if one of the desktop or mobile operating systems adds sufficient sandboxing in the future, I would not want to develop applications for it. Because it would restrict my creation to the people who use that one platform. And it would give the power to censor it or mingle with it to the platform operator.
- pjmlp 7y agoWindows has been on the sandbox path since Windows 8. Every release gets a bit more of that, regardless how many feel about the store or UWP API in general.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI don't want to only use trusted sources from any software store. If UWP had provided sensible deployment options, it wouldn't be as dead as it is. Hell, personal firewalls provide a better sandbox solution, at least for network access, even if that is not really their intended function. Be that as it may, I think good privacy laws and holding software manufacturers accountable is part of a solution. That software more and more behaves like worms regarding to user data is a more recent development.
- pjmlp 7y agoUWP is not dead, every Windows release adds more API space, React Native for Windows uses UWP, Windows 10 drivers now use UWP APIs as well (Universal drivers), WinUI uses UWP, XAML Islands use UWP, ... WinUI is also the official replacement for MFC, which triggered the rewritte of some UWP components into C++/WinRT from .NET Native. Windows store supports side loading since Windows 8.1, and MSIX packages have replaced APPX and MSI as the future of Windows package formats. Win32 APIs are frozen in amber since Windows 7.
- raxxorrax 7y agoMaybe. I am not really happy with it to be honest. Win32 is old and I thought WPF would be a real alternative. It did many things better than classical APIs, but I was never really into XAML and it was dropped just after a few years. I took a quick look at UWP which uses XAML in a different way, but I wasn't really convinced by it. I am not interested in side loading anything. I have just no interest to use an API that is abused to promote a proprietary store and an OS because I only see disadvantages in that. UWP may have changed by now, but for me it is too late. I have switched to other technologies and are pretty happy with them. If windows continues to be SaaS, I will not develop for it. Even if its legacy might continue for a few decades. If the primary form of deployment is a store, I could as well use Apple. Although their store isn't really shining on Mac OS as well. I believe there are good reasons for that. Windows as a platform had many advantages, but it seems to me that MS threw that away to emulate others. A futile strategy in my opinion.
- kitsunesoba 7y agomacOS Catalina is actually much more aggressive about this. Even in unsigned unsandboxed apps, the OS will pause the app and ask the user for permission when the app tried to access any directory it doesn’t have permission for, and this behavior is replicated across many other parts of the system too (webcam, mic, etc). It’s a bit annoying initially but it’s nice knowing that the system will put control back into my hands whenever apps try to do something shady.
- paulcarroty 7y agoGood feature, kinda sad macOS isn't popular like Windows. Linux apps supports permission management in flatpak, but the packaging can be a big headache.