7 ms·
> So far, nobody seems to have full self driving without "safety drivers". A common saying around here is that we have two seasons: winter and (road) construct
by zdragnar 7y ago
> So far, nobody seems to have full self driving without "safety drivers".
A common saying around here is that we have two seasons: winter and (road) construction.
Construction zones have pretty much every obstacle to automated driving you can think of:
* painted lanes that don't correlate to the temporary lanes marked by cones
* lanes that don't correspond to pre-programmed maps / gps
* irregular and unpredictable vehicle and pedestrian entrances and exits (construction workers and trucks)
* Areas where traffic is reduced to a single lane for both directions, and must take turns coordinated by humans with signs at each end of the lane
* speed limits marked by temporary signs
* rough, temporary transitions between pavement and gravel
Unless we can somehow get every state to compel every road construction company and every autonomous vehicle maker to use a single communication protocol, implement it at every construction site (so autonomous cars are made aware of these dangers) it's not going to happen.
Oh, and said protocol has to be hack-proof so trouble-makers can't start convincing cars that they're in the middle of a construction zone and force them out of their lanes on normal roads.
It's conceivable that the coordinated effort could happen, but I'm not going to hold my breath (due to the sheer increase in cost to the government) nor will I trust that said protocol will have fail-proof security.
- falcor84 7y ago>Oh, and said protocol has to be hack-proof so trouble-makers can't start convincing cars that they're in the middle of a construction zone and force them out of their lanes on normal roads. Why would it be easier for trouble-makers to fool autonomous cars? As a human driver, I'd be fooled by pretty much any road marking or guy in an orange vest.
- nishantvyas 7y agoCorrect. It’s amazing, how much forgiving we can be for human errors ( accidents every year) but absolutely not for machine/autonomous vehicles, even when, statistically speaking, machines may make better decision much faster(or at-least no worse than human judgement)... I guess feeling/perception of being in control is more important to us... Other interesting observation I find in every autonomous vehicle discussion is, how we only focus on edge cases... when in reality every tool that we use (including the car we been driving) today are built for general use case and operate under mostly a control environment. Rather if we think autonomous car as additional pair of eyes and hands when we need it most might serve us well in short run before the technology gets mature over next decade or two. I’ll be really happy and relaxed if my car can mostly (70-80%) drive it self to daily commute or next trip to LA; expecting it to be my chauffeur is bit too much, personally.
- beefield 7y agoThis is why I wonder why platooning technology is so much less hyped. Give me a platooning hardware kit to my current car, enough users after which I can join on my longer trips and literally more than 95% of my self driving car needs are covered. I really do not care if I need to drive a 10 minute stint on the city every now and then. And If I do, I can take a taxi. But getting my hands off the wheel and eyes off the road on the highway is what would have real utility to me.
- dmoy 7y agoPlatooning kind of messes up highway traffic because people need to either cross a ton of lanes to get in and out of the platoon (if the platoon is on the left), or non-platoons can't get on/off (if the platoon is on the right). If everything was forced to platoon on highways it would work. But that's like 30-50 yrs later, after the tech is introduced, barring some really radical legislation with huge popular and state support.
- beefield 7y agoNot sure if it would be techically possible to have gaps in the platoon after every five cars, but at least it would be trivial to set max size of one platoon to something reasonable.
- p1necone 7y agoYou might be fooled by a man in an orange vest, but I doubt you'll listen to him if he's telling you to drive into oncoming traffic.
- vntok 7y agoIf you don't immediately see the incoming traffic in question, yes you will. Otherwise your self preservation rules will prevail and you won't budge. Note that self driving vehicles aren't different from humans in that respect, except they see much farther.
- bradknowles 7y agoBut they understand less and have less common sense by which to operate. So, it takes a lot more work on the programming side to compensate.
- agent008t 7y agoWith self driving cars you have no idea what they would do when presented with an edge case they may have only seen very rarely before. With humans, you can in most cases assume the driver would do something reasonable, especially if there is enough time to think through the situation.
- pedrocr 7y agoYou must be driving in much better places than I do. Human drivers do incredibly unreasonable things even without edge cases.
- deelowe 7y agoIf someone did this to a human driver, they may make a mistake and potentially get injured, but pretty quickly someone would notice and do something about it. With automation, a cleverly crafted issue could persist for some time causing quite a bit of damage before it's corrected. https://www.reddit.com/r/gifs/comments/6ofa63/dont_turn_your_back_to_the_mill/ https://www.reddit.com/r/gifs/comments/6ofa63/dont_turn_your...
- zdragnar 7y ago> pretty much any road marking or guy in an orange vest That only works if a police car doesn't come by and catch the perpetrator in the act. With a wireless communication to automated drivers, someone could plausibly feed bad information from a hidden or otherwise remote location. Beyond that, just as automation allows human-intensive processes to scale by removing the humans, fooling automated drivers can scale much more readily than fooling human drivers.
- rebuilder 7y agoApparently, people mess with autonomous cars simply because they're autonomous. It's hard to say whether that's just the novelty factor or something likely to persist.
- jddj 7y agoI can easily imagine some bored teenagers (can even imagine a certain version of younger me doing it) blocking an empty autonomous vehicle from leaving a parking space just for kicks. I suppose coaxing other empty ones into a ditch or waterway isn't too much of a stretch either if the cars are owned by some mega-corp and become some kind of cheap public good like shopping trolleys. As soon as it becomes a robot, a lot of the social pressure to be a good person falls away. Less so if there are people inside, but I can see empty autonomous cars being given a pretty hard time just for kicks.
- pnutjam 7y agoJam rf signals, modify ir cues, etc...
- GVIrish 7y ago> Why would it be easier for trouble-makers to fool autonomous cars? As a human driver, I'd be fooled by pretty much any road marking or guy in an orange vest. Imagine someone hacking the 'construction zone protocol' and spoofing thousands of cars into thinking they're in a construction zone at once. You'd be hard pressed to fool thousands of geographically separated human drivers at the same time.
- zaroth 7y agoIf it’s possible for remote drivers to assist a vehicle with no in-car steering apparatus through areas where the algorithm can’t go, then I think it can be done. Getting to absolute 100% will require either AGI or an incredible infrastructure investment. Now personally I think FSD is worth on the order of $1 trillion per year to the economy, so it’s the next great Moon Shot, and totally worth every bit of infrastructure investment we can throw at it. But it makes sense to see how much further we can get with in-car algorithmic driving before the infra investments start coming in earnest to fill in the gaps. Another possibility is there could be ways for a passenger to assist the algorithm without actually using a steering wheel and pedals as input. I believe the level before truly perfect FSD allows the car to get stuck as long as it does so safely. Approaching and stopping at a single lane construction zone, for instance. The current Tesla AP does remarkably well on highways with missing lane markings. A stretch I drive every day is ground down in prep for new pavement and just has the occasional white square marking, but it’s enough for AP to lock in on. It also seems to do fine with cones. It’s worth noting that construction zones aren’t even particularly safe for human drivers (accident rate skyrockets). So technology to make construction zones more passable overall is important, even if it just enables self driving as a side effect.
- nradov 7y agoIt's hard to see how we could really count on remote drivers for anything safety critical considering that the current cellular data network is unreliable, lacks guaranteed quality of service, and has many coverage gaps.
- jfim 7y agoKeep in mind that the vehicle already has all the sensors to do collision avoidance and navigation. The remote control can be to tell the car "drive this path" instead of direct control of the vehicle over a high latency link.
- Nokinside 7y agoRemote operators solve these issue. Once you have autonomous cars that driving safely, but can't manage complex situations like you describe, you delegate those for remote pilots that are allowed to operate car in slow speeds. You need 5G network coverage with mission-critical features (mcMTC) to archieve that. BLER 10^-6 and E2E latency < 5- 10 ms. Construction work crews might be required to erect 5G mini cell tower before they can start working to make sure that traffic goes smoothly. Taxi fleet of 10,000 vehicles might need only 100-200 remote operators to manage the fleet. That kind of reduction in workforce provides huge savings.
- leoc 7y ago> You need 5G network coverage with mission-critical features (mcMTC) to archieve that. BLER 10^-6 and E2E latency < 5- 10 ms. I do wonder if that's a factor behind Musk's push into low-orbit satellite Internet. > Taxi fleet of 10,000 vehicles might need only 100-200 remote operators to manage the fleet. That kind of reduction in workforce provides huge savings. Even if all mileage was human-driven there would be very large benefits if you could really consolidate taxi drivers in call-centres for remote driving. No need to transport or preposition drivers and much less trouble estimating demand.
- Nokinside 7y agoStarlink can provide 25 to 35 ms latency from low orbits, so I don't think so.
- leoc 7y agoEven 70ms isn't all that long compared to the the official (let alone real-world) thinking-time estimates for braking http://www.brake.org.uk/component/tags/tag/thinking-time http://www.brake.org.uk/component/tags/tag/thinking-time , so it might not be an unacceptable delay, at least if combined with professional drivers and reduced speed limits and/or failsafe locally-controlled AI braking.
- masonic 7y agofleet of 10,000 vehicles might need only 100-200 remote operators It won't scale in a predictable way. Let's say there's a major event in NYC (natural disaster or unnatural). You may suddenly need 700 operators at the same time just to deal with NYC and environs.
- Balgair 7y agohttps://boingboing.net/2019/07/06/flickering-car-ghosts.html https://boingboing.net/2019/07/06/flickering-car-ghosts.html Essentially a POC that the car can see, but is so brief that the human cannot see anything.