4 ms·
Prices falling to 0 isn't a good thing; it means there is too much power and nothing to use it for. Nobody wants that, it is pointless. The people building the
by roenxi 7y ago
Prices falling to 0 isn't a good thing; it means there is too much power and nothing to use it for. Nobody wants that, it is pointless.
The people building the capital will make a profit over the year, so consumers will make up for the 0s with higher prices when there is not enough energy. And over the long term $0 prices potentially lead to building less infrastructure leading to blackouts.
Basically we know the average price is not going to be 0. Therefore, 0 prices signals variance. Variance is pretty much always risky and expensive in big infrastructure; and the electricity market is a good example. It can hopefully be managed to only be a minor inconvenience but it is certainly not a positive for anyone.
It does signal that there is a golden window to, eg, run a desalination plant. If anyone takes advantage of that opportunity then it would be a win, but the symptom of that happening would be non-0 prices.
EDIT
Also, coal plant failures in hot weather are probably a symptom of them not being maintained. Australia has already seen a Labor-Green coalition in federal politics; you'd have to be an idiot to spend money maintaining a coal plant in that political environment. Better to let them run down and try to extract money from the government in a crisis situation which seems to be the current strategy.
- ianai 7y agoAll it takes is a reasonable storage of that energy for later use. I saw a crane design that didn’t require any major tech.
- roenxi 7y agoIf we had reasonable storage the price wouldn't be 0. Or negative. It would just be low, because the storers would be competing to buy near-0 energy. High prices mean "we need more", low prices mean "carry on", $0 means "don't produce this stuff, please". Negative prices mean "We're begging you, turn it off, it is hurting".
- abathur 7y agoNot sure the economics here are this simple? It seems like, if this distinction was meaningful, renewable operators would be turning off generation capacity when prices dropped this low. There's some economic, effort, or technological incentive to keep the spiggots on (i.e., either the marginal costs of producing this power are so low there's no incentive for operators to stop, or the costs/risks of stopping it are too high to bother). Ignoring storage tech, it's also a signal that demand is too inflexible to redistribute power consumption (that is, an opportunity...).
- andromeduck 7y agoUsually when this happens it's because the producers have fixed/guaranteed price contracts so there's just no to stop producing.
- roenxi 7y ago> Not sure the economics here are this simple? The economics are pretty simple; electricity is about as pure a commodity as it is possible to get. The timeframes this plays out in are the 1-10 year windows where people make big long-term capital decisions. > It seems like, if this distinction was meaningful, renewable operators would be turning off generation capacity when prices dropped this low. In the short term people ignore market signals for all sorts of good reasons. I can ignore market signals all day if I want to. If they ignore a signal all year they will start to go bankrupt. But the fact that renewable are ignoring a market signal is not a positive benefit to cite when talking about "energy industry FUD". When market signals get ignored; consumers pay more. This has played out in Germany, and it is playing out in Australia. $0 wholesale prices mean high retail prices over the year. > Ignoring storage tech, it's also a signal that demand is too inflexible to redistribute power consumption (that is, an opportunity...). Massive opportunity. If prices are $0; nobody is seizing the opportunity. It is waste. If someone were making use of this they would be being charged a low but positive number.
- abathur 7y agoNot really looking to press this; it seems like you know more about the economics of energy production than I do. But, some examples of why I wonder if it's this simple: - Part of redistributing less time-sensitive forms of consumption around the grid/clock is demonstrating quantity and stability of cheap power at those times. One possibility is the producer is just being subsidized or obligated into production they wouldn't undertake without a distortion. But it seems like low/negative prices are also how you'd prove the supply. - In responsive real-time energy markets, driving prices down should force higher-cost producers to reduce output. Over time, that signal should take less-competitive producers completely offline. It's not obvious to me that they're ignoring market signals if their strategic decision-making function could more complicated than just "produce when the rate is profitable."
- stale2002 7y agoWhat if I were to tell you that it costs you 0$ for the air that you breath? I'd it a bad thing that the market price for the air that we are currently breathing is 0$?
- roenxi 7y agoPrecisely nobody is in the business of mass-producing commodity breathable air. It isn't a market. There are neither buyers nor sellers. If there was someone stupid enough to try and create a commodity market in air, it would signal to any producer "get out, you are crazy". If we lived in a utopia where electricity was produced without any human intervention whatsoever then a $0 price would be fine. Producing electricity does require human action. Maintaining solar farms requires human action. Maintaining wind farms requires human intervention. Acquiring fuel requires human action. These are not charities; free is going to turn out to be quite expensive.
- johnday 7y ago$0 doesn't imply a problem with the market, it implies an issue of oversupply. If the "problem" ends up being that coal/oil plants only run during the winter months, that seems like a net win for the world.
- spangry 7y agoJust to add to your point, per unit subsidies can also cause negative prices.
- imtringued 7y agoThe problem isn't a lack of technology. It's a lack of demand. We have several dozen technologies that in combination can solve this problem. However it's going to be slightly expensive and since most countries do not generate more than 70% of their electricity from renewables they can simply get away with the far cheaper option. They already have gas plants which emit less CO2 per kWh than coal plants. The difference between a 80% and 100% reduction in CO2 is less significant than the difference between a 20% and 50% reduction.
- topologistics 7y agoI dont get how the crane factors in to this unless you're suggesting that the extra energy could be stored as as gravitational potential energy, which probably doesn't fit the definition of "reasonable storage". I presume you'd get the energy back out of the system by dropping heavy things from the crane? A dubious proposal imho. I don't think there is a well-tested reliable way to harness energy from falling objects and convert it into some useful form.
- johnday 7y ago> I don't think there is a well-tested reliable way to harness energy from falling objects and convert it into some useful form. We do it with water. I'm not sure why the GP leapt to "crane" rather than "pump" but for sure we can achieve that. As for objects, a few designs spring to mind but they all seem less efficient than just pumping fluids.
- nullsmack 7y agoThey're talking about this story: https://qz.com/1355672/stacking-concrete-blocks-is-a-surprisingly-efficient-way-to-store-energy/ https://qz.com/1355672/stacking-concrete-blocks-is-a-surpris...