8 ms·
The problem is that while RISC-V may deliver an excellent open ISA, there is no equivalent open solution for the GPU/display controller side. As I understand it
by cmrdporcupine 7y ago
The problem is that while RISC-V may deliver an excellent open ISA, there is no equivalent open solution for the GPU/display controller side. As I understand it, the GPU world is full of patents and dominated by just a few parties. I don't think there's something that Huawei or other Chinese manufacturers could easily start with and extend.
So I can see RISC-V being ideal for applications that are not user facing or don't require fancy graphics -- servers, network hardware, microcontrollers, etc. But it would be a tough call to put one in a phone, tablet, or laptop.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bhouston 7y agoGPUs have sort of plateaued except for the raytracing component. There are quite a few vendors, Mali from ARM, Adreno from Qualcomm, PowerVR from Imagination, NVIDIA's GeForce, AMD's Radeon, Intel's integrated stuff, and then there is a few more smaller players (what Matrox, Broadcom, etc.) I think there is room for an open source straightforward GPU based on the standard principles. Although maybe there is patent licensing between all the parties that I am not aware of.
- mmanfrin 7y ago> GPUs have sort of plateaued except for the raytracing component What? As far as I understood it, CPUs had plateaued outside of efficiencies, GPU power still follows Moore's. Generational benchmarks show big leaps in every new arch on userbenchmark, whereas CPUs from 7 or 8 years ago are only marginally slower (SC) than modern ones.
- ksec 7y ago>Generational benchmarks show big leaps in every new arch on userbenchmark, That is because GPU scales very well with Transistor count, throw in more transistor and memory bandwidth and you are good. On the CPU you could have doubled the transistor budget and get marginal improvement in IPC.
- zsrxx 7y agoWhy can't a GPU power a computer?
- Retric 7y agoThe biggest issue is lack of huge caches, and the extreme latency to main memory due to the speed of light. GPU’s are fine or even better for a wide range of compute tasks see CUDA etc, they just end up being very slow at a subset of common tasks.
- hermitdev 7y agoCircuits don't operate at speed of light, though. People like to say this over and over again, but electron mobility through a circuit is only around 2/3s the speed of light, IIRC. They may have very tiny mass, but they still have mass.
- ArnoVW 7y agoSame reason we have OLAP and OLTP systems. Same reason it makes sense for some use cases to set up a Hadoop cluster, and for others to have a single but fast CPU: some tasks can be run in parallel, others can't. See Amdahl's law : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amdahl%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amdahl%27s_law
- joking 7y agoYou can calculate the value of each screen pixel without knowing the value of the others. To calculate the n value of a fibonnaci sequence you have to calculate the n-1 and n-2 values first, so it doesn't matter how many cores do you have. Gpus are for the former and CPUs for the latest.
- TomVDB 7y agoNumber of transistors/$ is about to reach a plateau soon (if it hasn’t already.) More powerful GPUs will happen as Moore’s Law continues for a few more years, but the free for all will soon be over. This is true for the whole semiconductor industry, and the consequences will be very interesting, not necessarily in a good way.
- mises 7y agoLet's be real, the Chinese have been stealing technology right and left for years. Losses number between $225 and $600 billion per year [0]. One in five companies has had its technology stolen [1]. They will just steal the tech. Or maybe they'll decide it's easier to work with AMD (they're already doing it on the CPU side [2]). This is not popular to say, but it is accurate and my statements are sourced. Feel free to provide rebutting evidence if you disagree. [0]: https://money.cnn.com/2018/03/23/technology/china-us-trump-tariffs-ip-theft/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2018/03/23/technology/china-us-trump-t... [1]: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/28/1-in-5-companies-say-china-stole-their-ip-within-the-last-year-cnbc.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/28/1-in-5-companies-say-china-s... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD%E2%80%93Chinese_joint_venture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD%E2%80%93Chinese_joint_vent...
- gamblor956 7y agoI'm surprised that it's only 1 in 5 companies. Based on prior client experiences with Chinese contractors, I would have expected it to be 5 of 5 foreign companies doing business in China.
- mises 7y agoI would assume that it's due to a limited number of companies having useful IP to steal. I have had similar experience with several companies, and hear similar stats from those who work with other companies, but that is anecdotal. I would also hazard a guess that many companies don't want to admit it, even if it does happen.
- hutzlibu 7y agoThe losses numbers are from a US government investigation. So they might have some bias ... and therefore not really mean anything.
- Taniwha 7y agoYou can't steal an open source ISA .... unless you don't follow the license (which in this case is trivial to do)
- 7y ago
- garmaine 7y agoThere is plenty of work being done on RISC-V vector computing and GPU equivalents. E.g.: https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Libre-RISC-V-February-Designing https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Libre-RI...
- monocasa 7y agoAs someone who looked hard into it, RISC-V doesn't really make sense for a GPU shaders, IMO. You'd have to change so many things about how the ISA works that you wouldn't get a benefit to using a common ISA. Stuff like how shaders are batched and dispatched, textures accesses make sense to be their own instructions, you want a larger register file on the scalar side, the memory barrier semantics are much more complex, etc. RISC-V might make sense inside of the GPU accelerators though. GFX command list processing, DMA engines, and video codecs all make sense to be something like RISC-V.
- rjsw 7y agoNvidia are supposed to be using RISC-V inside future GPUs.
- TomVDB 7y agoYes, as a replacement for their internal proprietary logic controllers which operate in the periphery. That has nothing to do with the RISC-V ISA being the right choice for core functionality like shader cores.
- Fnoord 7y agoAFAIU their RISC-V variant can also be proprietary, akin to FreeBSD based products such as Junyper or macOS
- monocasa 7y agoTo replace their falcon cores in the places I talked about in my second paragraph.
- jsgo 7y ago> As I understand it, the GPU world is full of patents and dominated by just a few parties. This would be a impediment typically, but considering they're blackballed already, how beholden are they to patents? Block imports? Think that's being done already. Requiring US companies to not do business with them? That's being done already. At this point, they just have to ride out the US/China trade war and then when things are being negotiated, I imagine a "turn a blind eye" to Huawei is going to be given. They're gimped in some ways, but in others they've probably never been more free.
- bilbo0s 7y agoTrue. If we're all just gonna take our marbles and go home, I guess there's nothing really stopping any of us from just making our own marbles. Still pretty dumb to make your own marbles though. But I get your point there.
- redm 7y agoYou imply Huawei was playing by the "rules" and not already stealing. [1] [2] [1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/01/us-indicts-huawei-for-stealing-t-mobile-robot-selling-us-tech-to-iran/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/01/us-indicts-huawe... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-02-04/huawei-sting-offers-rare-glimpse-of-u-s-targeting-chinese-giant https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-02-04/huawei-st...
- DiogenesKynikos 7y ago"Tappy" again, plus a story from Bloomberg, which has shattered its reputation when it comes to technology/security reporting (SuperMicro, among other false articles whipping up anti-Chinese hysteria).
- redm 7y agoOk, how about NPR: https://www.npr.org/2019/06/08/730898429/huawei-accused-of-technology-theft https://www.npr.org/2019/06/08/730898429/huawei-accused-of-t... Or ZDNET: https://www.zdnet.com/article/huawei-regularly-tried-to-steal-apple-trade-secrets/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/huawei-regularly-tried-to-stea... or CNBC: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/22/huawei-executive-accusetd-of-stealing-trade-secrets-from-axas-company-backed-by-microsoft-and-dell.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/22/huawei-executive-accusetd-of...
- alexnewman 7y agoIt's not clear to me that you can't make an open source cpu with a chip like risc-v
- xxxpupugo 7y agoHuawei is still a largely a networking equipment company, the consumer branch of it is growing very fast, but not essential, as per their CEO.
- camillomiller 7y agoI was in Beijing at their press conf last January when Richard Yu proudly announced that in 2018 the Consumer Business Group had a record revenue of fifty billion US$, making as much as the infrastructure division for the first time ever. Sure Ren Zhengfei is ready to throw the CBG under the bus if needed (but it won’t happen, as it is sustainable even as a China-only business). Still the consumer division is way past being just a small part of the company.
- microcolonel 7y agoNothing about RISC-V would cause any more difficulty interfacing with GPUs. Any GPU you can license piecemeal right now, can also be connected to a RISC-V complex.
- imtringued 7y agoARM isn't going to license their GPUs to a competitor.
- microcolonel 7y agoAMD just announced a major license of their GPU tech to Samsung. Nvidia, Qualcomm, and other vendors have complete designs with their own GPUs. Vivante and Imagination would surely be glad to license their tech to smaller players.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoPresumably if Huawei can't license an ARM core before of trade restrictions, they're not going to be able to license a GPU because of similar restrictions.
- microcolonel 7y agoMaybe Jingjia. Most GPU IP vendors are U.S, Korean, or broadly Western; so I can imagine it'd be difficult. It's not like they're having a more difficult time as a result of the host ISA. That's my main point.
- KaoruAoiShiho 7y agoThere is an okish Chinese GPU maker. We'll have to see if they actually deliver though. But with more funding they may be competitive. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/297099-chinese-vendor-designs-pcie-4-0-gpu-targets-gtx-1080-performance https://www.extremetech.com/computing/297099-chinese-vendor-...
- AFascistWorld 7y ago>Military ties, Chinese listed company That how you know it's nothing but a marketing campaign to boost their stock price.
- phkahler 7y agoIf they can only sell their phones in China, they will go ahead and make their own GPUs since they can violate US patents all they want in their own market. That will just force them to develop good GPUs.
- fulafel 7y agoFrom hardware POV GPUs these days are to a close approximation just multicore CPUs with more focus on parallel throughput instead of single core performence, and a few specialized graphics op instructions (like texture lookup) that are unlikely to be badly patent encumbered due to their age.