6 ms·
> The OECD data is particularly flawed because it is based on “income,” which excludes [...] healthcare provided by Medicaid, free clinics, and the Children’s H
by gus_massa 7y ago
> The OECD data is particularly flawed because it is based on “income,” which excludes [...] healthcare provided by Medicaid, free clinics, and the Children’s Health Insurance Program.
Don't many of the other countries offer some kind of "free" medical service for everyone? Should they add this to the average income of those countries?
Anecdote time. Here in Argentina we have:
* Free hospitals and free ambulances for emergencies, and even some standard procedures. The quality and waiting time may vary. It's free for everyone. Should they count this as
"income"?
* Also we get a compulsory 5% discount of the salary for additional healthcare that is controlled by the working union, this includes dental care. The quality and waiting time may vary. I'm not sure if they would count this 5% as income.
* Also you can pay a private medical plan or pay to a medic for a consultation. The quality and waiting time may vary, but it's usually faster and you have more options to pick a good medic hopefully.
- chrisco255 7y agoIn the U.S. we have Medicaid for low-income earners. So the bottom 20% the article mentions would largely qualify for free health care: https://eligibility.com/medicaid/texas-tx-medicaid-benefits https://eligibility.com/medicaid/texas-tx-medicaid-benefits
- erentz 7y agoHave you looked at Medicaid eligibility requirements? It is a common misunderstanding that if you’re poor you get Medicaid. Eg. In Florida no matter how poor your are you don’t qualify unless you’re disabled, have children, or are pregnant. In other states there are hard income limits which are incredibly low, and earns a dollar more, you don’t qualify. You go from having free Medicaid to needing to pay $1000 per month in premiums which obviously you still can’t afford. Edit: actually looks like it’s the same thing in Texas, if you’re poor you don’t qualify. You have to have kids or be disabled. These are all the states that refused the federal funding for Medicaid expansion I guess.
- _bxg1 7y agoInteresting; I wonder if the kids thing is why I always hear from conservatives that medicaid is all we need in this area. "It's your fault for not wanting to start a family like a normal American."
- adventured 7y ago> Eg. In Florida no matter how poor your are you don’t qualify unless you’re disabled, have children, or are pregnant. There are 4.4 million people on Medicaid in Florida. That's about 21% of the population, which matches up with the national Medicaid figure of 22% of the US population.
- chessturk 7y agoHow does that relate? Grass is often green. So are leaves.
- sjg007 7y agoThis is why we should allow medicaid buy in.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 7y ago> In the U.S. we have Medicaid for low-income earners. So the bottom 20% the article mentions would largely qualify for free health care: Medicaid isn't necessarily free healthcare: “States can impose copayments, coinsurance, deductibles, and other similar charges on most Medicaid-covered benefits, both inpatient and outpatient services, and the amounts that can be charged vary with income. All out of pocket charges are based on the individual state’s payment for that service.” https://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid/cost-sharing/out-of-pocket-costs/index.html https://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid/cost-sharing/out-of-pocket...
- adventured 7y ago> Should they count this as "income"? You certainly could include that in the total government benefits category (including it into income is questionable and probably unnecessary), which is regularly done for example when tabulating individual conditions & resources that segments have access to. That picture gives you a combination of income, entitlements, welfare, etc. The US jumps off the page in this case however, as the US spends 10x or more per capita on healthcare versus Argentina. For example it would not make sense in the unusual US system, to ignore that the bottom ~25% get free healthcare (which is an extremely expensive social transfer). You would want to consider their healthcare picture when looking at their total condition. If you don't look at the comprehensive, then you would miss that the US welfare state has vastly expanded and improved over the last 20, 30, 50 years. That is, ignoring these details is only effective if you are dealing with an entirely stagnant system (not likely). I don't think anybody would argue that eg Russia pensions should be ignored when looking at any comprehensive view of their condition as a people. It's a fundamental part of their system, their social contract, and their well-being nationally.
- jandrewrogers 7y agoPoor people in the US, the demographic being discussed here, all have access to free medical care at the same clinics middle class people use. This is partly paid for by the government from taxes and partly subsidized by the non-poor users of medical services. I grew up very poor in the US. We never paid for anything healthcare related, and still have poor relatives receiving excellent free healthcare today.
- adventured 7y agoI second that. I grew up poor in the US as well and received entirely free healthcare. I have a few poor relatives that receive free healthcare now due to their low income status, it's quite decent. They get access to exactly the same system as anybody else until you get into the top ~20% or so that are buying another tier of healthcare (easier access to the best specialists and latest medtech & biotech is the primary gap).
- rgbrenner 7y agoFalse. Medicaid eligibility requirements vary by state. In Mississippi, for example, they cover children and pregnant women at roughly the same income level as other states... but the parents of those children aren't covered if the household makes more than $227/mo (+78/mo for each additional household member). If you don't have children? No coverage unless you're in a very specific category (disabled, covered by medicare, etc)... no matter how poor and destitute you are. https://www.healthinsurance.org/mississippi-medicaid/ https://www.healthinsurance.org/mississippi-medicaid/ Missouri: no medicaid if you aren't disabled or have children (and you're below 381/mo for a family of 3): https://www.healthinsurance.org/missouri-medicaid/ https://www.healthinsurance.org/missouri-medicaid/ Same in TN: https://www.healthinsurance.org/tennessee-medicaid/ https://www.healthinsurance.org/tennessee-medicaid/ Same in TX: https://www.healthinsurance.org/texas-medicaid/ https://www.healthinsurance.org/texas-medicaid/ Seriously, go through the states that haven't accepted the ACA expansion: https://www.healthinsurance.org/medicaid/ https://www.healthinsurance.org/medicaid/ These poor people are not getting Medicaid.
- jandrewrogers 7y ago
- akhilcacharya 7y agoThe website appears to be from some sort of right-libertarian organization, so I'm not surprised by this.
- ailideex 7y agoHow does the publisher of the article affect how surprised you are by anecdotes?
- akhilcacharya 7y agoThe agenda is clear enough to make it useless as a source of information. Just peeking at their position on birthright citizenship solidifies this
- Faark 7y agoThe funny part is the article at the same time arguing how much benefits people receive and thus them not being poor while at the same time pointing out the US is great despite social programs, heavily implying that it would be even better with even less taxation and less "government assistance programs" that provide "an incentive, and the means, not to work." I would find it a lot more fair to not counting all those benefits in my analysis, if I'd want to get rid of them.
- weare138 7y agoAs an American who's seen and experienced "the bottom 20%" in our country, this was my first thought. People in America "consume" more economically because it's our only option. If our cost of living is higher relative to our average income compared to other developed countries then of course more of our money is economically "consumed". Notice there's no mention or comparison to other key economic indicators like savings, quality of life and upward economic mobility. Statistically most of America's "middle class" lives paycheck to paycheck. According to a recent article on CNBC 60% of Americans couldn't afford an unexpected $1000 expense. "Just 40 percent of Americans are able to cover an unexpected $1,000 expense, such as an emergency room visit or car repair, with their savings, according to a survey from personal finance website Bankrate." https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/23/most-americans-dont-have-the-savings-to-cover-a-1000-emergency.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/23/most-americans-dont-have-the...