15 ms·
North American versus European distribution systems (2011)
- dillonmckay 7y agoThere was a sponsored ad below the article, ‘How to Make Electricity for Free.’
- bantunes 7y agoI block ads, but that kind of "chum" is horrible - here's an article with some info on it https://www.theawl.com/2015/06/a-complete-taxonomy-of-internet-chum/ https://www.theawl.com/2015/06/a-complete-taxonomy-of-intern...
- bognition 7y ago> For urban systems, the European system can take advantage of the flexible secondary; for example, transformers can be sited more conveniently. For rural systems and areas where load is spread out, the North American primary system is more flexible. I’ve often wondered how many of the differences between Europe and The United States are the result of population density.
- kwhitefoot 7y agoGood to see, at the end of the article, that there are people thinking about different voltages and more sophisticated systems for transforming voltages. Now that so many devices are capable of running at quite low power it might be worth using USB-C alongside the usual power outlets for more than just computers.
- pjc50 7y ago5V USB transformers embedded in sockets have definitely started appearing in the UK; I have some myself and they're convenient. If we were to embed anything new in the walls I think it ought to be Ethernet, then make people use PoE.
- yardstick 7y agoEthernet PoE is nice, but USB-C I can see as the future for most power requirements both because it can carry a lot of power and it has a small form factor (Ethernet is too bulky for more and more products these days). The biggest issue with USB-C is unfortunately the zoo of different options. Not all USB-C cables and ports support high power output and it’s not trivial to figure out what cable or port to use. So much for universal...
- wil421 7y agoUSB C cables are extremely expensive compared to Cat6 there’s no comparison. 802.3af can run 48v for 100m I doubt USB C can run that far. Power delivery is a non-issue most devices can handle POE just fine and I have 3 Cameras, 2 APs, a switch, and a Pi all running off a single 150w UniFi switch. If you need more power you can always build another regular outlet much cheaper than setting up USB C.
- zaarn 7y agoIf you solder a 802.4af to a USB C socket you can get the same distance at the same voltage. USB C no longer has a specified maximum length, the only requirement is that the signal makes it across.
- wil421 7y agoCan you even buy a splicer that will put on USB C ends? Doesn’t any cable just required the signal to be enough? I mean you could put Poe injectors or signal amplifiers for coax every X meters.
- zaarn 7y agoNot quite, the cable needs to be suitable for differential signaling and it has some tight inductance and RF property requirements, otherwise the wire just leaks all over the spectrum and doesn't work.
- 7y ago
- zzzcpan 7y agoNot really, just like it's not worth it having any power supply embedded into a power outlet. It's also a bit dangerous, it can malfunction and burn your place to the ground without triggering circuit breakers. Also USB-C power in particular is pretty inefficient by design, as having say a 150 watt power supply to efficiently deliver 5 watts of power is rather complex and expensive to achieve.
- mikeash 7y agoWhat makes the risk of malfunction higher compared to a standard power supply plugged into an outlet?
- zzzcpan 7y agoNo airflow for cooling.
- tomatocracy 7y agoAs sibling says, no cooling but also no easy way to disconnect the supply eg if it gets hot or starts smoking or sparking.
- the_mitsuhiko 7y agoI think from a practical perspective the biggest advantage of the European system is that every household gets three phases. This is I guess likely the reason you have many more gas stoves in the US than in Europe where you can easily install a high power electric/induction stove instead.
- chaz6 7y agoIn the UK we usually only get a single phase. They will alternate the the phases down the street to balance the 3 phases.
- tomatocracy 7y agoTo add - the standard UK domestic supply for new installations is 100A single phase and voltage is 240V at 50Hz (despite the standard saying 230V, the tolerance is 230+10%/-6% and the UK never changed its actual supply voltage) so this is plenty for most houses even if they are electrically heated and have all-electric cooking appliances.
- swebs 7y agoNah, natural gas is just so much cheaper than electricity in the USA.
- alkonaut 7y agoEven with the maintenance of the gas lines? Unless you use gas for something else (e.g. heating) then you have an opportunity to stop paying expensive gas line maintenance costs and use that money to buy more expensive electricity. That's what's happening in some city centers in Europe as fewer and fewer residents use gas, those that do need to share the maintenance costs for the gas network, which makes it more and more expensive to keep using it so there is a spiral of people leaving. In stockholm it's now north of $200/year for a studio apartment even before buying any gas. You get quite a bit of cooking electricity for $200!
- 7y ago
- _trampeltier 7y agoI think it is great to have everywhere a 3-phase system here in europe.
- adev_ 7y agoWhen you say "European", please also say "excepted UK" who (like usual) does things differently. E.g ring cabling. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_wiring_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_wiring_in_the_Uni...
- seszett 7y agoThe article doesn't talk about end-user cabling within a house or building, but about the design of the whole grid, which is similar in the UK and on mainland Europe as far as I know.
- sametmax 7y agoMaybe the article is trying to stay relevant in a few months :)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cameronbrown 7y agoLast time I checked UK will still on the European continent for the foreseeable future ;)
- mcv 7y agoIt's always been just off the continent. I think they'd sail away if they hadn't been tethered to us by that tunnel.
- decasia 7y agoConsumer-facing question: Does anyone know if the higher European voltage at the socket produces statistically more severe or more frequent injuries among consumers? The 240v plugs themselves are designed differently (wider spacing between prongs) which I imagine is partly because they're supposed to safely handle higher voltages…
- masklinn 7y ago> The 240v plugs themselves are designed differently (wider spacing between prongs) which I imagine is partly because they're supposed to safely handle higher voltages… It's mostly because they're supposed to be safe at all, which US plugs really are not. 230V (that's the actual EU voltage[0]) will break down poor insulation faster, but AFAIK that's about it, 15mA across the heart will kill you and neither has any issue with this. [0] ±6% officially, with byes to +6-10 and +10-6 so countries formerly 220±6 and 240±6 are "in-bounds" without having to overhaul their grid in the short-term — therefore effectively 230±10%
- iikoolpp 7y agoThe UK plug causes far less injuries than any other plug due to its incredible safety design.
- antisemiotic 7y agoI'm not from UK, but having seen the UK plug, I think that the most common injuries it causes would be blunt trauma and possibly stabbings.
- alkonaut 7y agoHaving 400V 3-phase is excellent for EV charging. Guessing any new garage construction in europe makes sure to put in a 3-phase socket. Lots of older houses like mine have their Tesla socket beind the stove and only 230V in the garage unfortunately.
- LIV2 7y agoFrom what I'm currently experiencing here (Sweden) three phases also allows for interesting issues like partial power outages that take down only some of your house... Never saw anything like this in Australia where it's probably the US style
- punnerud 7y agoAnd Norway (+Albania?) mostly have a system totally different than rest of the world called IT-system where there is no ground. This require two errors to be present (on different wires) to give a problem. It’s the same systems as used internal in hospitals.
- mariuolo 7y agoDoes having a higher voltage make a substantial difference in the quantity of copper used?
- ajuc 7y agoTwice the voltage - four times the power with same loses and same wire. And resistance is inversely proportional to the area of the cross-section of the wire. So, if you want the same power - you can use 2 times less copper with 2 times higher voltage.
- mariuolo 7y agoI understand that. Does it have a particular meaning on a large scale? I mean, is infrastructure overall cheaper in that regard? Are wires less likely to be stolen? Things of that sort.
- Glawen 7y agoFor sure it is cheaper. On the scale of a house, it is not so much, i spent maybe 300€ of wires alone for my house (mix of 1.5 and 2.5mm2). But you need also to add the manpower cost. With 240V 16A (standard for a 5 plug circuit) breaker you can wire your house with 1.5mm2 wires. For 20A you need 2.5mm2 wires, and for stove (32A) you need 4mm2. By experience, I can tell you that wiring your house with 2.5mm2 is way harder to manipulate (bending, taking turns etc...) than the flexible 1.5mm2, and you need bigger enclosure in the walls. Your electrician will charge you higher because of this. Edit: section for copper, with aluminium you need a higher cross section Edit 2: my god, in the US you need a wire awg12 (4mm2) for a 20A 120V plug, to have a mere 2400W. This can be wired in europe with 1.5mm2 wires on 16A breaker, and you have 3800W of useful power ! It must be a pain to be electrician in the US
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- danielneri 7y ago"Reference" is a little conservative. A majority of this post is copied right out of the Electric Power Distribution Handbook by T.A. Short.
- korethr 7y agoThis article seems to only cover the residential distribution system. I say that, because it covers the single phase, center-tapped 240V (120V-Neutral-120) that's conventional in North American residential circuits. However, in commercial buildings, I've seldom seen single phase 240/120V service from the utility. Rather, I've seen 3-phase 480/277V. If 208/120V is to be used, there's usually another transformer on premise to step down the voltages. I wish the article covered how the secondaries for commercial distribution was done as well, but at least its coverage of residential service is informative.
- Tharkun 7y agoI'm seeing some broad generalizations in this thread, and some downvotes in disagreement. Please remember that Europe is a big place, and is not necessarily homogeneous. There are large differences between countries, and sometimes between smaller regions within countries. Just because A has 3-fase power cookers, doesn't mean B does too, for example.