3 ms·
I don't really like the tone of this article. The linked document doesn't show anything evil; they're not saying "haha look at this terrible secret we're keepin
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
I don't really like the tone of this article. The linked document doesn't show anything evil; they're not saying "haha look at this terrible secret we're keeping" or "word came from above, let's not fix this problem" or anything like that. It's just a non-specific bug report that Cambridge Analytica might be doing something sketchy, where nobody really did anything for a few months because they couldn't figure out how to get more details.
They say there's a timeline conflict, but I don't get what it's supposed to be. The new information seems very consistent with Zuckerberg discovering the issue in December, unless he makes a habit of reading every JIRA ticket at the company.
- Havoc 7y agoNot gonna lie - I read that post and thought "yep thats a FB employee".
- ggggtez 7y agoMaybe you haven't worked in a big company: someone raises a thread that one of your users is crawling and stealing all of your data and you don't resolve it for 3 months? At minimum, "Facebook" knew about the problem for 3 months. If it wasn't raised to Zuck personally, it should at least have been handled by someone more quickly than that. FB claimed they didn't know about it, but they knew about it for at least 3 months before the guardian article. Don't get tricked by weasel words where Zuck pretends to have selective Amnesia. Maybe he knew, maybe he didn't. But multiple people knew, and there were multiple email threads about it. FB can't claim ignorance here.
- smsm42 7y agoSome of the employees had concerns about what CA is doing. Which btw didn't do much different from what many others were previously doing with FB data. That doesn't mean it immediately rose to CEO level and everybody in top brass knew everything about it. Of course, if whoever handled it knew then what they know now - that it'd be such a public issue - they'd escalate faster, but they didn't. As such, "Facebook knew" is a bit meaningless statement - "Facebook" is not one person, it's very many persons, and knowledge propagated through this number of persons over some time. They details how it happened may be curious, but there's no additional proof of anything or refutation of the statement that FB top brass didn't know about it - it very well may be that some people knew, but didn't report (yet) it to FB top brass, because they did not realize what exactly is happening and how important it is about to become.
- ggg3 7y agobut we do agree that this can be throw in the garbage because the real case is that the CEO didn't have data protections in place. he can claim ignorance but wont be able to down besides VP leve if we want to be realistic. either you handle the legal requirements or you hire someone, otherwise you are negligent and can't claim you didn't know the law. so discussion in this and every other individual casew is futile, as we should be discussing if data protections should be a given like health inspection or not.
- soraminazuki 7y agoIt doesn’t really matter how the chain of responsibility works within FB, or how many people “knew” about the incident. FB handles an amount of extremely personal data never seen before in human history. It’s their responsibility to act as quickly as possible to protect such data.
- abraae 7y agoI've seen many instances, even on HN over the last few years, of large companies with the most hideous security practices being told over and over again, and simply doing nothing. My guess (only a guess) would be that the inside of Equifax was a toxic mess where plenty of techies knew of the dangers well before their hack.
- dragonsh 7y agoAs I mentioned in my other comment, it might be the case in order to monetize users personal information Facebook enabled personal data feeds, without realizing it's use case. "Cambridge Analytica" is just one of the companies whose details are out due to political implications. I am still not sure if Facebook did anything to move away from monetizing user's personal information. Indeed after "Cambridge Analytica" added "WhatsApp" and "Instagram" as additional personal information collection data conduit. Still today the only business Facebook earns all it's revenue is providing user's personal data feeds to millions of companies, may be with some additional procedure to fulfill the law on paper not in spirit. So they might just be doing enough, so that they are not prosecuted. Its not a pro-active effort to move away from economy of selling user's personal information for profit.
- quietthrow 7y agoYour comment exposes that your view of accountability is different from how real world operates. Zuck certainly does not review Jira tickets. But at the end of the day he is the ceo and ultimately the responsible person for facebooks actions. This is a failure of facebooks internal processes that management chain failed to handle which he is ultimately responsible for.
- ckastner 7y ago> I don't really like the tone of this article. The linked document doesn't show anything evil; they're not saying "haha look at this terrible secret we're keeping" or "word came from above, let's not fix this problem" or anything like that. It may not show evil, but it does show negligence. (I'd even argue that it shows gross neglicence.) > It's just a non-specific bug report that Cambridge Analytica might be doing something sketchy, where nobody really did anything for a few months because they couldn't figure out how to get more details. When you suspect a client of doing something very sketchy with data entrusted to you, allowing the client to continue accessing the data is extremely questionable. And "not being able to figure out how to get more details" makes it even worse; far worse.
- jplayer01 7y agoI feel like you've watched too many movies. Evil in the real world often looks mundane and boring. It's "ah, it's not important, we have more pressing matters to handle" because privacy, rights, safety or lawfulness aren't prioritised institutionally. Or there's a deadline, sales targets, revenue, growth, etc. to hit and is it really so bad if we skip the checks on those crucial parts, because it worked out the last time. Why don't we loosen the requirements a bit so we can get those cheaper parts or labor?
- DataWorker 7y agoSo humans are innately evil? That seems like a rather dreary outlook.
- megous 7y agoHumans are capable of setting processes so that things like these can be escalated/investigated properly. Nothing innate about it.
- jplayer01 7y agoI think, fundamentally, that we're all capable of good and evil, and it doesn't make sense, in a lot of cases, to paint a single person as wholly evil. It's a combination of inherent personality traits combined with an environment that incentivizes and motivates certain kinds of behaviours and ways of thinking. In the right kind of system, evil is just the natural consequence and it's something we see every day, all over the world.
- monster99 7y agoI think that's pretty much par for the course if you look at human history. Given that our culture is being locked up and thrown away with infinite IP extension and the game industry has successfully stolen PC games for the last 20 years and we now have windows "as a service" in windows 10. Evil looks pretty much like our MO as a species.
- meowface 7y agoThis is a very weird form of evil, then. This appears to be an earnest investigation into whether CA was violating their policies, and they concluded they likely were and that it needed to stop. What else do you want from them? You could argue the platform itself did not have proper technical safeguards in place to prevent this, but it's actually quite difficult to automatically detect this sort of thing. I'm not sure how else it would've been uncovered without a manual investigation like this. You could argue that this is unsurprising given that Facebook's whole purpose is to harvest people's data, but that's nothing we didn't already know. This just feels like a clickbait story to me.