7 ms·
I hope this happens. Native Americans have unique challenges. A thing I ran across on twitter: Native Americans were being de facto disenfranchised because they
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I hope this happens. Native Americans have unique challenges. A thing I ran across on twitter: Native Americans were being de facto disenfranchised because they couldn't use a PO Box as an address for purposes of voter registration and the reservations they were on only had PO Boxes as addresses for the residents.
I am guessing that this wasn't conscious and intentional. I'm not suggesting some conspiracy theory to purposely disenfranchise them. But the sorts of issues Indigenous peoples face are not faced by most other Americans and they at least need a voice to begin educating the powers that be about ways in which their reality is overlooked and how this negatively impacts them.
- rayiner 7y agoThis varies by state, but note that, in North Dakota, for example, the 911 coordinator can have an address assigned in a quick process: https://vip.sos.nd.gov/pdfs/Portals/VotingInformationforTribalMembers.pdf https://vip.sos.nd.gov/pdfs/Portals/VotingInformationforTrib.... Voting in places that lack infrastructure people tend to take for granted (fixed addresses) definitely poses challenges that state officials must address. I suspect at least with larger reservations, progress could be made by delegating more control over voting and polling places to tribal governments. At the same time (as reflected in the comments below), people unfairly deride any sort of voter identification requirement as a conscious attempt at disenfranchisement, when in reality U.S. states have some of the laxest voter identification requirements in the world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_Identification_laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_Identification_laws. I voted recently in Maryland, and I was actually quite shocked and a little perturbed how little verification was performed at the polling site. (I didn't have to show ID, just wrote down my address. Anyone could've pretended to be me.)
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI was homeless for a few years. I'm abundantly familiar with how lacking the usual assumed default living arrangements can negatively impact one's life. I'm also quite clear that most of it was not some intentional effort to make my life unnecessarily harder. I certainly ran into genuine prejudice and discrimination, but most problems I wrestled with incidentally happened to be more challenging because my life didn't neatly fit standard assumptions. I've generally found it helpful in life to not assume malice where ignorance/obliviousness are sufficient explanations.
- toast0 7y ago> Anyone could've pretended to be me. And if two people claimed to be you, it would raise red flags. Although it would not be possible to annul the earlier vote, the incident would be investigated, and in all likely hood be a widely reported news item. In my recent memory, reported voter fraud has been in maybe a few broad categories: Communications intended to dissuade people from voting (a notice claiming the election was moved to another day) An ineligible person being allowed to register, but later determined ineligible and charged with a crime (a felon voting in a state where that's not permitted) Someone voting under the name of a dead person, usually absentee, usually a relative of the deceased. An ID requirement may solve the last one, if the fraud is happening in person, but not if absentee. And it might solve the hypothetical case where people are voting in other people's names. However, it causes real problems for people who have trouble getting a government ID. It might be reasonable to do it in concert with a program to ensure everyone can get an ID issued, but these initiatives have not often been done together. Imagine how hard it would be to get ID if you didn't have it already: if you need to go to a government office, I hope the bus goes there, because you can't drive without ID; if you don't have ID, it may be hard to get an official birth certificate, since a notary may be reluctant to certify they verified your identity; if you need to go to the records office in person, travel without ID is much more difficult; some people may not have had a certified birth, or may not know where thseir certified birth happened, or their birth name. Certainly, these conditions would bring challenges to many aspects of someone's life, but imparing their constitutional right to vote seems a step too far.
- Nasrudith 7y agoI suspect it is 100% intentional and they know exactly what they are doing sadly - property ownership or a fixed address is not a prerequisite to voting and it isn't permissible to establish new reasons for ineligibility. There is sadly a rich tradition of screwing people over and ignoring the plain text of the law.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoIt is also a decent control against voter fraud. Unless we get voter ID, a rather important one. Also, it occurs to me that representation is based on residency. A homeless guy in my city isn't necessarily a resident of exactly one district.
- joaomacp 7y agoEuropean here. Can't they just use national ID card like social security number? Here, every national has a unique citizen card, but in the US it's stranger, using driver's license since there's no citizen ID...
- DoreenMichele 7y agoSocial Security numbers aren't intended to be a national ID. Social Security cards have no address or photo. They just have your name and social security number. They are flimsy cardboard, not plastic, and I think they state right on it that laminating it invalidates the card. They aren't designed to be used like ID. They are designed to actively undermine attempts to use them as ID. The US is a long way off from a national ID.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SamReidHughes 7y agoWe've been doing just fine running elections for a couple centuries without a national ID card. I'd focus on voting machine and ballot security.
- save_ferris 7y agoThe US has a long history of disenfranchising voters of color, which continues to this day via gerrymandered districts. Not saying that’s explicitly what’s happening here but there’s quite a precedent for such a conspiracy.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoWhy don't they overcome their own challenges? Why don't the Amish have the same problems?
- evan_ 7y agothe Amish largely don’t vote
- SamReidHughes 7y agoThere are other problems, and they have nothing to do with the federal government. Well, I suppose all reservations could be dissolved.
- fzeroracer 7y agoAre you asking why they can't solve the challenges imposed upon them by the US government? Isn't that like asking a gay person why they didn't just legalize gay marriage on their own?
- adventured 7y agoThat is a terrible example to lean on. Gay people did exactly that. They organized, persisted and got gay marriage legalized, with relatively very little help (out of the total population) and an immense amount of resistance. The extreme majority were against them for decades. You can in fact get something legalized in precisely that manner as a tiny minority. You don't require a 50.1% vote to convince the Supreme Court to rule in your favor. The US is not a majority rule democracy. One person, one case, can change the country dramatically through the Supreme Court. Historically individual rights take precedence over whim-based mob rule in the US. If that were not true, gay marriage would probably still be illegal, as there remained a large amount of mob resistance to it when it was legalized.
- BurningFrog 7y agoDon't learn your civics on Twitter!
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI follow a number of indigenous individuals on Twitter because, according to oral family tradition, I'm part Cherokee. I learned this from actual Natives bitching about the problem. Seems like a perfectly fine source of information to me.
- BurningFrog 7y agoOK, if you follow an actual expert on Twitter, my hasty comment does not apply. I do the same thing.
- masklinn 7y ago> I am guessing that this wasn't conscious and intentional. I'd assume the exact opposite. We know for a fact that e.g. lawmakers have requested IDs listing classified by frequency of ownership / use, so they would allow and reject IDs based on which group used them most. This sort of strategy is perfectly in line with what Atwater explained in his infamous '81 interview: abstracted impact and plausible deniability (as long as the emails where you explain why you're doing this don't get leaked, and even then it might go through regardless).