5 ms·
The reason given was that only one woman submitted a proposal from over 250 submissions. Lots of discussion on twitter about how talks were chosen. Not many br
by sp332 7y ago
The reason given was that only one woman submitted a proposal from over 250 submissions.
Lots of discussion on twitter about how talks were chosen. Not many brought up the fact that the submissions process itself was apparently broken.
- abeisgreat 7y agoIf you read through the second link he mentions how he tried to work with the organizers to improve their submission process and reach more diverse speakers and they opted not to.
- ngngngng 7y agoThat's not what I read, I read in the second link that he wanted to cancel a bunch of the male speakers, and then have everyone work like mad to reach out to women to come speak. That's not a submission process at all. That's outreach.
- larkeith 7y agoAgreed that it's outreach, but it also seems necessary, unless <=0.4% of the PHP community is female (ratio of applications by gender).
- busterarm 7y agoI don't know about you, but if I paid to attend a conference because of a certain speaker or talk that gets cancelled, I'm probably pretty pissed and also probably out some money if I decide not to go.
- neilv 7y ago> That's not a submission process at all. That's outreach. A lot of conferences seem to have a sort of selective outreach component to their call for papers. Conference organizers will go and post the CFP in various forums from which they'd like to get papers -- particular programming language forums, particular theory or practice forums, particular universities, etc. Some of this seems creative, like "we'd like to get more foo-lang people involved with bar-con this year." All that sounds like selective outreach. If the conference values, say, diversity of background brought to the table, then those conference organizers could seek out and post the CFP in places that diversity might be found. One of the difficulties is that it's hard to know what all diversity you're missing out on (much of it isn't visible, and much of it doesn't have familiar labels), but other of the diversity omissions are glaringly obvious. Including the glaringly obvious omissions in one's outreach seems a good start.
- belorn 7y agoWould be very insightful to learn where they did seek out and post a CFP. From the article it implies they did not do that.
- mpweiher 7y agoHow “broken”?
- sp332 7y agoAfter a couple minutes of research, the lowest number I could find for women in CS was from https://web.archive.org/web/20141221112502/http://floss2013.libresoft.es/ https://web.archive.org/web/20141221112502/http://floss2013.... Without getting into how accurate it is, I'm just taking it as a very conservative estimate that 10% of OSS software programmers are women. So out of 250 submissions, we'd expect about 25 of them to be from women if the sample is unbiased. And the odds of having only one woman would be... not sure if I did this exactly right but something like (0.1 * (0.9 ^ 249) ) * 250 = 10 ^ -10. Kinda looks like the submission process was biased.
- LudwigNagasena 7y agoWomen are less assertive and more risk averse. This conference is not any different from any other conference, the field in the whole or society at large. This particular phenomenon was even highlighted in nature multiple times: https://www.nature.com/news/why-women-talk-less-at-conferences-1.16270 https://www.nature.com/news/why-women-talk-less-at-conferenc... https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07049-x https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07049-x
- javagram 7y agoThat assumes that women submit talks to conferences at the same rate as men. I doubt that’s actually the case. But 1/250 does seem very low.
- tzs 7y agoThe survey you cite that found 10.4% included software and non-software contributions (such as translators, documenters, community managers, etc.), and found that women contributors were much more likely to be the later. Other surveys, such as a 2017 survey of 5500 contributors to GitHub projects, put it at 3% women [1]. None of that is really relevant, though, because we aren't talking about a generic OSS conference. We are talking about a PHP conference. What is the percent of women who are PHP programmers? Actually, that number would not be all the useful, either. Such surveys are going to find out what percent of various groups use PHP. That would be somewhat useful for estimating what the conference attendees should look like. Conference speakers, on the other hand, should be people are are doing new things with or to PHP. That's going to be a much smaller group than the people who use PHP, and so is likely to have much more skewed demographics compared to the larger PHP user population. [1] https://www.wired.com/2017/06/diversity-open-source-even-worse-tech-overall/ https://www.wired.com/2017/06/diversity-open-source-even-wor...
- mopsi 7y agoAll his life, Shloime hoped to win the lottery. Each week, he’d pray to God intently, pleading that this be the week he’d finally win. For years he prayed for the lottery – but he never won. Finally one day, in the middle of Shloime’s fervent prayers, a heavenly voice was heard in the synagogue: "Shloime, buy a ticket already!"