4 ms·
You write: “Human beings are black-box algorithms; we can concoct plausible explanations for our behaviour, but there is abundant evidence that we don't actuall
by hhs 7y ago
You write: “Human beings are black-box algorithms; we can concoct plausible explanations for our behaviour, but there is abundant evidence that we don't actually know our own minds. I think our discomfort with black-box algorithms is essentially a reflection of our discomfort at the unknowability of the human mind.”
I tend to agree, and if you look from a species perspective there are boundaries to what other animals can also do. For instance, an ant can only do so much; they can do basic thinking and processing but they lack complex physiological structures and reasoning abilities, as far as we know, to concoct plausible explanations for their behavior. Humans can come up with explanations but it’s still hard for them to tap in deeper and ask those why questions.
On a scale of species reasoning ability complexity, I’m curious if there are other animals that have the capacity to engage with nuanced why questions. Any zoologists out there?
- deanCommie 7y agoI think that question inherently requires us to identify some subjectively fuzzy definitions for what are "why questions". It would be similar to how we have been adjusting our definition of what it means to feel pain. (particularly in the context of claims that entire animal species do not feel it, so there are no qualms about preparing them as food in ways that would be considered inhumanely cruel with others - see lobsters, crabs) Chimps recognize themselves in the mirror. So they have some theory of mind. Dogs don't, but unlike chimps, can follow pointing directions. So they have some theory of OUR mind. My dog is stubborn and doesn't follow some directions right away. I will sometimes see her pause, consider, and ignore the command. If I then remind her in a generic way that I am serious (like a stern generic "hey"), she will then come back and do the command. So it's more complex than a direct cause and effect. That also sounds like a "why" question that has gone through her head...
- hhs 7y agoGood to think about, thanks.
- joe_the_user 7y agoI don't think you can say that reasoning is quite true or false. The main thing about that argument is it compares apples and oranges. Human beings construct beliefs about each other's processes and provide reasons for actions which are far from scientifically accurate but which are crucial for us to operate together as a species - and our ability to operate together as a species has been key to our success, despite the many limits we have to our ability to operate. Which is to say we don't experience each other as black boxes (regardless of whether we really are these). We experience each are partial unknowns - people often do unexpected things but we often construct plausible after-the-fact explanations and those who consisting do things without any explanation make us nervous.