3 ms·
This topic has been discussed endlessly over the last 40 years (both by local social scientists and people trying to reproduce Silicon Valley elsewhere). The sh
by gumby 7y ago
This topic has been discussed endlessly over the last 40 years (both by local social scientists and people trying to reproduce Silicon Valley elsewhere). The short answer is “it’s a just so story commingling schools, openness, military boom...”.
One thing to notice is that plenty of industries have followed this pattern until they became mature (cars, breakfast cereals, aircraft to some degree). And you see this in software: the pressure discussed is at the frothy end of the market.
- iso-8859-1 7y agoI couldn't parse: > it’s a just so story commingling Explanations: In science and philosophy, a just-so story is an unverifiable narrative explanation for a cultural practice, a biological trait, or behavior of humans or other animals. The pejorative nature of the expression is an implicit criticism that reminds the hearer of the essentially fictional and unprovable nature of such an explanation. com·min·gle: mix; blend
- dreamcompiler 7y agoI know some of the answers but at what point does the cost of doing business in the Bay Area outweigh the benefits? Keep in mind when Silicon Valley began they were actually fabbing silicon. That doesn't happen in SV today (AFAIK). It's mostly software now, and software is much more portable than silicon.
- rficcaglia 7y agoIt happens but on a very small scale. Very niche fabs for stuff that isn’t at mass market scale.
- gumby 7y agoClearly the cost outweighs the benefits for run-of-the-mill software and hardware, as the majority of the world's code is written outside the valley, and most low end hardware is designed outside it as well. Also it's not worth it where the valley is behind the curve (e.g. engines are designed in different centers of excellence). Even for venture-backed (intended-to-be) high-growth companies, the Bay Area is only about 50% of all US venture capital investment. And there has been some spread: in my professional lifetime the "Valley" has grown to encompass SF and parts of the East Bay. When I first started working here people lived in SF and commuted to tech jobs in MP and points south. But some products are just so high margin (iPhones, Internet search, USB-powered vape tubes) that it's cheaper overall to be here and take advantage of the affordances available.
- Ericson2314 7y agoThe very short answer is social graphs are dense enough. Land use is important even if you have tons of land like the US.