30 ms·
So, if my view is that trans women should be called men, and I call a trans woman at my work a man, is this speech or an action? This is where I'm having diffic
by SolaceQuantum 7y ago
So, if my view is that trans women should be called men, and I call a trans woman at my work a man, is this speech or an action? This is where I'm having difficulty distinguishing speech and action.
- jimbokun 7y agoIn the US? Would be protected free speech, and the government cannot make any laws about it. For your company, though, they could fire you for violating their internal policies. To categorize the speech, I would say it's just being an asshole. Even if you believe biological sex is assigned at birth and is immutable, going out of your way to not address someone the way they wish to be addressed is just being intentionally rude. But even then, it's still speech.
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoSo is it okay that the company does not tolerate that view, even if that view is only expressed through speech? We're not in the context of a government, only an employer. Is that fine?
- jimbokun 7y agoThat is the way the US Constitution works, yes.