8 ms·
Go Scan 3D – Handheld 3D Scanner
- sansnomme 7y agoWhat SLAM algorithm do they use to achieve such high accuracy?
- iamleppert 7y agoThe accuracy they state is a maximum, it depends on how close you are to the object. The closer, the higher the resolution. It appears to be a structured light technique so it is limited by the resolution of the projector and camera setup.
- mysterydip 7y agoCan anyone suggest a hobbyist/entry-level 3D scanner? I have a 3D printer that I would love to replicate or modify some real-world objects on.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoPhotogrammetry apps are your best bet at the hobbyist level. Might be tough with some materials or shapes, but it isn’t going to set you back $35k. I assume it’ll only be a matter of time before this tech makes it into everyone’s smartphones. Sensors and algorithms are cheap. https://www.aniwaa.com/best-3d-scanning-apps-smartphones/ https://www.aniwaa.com/best-3d-scanning-apps-smartphones/
- speps 7y agoGot this in my emails recently: https://www.instructables.com/id/DIY-Budget-3D-Scanner-V3/ https://www.instructables.com/id/DIY-Budget-3D-Scanner-V3/
- cjbprime 7y agoI think for entry level there are lots of apps for Android/iPhone that are passable for small objects but time-consuming.
- skykooler 7y agoPerhaps check out https://www.open-electronics.org/an-open-source-3d-scanner-made-with-raspberry-pi/ https://www.open-electronics.org/an-open-source-3d-scanner-m...
- sleepysysadmin 7y agoYour cellphone. Iphone has the best 3d scanner apps, android has some good ones. They use photogrammatry and do a fine job.
- nickthegreek 7y agoThey all suck. I've tried so many from cellphones to $5k devices. Until you get into $20k systems, don't expect a workable scan that doesn't required many hours of CAD work for cleanup. Photogrammetry will be your best bet. Also not cheap. https://www.autodesk.com/solutions/photogrammetry-software https://www.autodesk.com/solutions/photogrammetry-software I would really suggest learning Fusion 360 for mechanical or blender for organic modeling and build from scratch. It's a great toolset to know and can be very rewarding. It will teach your core skills that you can apply all the time with your 3d printer. If you have never done any 3d work before, start with tinkercad.com until you feel comfortable.
- nategri 7y agoTangentially related but I've had a 3D printer for years but only just recently learned Fusion 360; it has been a real game changer in terms of the kind of projects I can tackle. Can't recommend it enough.
- womitt 7y agoShapr3D was the game changer for me - although you need an iPad pro for that one
- yardie 7y agoWhat did you use to learn F360? I’ve been meaning to get started for a minute. But when I have the time I tend to forget to fire up 360.
- nickthegreek 7y agoI used lynda.com myself. In many cities in the USA you can get free access to the site through your local library. I found it easier then searching for a video here and there on youtube.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- snovv_crash 7y agoFor $400 you can get the Occipital Structure Core [1] with Skanect Pro scanning software bundled. I've used Structure Cores for other purposes, and they seem pretty good. Not sure what your accuracy will be though. 1. https://store.structure.io/buy/structure-core https://store.structure.io/buy/structure-core
- Cyclenerd 7y agoCheck out https://github.com/alicevision/meshroom https://github.com/alicevision/meshroom Video tutorial from Prusa: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1D0EhSi-vvc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1D0EhSi-vvc
- gorkish 7y agoAt the hobbyist level currently the best results (in terms of cost/quality and time/quality and overall capability) can be achieved using photogrammetry in conjunction with processing in Meshroom and post processing in Meshlab or Blender or editor of your own selection. This works for really tiny stuff right up through drones scanning entire buildings, and the workflow is the same. That's not to say there isn't a knack to it or things you have to learn. But it's the right direction to explore right now. See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ye-C-OOFsX8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ye-C-OOFsX8 and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1D0EhSi-vvc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1D0EhSi-vvc for a quick intro. There are alternative workflows and "low cost" commercial hardware and software products even for photogrammetry in the market. Nearly every technique I have tried or seen produces a much lower quality result than the above, costs a lot more, or has some other limitation (such as the size of the object you can scan) that radically limit its usefulness. This is of course until you get to the high end scanners like the one linked here which use one or more high resolution LIDAR sensors in conjunction with cameras, lights, motion sensors, etc: alll selected and calibrated to give precision results. If you can stomach the price they are awesome. But to some degree, commercial solutions regardless of cost will often promise their output will require "no editing or post processing" You should be aware that this is total baloney. You will absolutely have to devote a little time and effort into learning how to edit, clean, and simplify meshes regardless of what you intend to do with them. All this being said, this advice only really applies to objects where 3d scanning has some merit. If you want to 3d print something like a replacement part for a broken appliance, often 3d scanning even with an expensive commercial scanner is not the best approach. Many times it's considerably faster to pull out a pair of calipers and simply model the object in some CAD software like Fusion360 or for real simple stuff, even TinkerCAD.
- ur-whale 7y agoMeshroom is really good, and it's even better for large scale stuff (like landscape / architecture reconstruction from aerial pics).
- gaze 7y agoNothing works. I promise. I’ve even used these extremely high end scanners like the creaform ones and they suck. Here’s how I get _good_ results on complex objects. Use agisoft photoscan, a cheap SLR and a stepper motor controlled turntable. You need to put all this in a photo tent and light it as flatly as possible. Then, you need to do surface prep. Spray your object with magnaflux spotchek. This is a white powder in acetone which will go down on the surface and make it temporarily matte. It wipes off when done. When you’re done, process the images, process the mesh, and pull it into Rhino to repair it. If you’re modeling for a functional replacement, pull out your calipers and take measurements and use your 3D scan essentially to pick off profiles that you can loft to remodel the final object. This shit is really hard.
- jefft255 7y agoWhat where you trying to scan that the creaform one couldn't handle? I've worked with them for metrology and they are really good.
- carriere4 7y agoIf you have access to an iPhoneX and some patience, Scandy Pro is worth a try: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/scandy-pro/id1388028223?ls=1 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/scandy-pro/id1388028223?ls=1
- russley 7y agoI had some minor luck with capturing 3D objects in Meshroom, then using Blender to refine/simplify the model, before taking it into Meshmixer to prepare for actual 3D printing. I don't know how phone cameras hold up, but I was able to achieve decent results with a DSLR and some daylight lighting.
- toddwprice 7y agoAs others have said, if you want to replace an existing part, it's probably actually better to redesign it. I use OpenSCAD to do simple 3D designs in code. It's easy to get started if you're a developer. As for scanning, I've used Trnio on iPhone for artistic scans. e.g. I scanned my dog and printed a tiny replica. My nephew thought it was a pile of melted yogurt, but I knew what it was. :-)
- alexschiff 7y agoCheck out Structure Sensor (structure.io) if you haven't yet. Full disclosure I work for the company that makes it :)
- knolan 7y agoThe Kinect is okay as a 3D scanner.
- TheRealSteel 7y agoThe Galaxy Note 10+ has one, but I don't know how good it is.
- coolspot 7y ago*Creaform technologies start at $35K.
- ShakataGaNai 7y agoAnswering the real questions. Thank you!
- nym 7y agoWould love to rent one then!
- tootie 7y agoThis one is $400. I've used it to scan people with pretty good results. https://structure.io/structure-sensor https://structure.io/structure-sensor
- groundlogic 7y agoReminiscent of the Logitech Scanman handheld 2D scanner from 1988 (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Logitech_ScanMan_32-Mus%C3%A9e_Bolo https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Logitech_ScanMan...), but now in 3D. (How is there not a Wikipedia article about this product? I bet deletionists are to blame.) I think this concept could eventually be a success just because it has the potential to be a lot cheaper than a fully automated/mechanized solution. Just like the Scanman was a lot cheaper compared to the very expensive flatbed scanners of the 80s. Smaller, lighter, zero/minimal amounts of moving parts, etc. Perhaps not good enough for professional use, but the pro market was kinda small anyway. I guess the endgame is that high-end 3d scanning functionality gets built into regular smartphones.
- rsp1984 7y agoI guess the endgame is that high-end 3d scanning functionality gets built into regular smartphones. We will likely see 3D sensors get embedded into smartphones very soon but there are substantial trade offs in terms of size, power consumption, cost and performance. Also the consumer use-cases for 3D scanning are quite unclear. Hence what's going to be in phones will likely be used for enhancing AR applications / "Lenses" (proven use case) as opposed to capturing an accurate 3D representation of the world.
- groundlogic 7y agoI think there are lots of clear consumer use cases for this. Like: a) Scan a friend's face/head and then use an app to replace the hairstyle with something different. b) Get a friend to scan your body (or scan your own feet) using your smartphone, then use that data to order custom outfits or shoes that fit perfectly.
- Gracana 7y agoI did some work to attempt this sort of thing using a kinect, back when they were newish. We were trying to automate the sizing of custom-fitted clothing. It was easy enough to get rough measurements, but very difficult to get repeatable and accurate measurements. I suppose if you were just looking to see which of a set of sizes would work best for a person, it might be easier. Also, today's technology is better and I didn't really know what I was doing. :) But still... fabric measuring tapes are cheap and easy to use, and they won't invade your privacy or try to sell you stuff like phone app developers inevitably will.
- Causality1 7y agoMuch like the 3D printer market of fifteen years ago, the problem isn't so much a lack of selection as the price. When out of the box 3D scanners get below $300 I'll get excited.
- alexschiff 7y agoHave you looked at Structure Sensor before? (structure.io) - it's $399
- Budabellly 7y agoI'm really curious to see how this would work on humans. It'd be great to see quality level similar to the Obama 3D scan available to consumers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpMOe7O88cY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpMOe7O88cY I've been hobbying around with Bellus3D's face app leveraging the iPhone's depth camera: https://www.bellus3d.com/faceapp/iphone https://www.bellus3d.com/faceapp/iphone
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoI had a Fit3D total body scan done at a local clinic when starting a weight loss program. I was surprised by the detail level for something that cost me $5/scan. I had to switch to wearing bicycle shorts during the scans because the first time I wore just underwear and the result produced an inappropriate amount of detail in that area. My plan is to 3D print my "before" body and display it in my exercise area to motivate me. Might have to make a pair of shorts for it to wear or edit out those details in the obj file.
- ChickeNES 7y ago> Might have to make a pair of shorts for it to wear or edit out those details in the obj file. I'd bet if you scaled it appropriately you could just buy some doll shorts from a thrift store or eBay
- knolan 7y agoIt would be interesting to split the models down the sagittal plane and join the left and right sides of before and after.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoThat's a pretty interesting idea. Can't see any reason why it wouldn't work. I'm only looking to lose 50 lbs so it probably wouldn't even need any additional rafting.
- jiveturkey 7y agoi had the previous generation of this device. incredibly good, but incredibly expensive and incredibly fragile.
- anibalfernando 7y agoSomething like this integrated in a smart glasses
- roywiggins 7y agothis thing is 2.7 pounds, so there's a bit of a ways to go on miniaturization
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThis would benefit from more threaded mount points. Presumably there's one on the bottom?