5 ms·
Because they have work to do. That's why they're there.
by BurningFrog 7y ago
Because they have work to do. That's why they're there.
- arcticbull 7y agoTheir job is to create a forum for others to debate, and to try and maintain neutrality. Their own politics aren't necessarily relevant. Everyone wants to be able to have their political opinions, try and convince others, and not get fired. It's kind of a pick-2 situation. Feel free to bring politics in with ya so long as you embrace the philosophy that you can say anything you want on your last day.
- root_axis 7y ago> Their job is to create a forum for others to debate, and to try and maintain neutrality What? Says who?
- arcticbull 7y agoOthers as in not their employees. Google indexes all the worlds information, who says their goal is to impose their opinion on it? Isn't neutrality in indexing the assumption?
- Nevermindmine 7y agoWhy would you assume that?
- cameronbrown 7y agoSpeaking for myself here. Yes and no. Ranking by definition means not being neutral, it's just that society has decided that it's acceptable to rank spam lower than other content. Neutrality looks a lot like bias from the perspective of spammers. When you're dealing with more complex signals at scale there are so many second and third order effects that are hard or impossible to predict. For example, the conservative bias everyone's talking about doesn't seem to me to be literal bias against the right, but bias in favour of mainstream news sources which are overwhelmingly left-wing. I'm sure there are many issues in Search like the one I just described, and being able to have these conversations is what makes it possible for Googlers to spot these issues, decide if it's even an issue and fix it. If you ban a certain type of conversation, you'll change how people think about a potential issue.
- root_axis 7y ago> Google indexes all the worlds information They do not collect anything even remotely close to "all the worlds information". > who says their goal is to impose their opinion on it Their goal is to make money. Whether they impose their opinion on the index is a business decision. > Isn't neutrality in indexing the assumption? Why would it be? What if the people that run google have a fundamental disagreement with certain political ideas and have a desire not to index those things?
- TheCapn 7y ago>Everyone wants to be able to have their political opinions, try and convince others, and not get fired. In fact, many people do not want to try and have others convince them of their political leanings.
- Aperocky 7y agoYeah, THIS. Trying to convince other people of MY political leaning goes against one of the central political leaning that I have: Everyone should have freedom to believe in whatever they want to believe in. I also find it annoying when other people try to shove their believe down my throat.
- bcrosby95 7y agoI try to view political discussions as helping to spread information and confront one's own biases. Most people don't seem to though. I've had people that I agree with politically on a subject yell and curse at me because I don't believe every bullshit "fact" they sling my way.
- refurb 7y agoExactly. If I'm working on a team that is rolling out a new Google drive feature, I really don't need to hear you talk about why drinking straws are a phallic symbol and used by the patriarchy to keep woman down. We have work to do.
- gwbas1c 7y agoI wish your comment was top level, because most of the comments in this thread are snarky responses that don't understand how politics turned Google's workplace toxic.
- arcticbull 7y agoI'm sure the oppressed party in your example feels the polar opposite and don't want to hear your whining about how feminism doesn't matter in modern society because it's good enough as is. And I think that's the point :)
- cameronbrown 7y agoI assume you're being sarcastic/exaggerating, but even so. This is just a perfect example of how polarised politics is today. Society just needs to calm down and evaluate itself instead of bickering over nonsense.
- TheGRS 7y agoYes, every meaningful change in society has come to light because everyone calmed down enough.
- cameronbrown 7y agoHow is meaningful change in society related to shipping Google Drive features? Time and a place. Politics has no nuance or filter anymore. It's all the time on full blast, forever. I hate it.
- 7y ago
- SkyBelow 7y agoIt would be up to the details of their individuals contracts. It would be possible for someone's contract to either directly (unlikely) or indirectly (far more likely) allow for debating of politics to some degree. That freedom would be part of their compensation package, though one often not considered in simple models. I think Google is realizing they have undervalued the cost to them of allowing such an action and want to renegotiate. Since it is likely an indirect benefit, this would largely be done by changing corporate rules and culture concerning politics where workers could respond in numerous ways. While it is possible for a contract specifying 8 hours of work without a single thought other than work (and any legally mandated breaks) in exchange for the given salary and benefits, I've never seen any organization that actually operated using such contracts.
- jackcosgrove 7y agoI think there are a lot of reasons someone at work may not be doing work, that have nothing to do with talking about politics. BRB...gotta get to work ;)
- gaze 7y agoYes but what work? Should that work be done? Google just wants everyone to be good little soldiers and do what they’re told.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 7y agoWhen you organize the worlds information, then some amount of politics is a necessary part of the job. The product you are selling is built by political talk. To give a fairly tame example. Lets say someone googles "Can crystal healing cure cancer". Do you put a box saying no? Do you put put a box saying "according to authority it does not". If you defer to authority to do you defer to different one in different countries? What if they disagree? Maybe we need a list of FUBAR countries?