3 ms·
As much as SHAKEN/STIR is a fun tech, I think the article misses the part which will actually hurt the callers: > Require Traceback Cooperation in Contracts. F
by viraptor 7y ago
As much as SHAKEN/STIR is a fun tech, I think the article misses the part which will actually hurt the callers:
> Require Traceback Cooperation in Contracts. For all new and renegotiated contracts
governing the transport of voice calls, use best efforts to require cooperation in traceback
investigations by identifying the upstream provider from which the suspected
illegal robocall entered its network or by identifying its own customer if the call originated
in its network.
This is the amazing low-tech solution: It basically means companies will stop ignoring what they knew is happening for ages. As long as LE takes on the uncovered sources, I feel like this is the most important principle.
- reaperducer 7y agoI'd have more faith in it if it didn't include the phrase "use best efforts."
- jerf 7y agoI'm pretty sure that's basically lawyer-speak for "you can't sue us if a robocall gets through; we never committed to anything". Don't worry about it, if they follow through and it works it won't have meant much if they said that.
- vageli 7y ago> Don't worry about it, if they follow through and it works it won't have meant much if they said that. That's a pretty big if though, and if it doesn't work that statement precludes recourse.
- jerf 7y agoThey were never going to give you recourse anyhow. They'd be idiots to do so. I certainly would not be willing to personally guarantee that hostile, intelligent human beings will not find some way past the security I implement. I'd love to be able to, but when the opposition is as smart as you and generally endowed with more time and motivation, giving out lots of recourse if they do manage to score some points is a fast route to bankruptcy. If you think about it, most of our normal concepts of "recourse" involve things entirely under the other party's control, and in serious contracts, still often have a call out of "acts of God". It'd be like a football team offering legal recourse if the other team wins; not the brightest move.
- Scoundreller 7y agoIn other words, don’t transport calls coming from “bad neighbourhoods”. Just like blocking .ru IPs or non-ARIN IPs on your local theatre blog.
- viraptor 7y agoNo, I'd really disagree with that comparison. You don't block countries in telco. You can penalise telcos with too high ratio of spam calls with higher rates for example, but that's completely different from blocking whole country which will send you legitimate traffic and you'll be losing customers over it.