4 ms·
Palantir is a software company right and sells tools to ICE? Does someone wearing an Excel shirt make you uncomfortable because ICE uses MSOffice? What about O
by prepend 7y ago
Palantir is a software company right and sells tools to ICE? Does someone wearing an Excel shirt make you uncomfortable because ICE uses MSOffice?
What about OSS projects like R and Python that also enable ICE to analyze data to find people.
Is the expectation that Palantir should not sell software to ICE?
- matchagaucho 7y agoThe difference is in Pro Services. MS does not send employees from Redmond to help ICE use Excel. Palantir does bundle software and services. Their software is so complex, it is typically Palantir employees building the models and analytics.
- prepend 7y agoMS has professional services and they do send people to ICE to help use Excel. They also have an extensive partner network. Any large software company sells consulting services. I don’t know about Python, but RStudio sells professional services to help with use of R.
- the-dude 7y ago> and they do send people to ICE to help use Excel. source
- TallGuyShort 7y agoI think the expectation is that Palantir should make lots of money selling software to other people, and then a portion of their profits and employee's salaries is required by law to go to funding ICE anyway. That seems to be what everyone else is okay with.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoMost enterprise software sales aren’t as low touch as an Excel license, and Palantir is very much on the high touch side of the spectrum. When Palantir sells software to a large government agency, that means squads of Palantir employees go to the government agency and help them run it, and that consulting effort is a huge component of what the customer is paying for. Having said that, some people do think Microsoft should refuse to sell to ICE too.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- analogist 7y agoSo you think there is no difference in guilt between being a war criminal’s arm dealer and being a war criminal’s grocer?
- navigatesol 7y ago>So you think there is no difference in guilt between being a war criminal’s arm dealer and being a war criminal’s grocer? No, can you explain it? It sounds like a way to justify to yourself that "those people are bad", but you're "just doing your job". Are you principled about who you do business with, or not?
- nailer 7y agoI might be really uneducated here - I'm not American. All I know about ICE is that they're immigration and customs enforcement - they're basically the US's border force. The quality of the conditions they keep migrants in is poor, and has been for years. OK. Why is that worthy of a boycott? Your democratically elected governments create the laws, and determine the funding for things like beds and toys etc. Boycotts in some cases may make those conditions worse instead of better. There will always need to be a border force. Wouldn't it be better to focus on improving conditions, increasing funding, and stopping people from crossing the border in the first place?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoICE isn't the border force. All border security operations, stopping people from crossing and customs inspections and such, are done by a different agency called CBP.
- nailer 7y agoOK. Why not change the law, if you want to make undocumented migration legal?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoMost people trying to boycott ICE don't think undocumented migration should be legal. They just don't think ICE is a good agency. (Again, ICE is not the only agency responsible for undocumented migration, so undocumented migration isn't automatically legal if they can't do their job.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- _bxg1 7y agoThe expectation is that companies like Palantir should not exist at all. Their core business is surveilling innocent people en masse.
- prepend 7y agoThat is not their core business. Their core business is data analysis. If I remember from some tech book, they were spun out from the fraud department in PayPal detecting fraudulent transactions and then selling services to FBI. I became familiar with them through their disease prevention activities trying to evaluate bug transmissions and food borne diseases. Certainly, you can analyze innocent people, but it’s not like they are a face recognition camera company or something. I’m not employed by Palantir and not a fan or anything, but am surprised at how mischaracterized they seem to be.
- notJim 7y ago> Their core business is data analysis. This is like saying Raytheon's core business is antennas. Yes, Palantir does data analysis, specifically for ICE, the military and the police.
- prepend 7y agoPalantir is private so hard to know revenue breakdown. But hard to believe that over 50% of their revenue (what I would consider core) comes from ICE, military and police. I found this article [0] from 2018 that said half of its $1B in revenue comes from government and the other half from corporate. So if every penny of government work comes from ICE and ICE-likes maybe that’s core. [0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-01-16/palantir-posted-nearly-1-billion-in-2018-sales-executive-says https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-01-16/palantir-...
- tzakrajs 7y agoWhat if the other corporations they serve are subcontracted by LEO, ICE and CBP? Palantir is deeply in cahoots with CBP/ICE and Peter Thiel (isn't even a US Citizen so I can't even call him a traitor, but) is an enemy of the American people. Fuck ICE, Fuck Palantir, Fuck Peter Thiel
- rtkwe 7y agoIs it not easy to see that there's a moral space between creating a tool that can be used for something you dislike (basically all software falls into this category) and working specifically for a company making software that will explicitly be used for something you dislike?