4 ms·
The best explanation I've heard for negative rates is this: Imagine you have a million dollars worth of cars. If you want to store that in a bank, you'd pay t
by jedberg 7y ago
The best explanation I've heard for negative rates is this:
Imagine you have a million dollars worth of cars. If you want to store that in a bank, you'd pay them money to do so. Why? Because the car has no value to the bank. The only thing they can do is store it in the vault, which requires security personnel, space, climate control, etc.
Now instead you have a million dollars in cash. In the current environment, where more people want to put money into the bank than take it out, the cash also has no value to the bank. They can't loan it out again because no one wants to borrow that much. So they charge you for storing your money. This is how they make a profit. By slowly taking your balance, since they can't make money loaning it out.
A negative interest rate basically means more people want to save money than spend money. When the government offers negative rates, it's because they want people to spend money instead of save it. When a bank does it, it's because more people are putting money in than taking it out.
- duxup 7y agoI have some visibility to a tiny community bank started by some folks and then grew into a larger bank over time. They were mostly a consumer bank (consumer banking, small business type loans, etc) with some side banking related activity. Paradoxically (well seemingly so) the best time for them to buy or merge with other small community banks was if there was an area they wanted to be in ... that was doing well economically. That was the time to look around at the local banks that they might want to pickup, or those banks actually came to them. Local small (usually rural / suburban) community banks would find themselves in a bad spot as the locals were doing well financially, paying off loans early, not really borrowing much, and the locals with their extra money started stuffing it into the local bank. Businesses expanded, but they were able to do so with short term or very limited loans. The local small bank found itself flush with cash, and nobody who wanted it (well not nobody but you get it). That was the time for the other bank to swoop in and save them as they could provide a larger regional reach (and some side businesses that benefited from being backed by all that cash) to areas that still wanted that money for loans.
- booleandilemma 7y agoThanks for your explanation, I think it helps me to understand what’s happening a little better. But how can I reconcile what you’ve said with articles like this?: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/15/bankrate-65-percent-of-americans-save-little-or-nothing.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/15/bankrate-65-percent-of-ameri...
- icelancer 7y agoTwo things: 1) That's America. Europeans actually save money. 2) This isn't about retail investors (normal people). These bonds are for governments, large corporations, huge business deals, etc.
- samsonradu 7y ago"It used to be a respectable thing to save money, now you're just hoarding cash!" - @Hipster_Trader
- Dylan16807 7y agoA fun comment, but it's a really easy paradox to solve. If you have less than 1 million dollars you should be saving money. If you have more than 10 million dollars you have too much money.
- Spooky23 7y agoThe easier explanation is what it is... deflation.
- jedberg 7y agoA lot of people don't really understand what that is either though...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- solatic 7y ago> They can't loan it out again because no one wants to borrow that much. Which is why this is a signal that the economy is failing. The underlying behavior which drives the value of currencies is that the currency is being used. If people just stockpile cash then the value of that cash is eroding as people find fewer uses for it. Since the productive use for debt is as an engine for growth, if there isn't anybody looking to secure debt for growth then we're seeing the long-term effects of a loss of dynamism in the economy, which is detrimental pressure on the underlying economy itself. It's not sufficient to try to persuade people to spend more on consumption (people are always incentivized to consume) - people need to be incentivized to take risks for growth, which they currently are not. What the central banks will realize is that you can't incentivize people to take risks by holding a financial gun to their heads - that only incentivizes people to seek further safety. You need to, perhaps paradoxically, make it safer to take risks. If the ordinary control for doing so (reducing interest rates) isn't working, then there's a compounding factor which is preventing that safety from being felt.