4 ms·
I really don't understand the negativity on HN towards WeWork. In principle, how it is different than AirBnB or Uber in regard of being a tech company? It's no
by mrtksn 7y ago
I really don't understand the negativity on HN towards WeWork.
In principle, how it is different than AirBnB or Uber in regard of being a tech company? It's not like Uber or AirBnB's core compentancies are tech, I'm sure WeWork can also build a dev team making frameworks and research that some day might be used in their core business.
The article argues that the difference is that Uber, AirBnB, Yelp, Twitter is a tech company because they have "scalable virtual models that can be exponentially magnified overnight with little additional costs" but this seems to bu untrue since they did not took over the world. Maybe they are just humble but I think it's simply that their business model is "low touch high scale" and this is being mistaken with Microsoft's ability to develop technology and sell it infinite times with at no addditional cost per copy.
What stops WeWork from embracing the Uber model? Maybe you have an empty flat, you can turn it into WeWork location by furnishing the place according to the WeWork standarts and install some kind of kiosk and smart lock system. Uber makes the driver to use cars that obey certain standarts, why wouldn't WeWork do the same and "scale overnight"?
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoIt's different because according to the filing, the founder's relationship with the business - and its finances - is best described as "very unusual."
- marcinzm 7y ago>What stops WeWork from embracing the Uber model? Maybe you have an empty flat, you can turn it into WeWork location by furnishing the place according to the WeWork standarts and install some kind of kiosk and smart lock system. Uber makes the driver to use cars that obey certain standarts, why wouldn't WeWork do the same and "scale overnight"? Everything is possible but that's worthless until someone actually does it. Uber, AirBnB, etc. have already done those things. WeWork hasn't. Until it does, it's perfectly valid to say it hasn't proven it can and to assume it can't.
- the_gastropod 7y ago> In principle, how it is different than AirBnB or Uber in regard of being a tech company? It's not like Uber or AirBnB's core compentancies are tech, I'm sure WeWork can also build a dev team making frameworks and research that some day might be used in their core business. Some day, maybe they could?! But their current business is selling short term office space leases. They have massive liabilities in their long-term leases. If Uber (an absurd business in its own right) bought all the cars and paid their drivers salaries, that'd be a closer approximation to what WeWork is doing. It would be just another taxi company, and worth at least an order of magnitude less than it is today.
- insulanus 7y agoGood description. Uber is making use of people's free time, and their car (a very expensive asset) at low rates. They can cut or hire a driver at any time, and they also control the pricing both ways. WeWork only controls pricing on the customer side, and office space leases are way more cumbersome than the Uber driver contract (I shudder to think what that looks like).
- mrtksn 7y agoMost technology IPO were of companies that were losing money, people bought what they might become one day. Nothing new here, maybe they will change the way they operate when they establish the brand and optimize the operations.
- human20190310 7y agoThe depth of the hole they're in at IPO time has some bearing as to whether or not they'll climb out of it.
- mrtksn 7y agoBut this doesn’t say if they are a tech company or not. If you think that it’s a bad investment simply don’t invest? Why is the “WeWork ain’t tech company” uproar?
- the_gastropod 7y agoIt seems like you're just not listening. They're not a tech company because they, while they may use software for some things, it's not their differentiator. Tech companies are valued at higher multiples because software doesn't deal with scarcity. It costs Microsoft virtually nothing to sell an extra copy of Windows. So each extra sale is pure profit. WeWork sells OFFICE SPACE—something with real world scarcity, and each additional sale / customer they get has very real costs and overhead associated with it.
- 7y ago
- ZiiS 7y agoIsn't the point that they are not doing the things you say? If they did (siccessfully) they may well deserve a higher multiple.
- cushychicken 7y agoTwo reasons: 1) They've accrued a lot of large financial obligations in their quest to secure office space. There's a lot of concern that these obligations will only grow worse due to the terms of the contracts, or an economic downturn. 2) Their relationship with their CEO seems to have veered more in favor of his personal benefit than sound corporate governance.
- lilbobbytables 7y agoAirBnb and friends could not exist without the basic tech. they're tech doesn't need to be groundbreaking, but in the very least they're an e-commerce like platform of sorts. At WeWork tech is so secondary to their requirements. Sure, they can make it more and more required -- just like fridges do these days. But for WeWork the tech is about as necessary for you to derive value as a touchscreen on a fridge is necessary for you get get value from the fridge. _Just because it relies on technology doesn't make it important to it_
- Fej 7y ago> Maybe you have an empty flat, you can turn it into WeWork location by furnishing the place Zoning, perhaps?
- mrtksn 7y agoSo? AirBnB has the exact same problem with regulators. Uber is in trouble with taxi regulations in major cities.
- dumbfoundded 7y agoThe primary difference is the marginal cost of an additional customer. The definition of a tech company (at least for investors) isn't really about technology, it's about a near $0 marginal cost of adding an additional customer. A great example of this is Facebook. For someone to sign up and start using Facebook, it really doesn't cost Facebook anything. Facebook probably only thinks about scaling in terms of orders of magnitudes. Uber/AirBnb and other double-sided marketplaces debatably meet this definition. For these types of companies, the marginal cost of a new customer is $0. But these types of companies also have to onboard providers. Much of this is onboarding is automated but it can still require human intervention. Still, it's very cheap to onboard, there's not really any sort of capital expenditure that goes into scaling the provider side. WeWork obviously has a giant marginal customer cost. This is the fundamental criticism of their business model. Lots of successful businesses like Amazon can do this but it appears like WeWork doesn't have any sort of scales of economy. For Amazon, you can put more products in the same warehouse, you can build warehouses closer to customers for faster shipping. WeWork pretty much can just open new locations with the same model. Note that WeWork is trying to expand into other markets like gyms to get some of these benefits but whether or not this is a scalable business model is debatable. So far, it hasn't worked and there's not a great indication it will. You mention that WeWork could change its business model to get better scalability. Of course they could change it but so could a well-funded startup. So could AirBnb. Frankly, it's a hypothetical that isn't proven out. Basing a valuation on a what-if that isn't a natural extension of what they're already doing is extremely risky. To do what you're saying, WeWork would basically have to start from 0, maybe with some expertise about what customers want. AirBnb could immediately launch the same service with 10,000 locations by leveraging their existing hosts. How they got a $50B valuation seems deceitful and ridiculous. They conflate using technology and modern appeal with technology business models. Currently, WeWork does not have any business model that could be considered $0 margin customer cost. Maybe one day they could find one. Probably not.
- fl0wenol 7y agoWould you consider a company like Ticketmaster a tech company in that case? What about pre-merger DirecTV? (In the former case I think it pretty much meets the definition but is not traditionally thought of in this way; in the latter I think they are very dependent on low-margin but non-zero scaling but clearly tech-enabled in the same Netflix has become)
- kevin_b_er 7y agoNo the Uber/AirBnB model is to mask and hide risk offloaded to members of public, while simultaneously using apps to bypass regulations on where and how businesses normally operate. They work by committing frequently illegal acts, organized by apps, in such a way as to put the majority of risk upon "independent contractors" rather than themselves. Now you might point out how WeWorks' shell corporations for each property might act similar, but that's big landlords and banks getting screwed over when WeWork goes under, not individuals. Though individuals might get screwed over in the stock market by giving money to the founders and investors through IPO, but at least if they'd actually read through the hype before investing..
- paxys 7y agoUber, Lyft, AirBnb etc. offered technology as their major differentiator when they entered large, already established industries. They are all pure online marketplaces, and don't deal with physical assets, inventory, contracts or whatever else. WeWork is different because its primary day-to-day operations consist of purchasing/renting/renovating/managing offices. Yes it could pivot to an Uber model in the future, but we are evaluating all of them as they stand today.