6 ms·
CentOS 8.0 is almost ready
- llarsson 7y agoCan someone weigh in on why CentOS lags behind Red Hat? CentOS is blessed by Red Hat these days and I was under the impression that packages are essentially new compiles from the same sources as Red Hat. What causes delays? (Asking out of pure interest, not malice in any form.)
- tejtm 7y agothey do not move fast and break (your) things
- robohoe 7y agoI suspect it's because it takes time to remove references to Red Hat in packages (licenses, any proprietary bits, etc).
- electronstudio 7y agoSince Red Hat make Red Hat and Red Hat also make CentOS, could Red Hat not simply ask Red Hat not to put in those references in the first place? Or when they do put them in to always include a flag to easily remove them?
- da_chicken 7y agoWhy ever would they do that? The purpose of RHEL is not to build CentOS. It's to sell RHEL. Red Hat helps with CentOS because CentOS drives business to RHEL. That doesn't mean that Red Hat benefits by diluting their branding. Red Hat didn't become the biggest name in enterprise Linux by not putting their name on the product they're selling.
- bluedino 7y agoA CentOS major release takes a lot of planning and changes in tooling as it is based on a much newer version of Fedora than previous versions. This means that everything from the installer, packages, packaging, and build systems need major overhauls to work with the newer OS. This means that there is always a ramp up period depending on the changes needed to make a rebuild work. The differences between EL-8 and EL-7 are no exception as the kernel has changed drastically, the repository format has added 'modules' and RPMS have grown many features that EL7 and before do not have. About the only item which has not drastically changed between EL7 and EL8 is the init system which is still systemd. [This is a first as EL5 had SysV, EL6 had Upstart, and EL7 had Systemd]. https://wiki.centos.org/About/Building_8 https://wiki.centos.org/About/Building_8
- robbyt 7y agoThis doesn't really answer the question...
- washadjeffmad 7y agoIt did well enough? OP didn't ask why this release in particular seemed to lag behind more than other releases. The answer to that was provided generally, but it's because CentOS had to redo their entire build system for 8.
- Avshalom 7y agoThe other half of the question is why centos has to wait until after RHEL8 is released to start the work instead of being given a month or two advanced access given their (quasi?) official status these days
- nineteen999 7y agoI'm just speculating, but given that CentOS is (historically) pretty much identical for the most part to RHEL without the high licensing cost, there is little incentive for Redhat to ensure it is always available in lockstep with RHEL. They make a lot of money from RHEL licenses so why give a clone of it away on day one of a major release.
- dimitar 7y agoThe general steps are in the article, which seem like little work but this is a community effort, so it takes a while. Basically its rebranding, setting up build systems and doing QA on the changes.
- chasil 7y agoThere is no central organization that is writing checks for the work in CentOS; this is being done either by volunteers, or by organizations which have loosely-aligned goals. Oracle completed and announced their clone of Red Hat 8 on July 18th: https://blogs.oracle.com/linux/announcing-the-release-of-oracle-linux-8 https://blogs.oracle.com/linux/announcing-the-release-of-ora... Oracle is generally faster than CentOS in reissuing upstream changes, and perhaps CentOS as a project was able to take some direction from the results of Oracle's speed and focus.
- tw04 7y ago>There is no central organization that is writing checks for the work in CentOS What are you talking about? Redhat acquired the CentOS project and hired the developers as full time employees dedicated to working on CentOS. There is absolutely an organization behind it and it is 100% not made up entirely of volunteers. https://lists.centos.org/pipermail/centos-announce/2014-January/020100.html https://lists.centos.org/pipermail/centos-announce/2014-Janu...
- chasil 7y agoI was not aware of that. Thank you for the information. In that case, I have no idea why there is an extensive delay.
- ch_123 7y agoI suspect that they want to keep their infrastructure and processes loosely coupled to the upstream to maintain independence. Given the fate of certain open source projects affiliated with large corporations (Sun's ones in particular come to mind) I think this is a prudent course of action.
- pkaye 7y agoI think Red Hat isolates the Red Hat Linux development from CentOS to better differentiate it to their corporate customers. Basically they post the source packages and the CentOS team does their own thing.
- vbezhenar 7y agoIt seems that they are not blessed by Red Hat as much as you might think. It's still community effort based on published sources. They don't have access to some secret know-how or some kind of closed early access to unpublished work.
- aj484 7y agoSystemd still breaks everything.
- effnorwood 7y agoGoody.
- dang 7y agoSince threads about incremental releases are inevitably discussions of the general product, we can wait until the release is ready.
- donmcronald 7y agoI've always found the relationship between RHEL and CentOS to be a bit odd. Ignoring the technology side of things, where I prefer some of the RHEL philosophy, using Ubuntu to gain the option of paid support makes a lot more sense, doesn't it? How would I switch from being a CentOS shop to a RHEL shop if I all of a sudden find myself needing support?
- derekp7 7y agoI believe you can switch your yum (or dnf) repository to point to a Red Hat source, then use yum to reinstall all your packages from the RHEL equivalent. There's a couple tutorials out there for it, and once finished your system will look indistinguishable from the RHEL version. Of course, if you are running your systems using modern devops design principles, then you can redeploy your infrastructure based on RHEL repositories instead of CentOS.
- bluedino 7y agoI don’t get why anyone would use CentOS if they didn’t have to for some reason. I can understand using Redhat for “company” reasons, but why restrict yourself by running CentOS if you don’t have a real reason to?
- ch_123 7y agoI would be inclined to see it the other way around. In most of the places where I have worked, there are enough people to provide support and build custom packages for the CentOS that paid Red Hat support makes little sense. As to why you would use it vs other Linux distributions? It's well supported by commercial software, server hardware, and there's a large pool of people with Red Hat certification which is directly applicable to CentOS. It's also pretty mature and not prone to sudden changes. I would imagine that most RHEL customers are to be found in more conservative sectors of business, but that could just be my personal biases :)
- chasil 7y agoExasol loves CentOS. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exasol https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exasol Let me show you how much they love CentOS: http://www.tpc.org/tpch/results/tpch_result_detail.asp?id=119070902 http://www.tpc.org/tpch/results/tpch_result_detail.asp?id=11... Exasol and CentOS are alone in TPC-H database performance. There is no other competitive player.