7 ms·
The Financialization of the American Elite
- themark 7y ago“Hedge funds, private equity firms, and investment banks are just the first order players.“ Aren’t these all basically the same thing?
- pzone 7y agoQuick rundown: - Private equity firms invest in businesses that are not publicly traded. For example, they invest in startups that are seeking to grow and eventually IPO. - Investment banks help existing firms undertake financial transactions such as issuing new debt or new shares, and serve as brokers for e.g. sales of small businesses to new owners. - Hedge funds make speculative bets on existing financial assets they believe are over- or under-priced.
- refurb 7y agoThey all invest, but not in the same things necessarily.
- tlb 7y agoI rarely buy the "deeply flawed messenger" argument. Here, he's basically criticizing short-term business thinking, which he also took advantage of as an investor. Should we therefore put him in a hippo crate? Few people in the tech community say "This guy exploited a security bug. Therefore, we shouldn't listen to his bug reports." In fact, you can't really understand a bug except by trying to exploit it. I suspect the same is true in business. Everyone agrees vaguely that there's some kind of short-term thinking problem in big American business. But this guy understood the problem deeply enough to exploit it, while everyone else just is just waving their hands. I think PoC||GTFO applies to business advice too.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoI agree. It seems like this dude is coming to terms with his mortality and is realizing he's spent his life exploiting the system without trying to make it better and is trying to do something to make it better.
- word-reader 7y agoIt's demonstrated later in the article that he continued to take advantage of short-term business thinking with probable bad externalities all the while and after he was trying to repair his reputation with his Harvard donations and conciliatory speeches. In particular, the argument is that the critiques offered in conferences like this are insincere and aimed at preserving the insiders' status rather than actually changing any of the things they're talking about: "His career tells us how he would advise those beginning their careers to navigate these challenges: Loudly criticize political dysfunction, but make no effort to explore its structural causes or remedies...[his] prominence conveys that incongruence between words and actions is tolerable, even desired." And further, that it would be "foolish to listen" to said finance people's self-serving political solutions. A closer equivalent in the tech community would be more like "this guy has spent decades running shady adtech and addictive gaming companies, and continues to traffick personal information and addict kids to pay-to-play games, but is now also running an organization dedicated to digital privacy and is building a reputation as an expert in parenting in the digital age and voluntary gaming regulation".
- debatem1 7y agoIf someone spent decades exploiting vulnerabilities to the point where they made a billion dollars shuttering hundreds of healthy companies and costing thousands of people their jobs, that person would either be very quiet about it or in jail, most likely the latter. And as a security person, I don't think that's a bad thing. We have laws around these kinds of issues specifically because having the raw technical capability to ruin lives should not be viewed as tantamount to permission to do so. So should it be in the financial realm.
- _bxg1 7y agoCapitalism is a system that sounds great on paper, but doesn't work in practice.
- dang 7y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to HN. Especially not generic ideological comments, which tend to lead to generic ideological flamewars, which we want to avoid because they're so predictable. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- _bxg1 7y agoI felt it was substantive; lots of people worship the market blindly and this article is an excellent deep-dive into exactly what's wrong with that mentality. I was also drawing an analogy to the common refrain about communism, which is true in that case as well. The world's most prosperous societies know how to strike a balance.
- Animats 7y agoHe's missing a big change since 1949 or 1974 - the demise of communism. It's not that communism was all that successful, but it was competition for capitalism. Capitalism had to do better for the voters than communism. From about 1920 to 1980, American business was scared of communism as an alternative system. In the 1950s and 1960s, when the USSR looked to be surging ahead, there was heavy PR about how capitalism delivered a better life for workers. (Some period cheerleading from when the USA really was #1: [1][2]) Businesses were in fear of being broken up, having executives arrested for price-fixing, or even being taken over by the government. The British government took over and ran big parts of the steel and railroad industries. British telecom was government-owned already. US businesses feared that might come to the US. This fear, and fear of unions, kept wages going up, and prices stable. It wasn't perfect, but there was a major force pushing back against corporate greed. With that threat removed, capitalism has a monopoly, and now acts like one. [1] https://archive.org/details/4050_Meet_King_Joe_01_19_26_08 https://archive.org/details/4050_Meet_King_Joe_01_19_26_08 [2] https://archive.org/details/Productivity-KeyToPlenty https://archive.org/details/Productivity-KeyToPlenty
- rjsw 7y agoBritish Telecom was spun out of the Post Office, it wasn't a formerly private business that had been taken over by the Government.
- walshemj 7y agoActually not the UK government nationalised most of the Uk's private telecom businesses before WW1
- Gibbon1 7y agoI think the telegraph system in the UK was a state owned or controlled monopoly. Lol, I tried searching to back this up and this popped up! https://www.jstor.org/stable/25101819?seq=1#metadata_info_tab_contents https://www.jstor.org/stable/25101819?seq=1#metadata_info_ta... I read stuff like this is it feels like the West has utterly forgotten things that were well and clearly understood 100 years ago.
- tony_cannistra 7y agoI have to say, these three particular sections are able to finely articulate what I've been thinking as I watch rich people try to run the United States. > "At bottom, when many of our country’s wealthy citizens say “democracy,” what they really mean is “our class’s way of life.” If they respected democracy as fervently as they worship the “invisible hand,” they would see that the popular discontent simmering across the world today is the direct result of decades of elite hypocrisy and greed, hidden behind a façade of neoliberal economics. > "The “center” is not where the best policy is made, or where public opinion converges; it is a place where political activity is fully dominated by financial elites and thoroughly subordinated to the market." > "These are the same people who have left us with an upside-down economy and a weakened social fabric. Income inequality, financialization, and a socially inefficient distribution of both capital and talent are the legacies of shareholder capitalism. Although these elites now mourn the erosion of the political “center,” they actively participated in the erosion of the American middle class. To add insult to injury, they insist on telling us elaborate stories about their entrepreneurial spirit and good intentions, and invite us to celebrate their virtue when they give back a tiny share of their captured wealth."
- golemiprague 7y agoAnd then this guy Klarman moved his support from Trump to Clinton which exactly represent this centre, or basically, when a guy came and deviated from the centre Klarman was running away to the safety of what he always supported. He is not different to the rest of them.
- bob457 7y agoI thought this was going to be an interesting article. Then I read >At first glance, this is sound—even admirable—advice for aspiring business leaders. But a closer look at Klarman’s remarks, as well as the origins and trajectory of his career, suggests a deeply flawed messenger. And I realized this was just another article which refuses to engage ideas and falls back to ad hominem. I don’t care if the messenger is flawed, or what somebody thinks his or her motivation is for delivering a particular message. I want to hear a critique of the message itself.
- akiselev 7y agoThe majority of the article is about shareholder primacy and the disingenuousness of the messenger and his message, as demonstrated by his actions.
- seem_2211 7y agoA considerable amount has been written about the financialization of the American economy. Less understood is the financialization of America’s business talent. Klarman, his alma mater, and its peer institutions are all part of this story. What we confront today—a business elite dominated by financiers and their squires, presiding over a disordered economy gutted of both its productive energy and the ability to generate mass prosperity—is a direct result of this economic and cultural evolution. To some degree I think we see this in the startup world where a lot of the aspiration seems to be: Operator -> Angel Investor (on the side) -> VC.
- Qasaur 7y agoVery interesting article. I think what a lot of these articles lack is a discussion of the role that monetary policy plays in the financialization of the American (and, indeed, global) economy. While I agree that there are other factors that lead to the rise of shareholder primacy, I think the most important one is the distortion of relative capital proportions in the economy largely caused through the mechanism of monetary inflation. I find it odd how there is so little literature on this apart from books and papers from the relatively fringe (but no less accurate) Austrian school of economics. Inflation is not something that happens everywhere in the economy at the same time (the Cantillon effect). Inflationary central banking policies benefit those who are closest (relatively) to the money printer, and in modern Western economies this is almost always financial firms and those who marshal capital. Large inflows of money (inflows that have vastly increaed sinced 2008 after the advent of extensive quantitative easing) allow those close to the central bank to have a larger purchasing power than the rest of the economy as inflation has not "trickled down" yet. This allows said financial firms to purchase assets, invest in companies, and capture value in ways they would otherwise not be able to do and in scales that are completely unnatural. And yes, this includes venture capital firms (for many of us who work in startups, we are among those who are relatively closer to central banks, hence the ridiculous salaries). As there is much more money flowing in the system but less "real" wealth, much of this money heads to equity markets to chase returns, and the result is what is described in the article. This distortion of the capital base allows financial firms to hold and direct more capital than they otherwise would, so it is no wonder that the financialisation of the American economy and increases in general economic inequality globally largely began after the gold standard was abolished in 1971 and central bank printing presses were set free. Indeed, I would go so far to say that the real fix to this problem is to abolish inflation targeting (and by consequence the central planning of the money supply through central banks).
- solotronics 7y agoI think the firehose we have now of unconstrined fiat currency will go down in the history books as an aberration in the history of money. Money and the economy are part of the bedrock of modern society and the human interactions that happen on a macro and micro level. When you get down to it fiat currencies like the USD became uncoupled from reality when it went off being pegged to a physical amount of gold/silver. I always see a lot of hand waving when I bring this up. I am betting that our current system of fiat is smoke and mirrors and we will return to money based on something concrete.
- caycep 7y agocontextual background on the publication itself? https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/a-new-trumpist-magazine-debuts-at-the-harvard-club https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/a-new-trumpist-maga...
- JetSpiegel 7y agoA Trumpist magazine extolling the virtues of Elizabeth Warren's platform? This seems to be the classical criticism of analysts that look at Trump's policies instead of painting anything he does as anathema. Being BFF with Peter Thiel is a black mark, I'll give you that.
- darawk 7y agoHmm...this article, along with Elizabeth Warren's recent proposals make me think that maybe the answer we ought to be looking at is something quite simple: Provide significant tax advantages to compensating employees with equity. If the problem is that employees are losing at the expense of shareholders...well, let's make them shareholders.
- solveit 7y agoIt's a bad idea to put both your money and your career into the same basket. Either the employees will immediately sell the equity, which will essentially make this just a tax cut, or (if they can't) they'll be in a dangerous position and the next recession will be devastating.
- ryandrake 7y agoYou can't really make people into shareholders--at least not into successful investors. The reason many (most?) people aren't shareholders is because they simply can't afford to save. You can't eat AAPL. You can't clothe your baby in JNJ. People should "pay themselves first" as savings but the reality for the normal person working 3 jobs in order to hold their household together is there's no room to pay yourself first--you barely make enough to survive. Even if you have $100 in your pocket at the end of the month, if you use it to buy a stock you're -10% right off the bat due to brokerage fees. What are some ways a company can try to "make" their employee into one of the shareholder class? Well, they can just give their employees company stock in lieu of some other compensation, but then the employee is stuck with this risky single-equity portfolio which they either need to sell (minus transaction fees and taxes) then use to buy some other diversified investment (minus transaction fees), or hold on to and risk being the next Enron casualty. They can offer a 401K and even match contributions, but this requires the employee to deliberately elect to participate, which only makes sense if your basic needs are already met. 401Ks seem to mostly benefit middle class and affluent people who already budget for saving. Plus most 401K plans I've seen are loaded with expenses that eat a significant percentage of participants' savings. Maybe the government can step in. People talk about Basic Income... Maybe instead of cash basic income offer basic equity: every American could be issued N shares of SPY every month or something. Let everyone have some basic baseline skin in the financial system game. This helps everyone benefit, not just employees. Maybe instead of tax refunds being a big lump of cash, they can default to being issued as treasury bonds. I don't know. "Tax breaks to corporation, hoping they in turn act nice" hasn't worked out very well for us.