7 ms·
If you come at it from the perspective that Google is your friend, as in not like a real friend (who I wouldn't let change my passwords), but a friend that's ev
by whatshisface 7y ago
If you come at it from the perspective that Google is your friend, as in not like a real friend (who I wouldn't let change my passwords), but a friend that's even better than a real friend, then sure, these points are paranoid. The GNU perspective is very distrustful of the idea that anyone else should be administrating their devices, and refuses to trust any corporation more than they would a friend.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoGoogle is not your friend. Google is a multi-billion dollar international corporation which sells advertising. It does have a good marketing team that makes cutesy artwork for it's PR campaigns though.
- skybrian 7y agoYour "friend" analogy is basically the perspective of someone who wouldn't put their money in a bank. If you wouldn't trust a friend to hold thousands of dollars for you, why would you trust a bank? It's questionable whether Google deserves similar trust as a bank since they aren't regulated in a similar way. But it isn't unusual for people to trust companies over friends for some things, such as their life savings. The other thing to remember is that trust can be partial. For example, I wouldn't trust a bank not to be looking for legal ways to charge me fees and I wouldn't trust their investment advice, but I'd trust them to keep their ATM's working and not to lose my money.
- badrequest 7y agoYou bring up regulatory controls on banks, but then dismiss them as if most folks would willingly put their money into them if the regulations weren't there. If you'd trust the bank with your money without the regulations, I'd love to send you details about the bank I'm forming.
- lazyasciiart 7y agoMost folks, maybe not. Everyone who's ever used bitcoin though....
- jcranberry 7y agoI don't see where he made any such dismissal.
- joshuamorton 7y agoYou've managed to acknowledge and then ignore the point. You aren't trustworthy. Or maybe you are, but I don't know that. A bank is. There's history of acting, if not ethically, at least not totally unethically, even without government regulations. Wells Fargo, Visa, and Coinbase all have decreasing sets of regulations, but all have more consumer trust than "badrequest".
- AndunD 7y agoRight... consumers trust bankers now?
- pessimizer 7y ago> There's history of acting, if not ethically, at least not totally unethically, even without government regulations. I do not believe that this is a thing that is true. There is no well-known history of ethical unregulated banks.
- joshuamorton 7y agoLike I said, not ethically, but not totally unethically: they'll absolutely try to rip you off, but they won't just steal your money.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIn the world of cryptocurrencies, everything to the "less regulation" side of Coinbase actually did steal your money.
- skybrian 7y agoI certainly don't mean to dismiss financial regulation. It's an important reason why today's banks are lower risk than in previous times - at least, for depositors. But people used and trusted banks long before FDIC insurance. (And often, that trust was broken.) I expect we will see more regulation of the companies storing personal data, along the lines of the GDPR. I don't expect people will stop using the big tech companies to store personal data.
- henryfjordan 7y agoThe GNU completely ignores the value that you get from Google. For instance this point: > Google Chrome contains a key logger that sends Google every URL typed in, one key at a time They are describing the auto complete feature... I get that people should be making informed choices about what data they share, but for the FSF to so intentionally mis-describe what is going on does not help inform anyone.
- BryantD 7y agoI think it's useful to describe the features in terms that make it very clear what's going on. On the other hand, I disagree with the assumption that users should not be willing to make the tradeoff of using the software anyway.
- ChrisSD 7y agoWait but that's literally what the auto complete feature does. Most users understand the value of the feature (they use it!) but there's a good reason to spell out the cost too. I agree with the criticism that they should draw a clearer line between the cost and the benefit but there's nothing to be gained by softening the language used to describe the cost.
- jammygit 7y agoYears ago I used to assume autocompletions were performed on device, not sent to a server
- chucksmash 7y agoI'd naively consider a keylogger to be software that captures your keypresses universally. I use Firefox and have search suggestions disabled there so I am somewhat sympathetic to their point. That said, calling server-side autocomplete on a field you explicitly are typing in strikes me as about as sensible and forthright as calling an Amazon text field that takes my credit card number a card skimmer.
- aflag 7y ago
- tropicalia 7y agoIf you come at it from the perspective that Google is your friend, as in not like a real friend (who I wouldn't let change my passwords), but a friend that's even better than a real friend, then sure, these points are paranoid. If you start an argument with a false premise (like the above), then sure, you can come to just about any kind of conclusion you want. The GNU perspective is very distrustful of the idea that anyone else should be administrating their devices [etc etc] Which is a perfectly reasonable position to have, and no one takes issue with GNU for having it. What one takes issue with is the consistent use of manipulative language, egregious omission of context (e.g. like what was just said about Google in the post above) and other generalized mindfuckery that GNU folks seem to routinely resort to in order to get you to buy into their shtick. As exemplified in the article referred to in the original post for this thread. And which has gotten to be way beyond old. For like, multiple decades now.
- yongjik 7y agoGP's points still stand, if coming from the perspective that Google is a successful, multinational corporation, with a reputation to protect, and staffed with thousands of engineers who also have their own job standards and individual reputation to protect.
- whatshisface 7y agoYour friends have your friendship to protect, right? If multinational corporations have your interests at heart more reliably than your friends then maybe it's time to meet new people!
- yongjik 7y agoDifferent entities can be entrusted with different responsibilities, not because I trust one more but simply because they're different. I'll never ask my friends to memorize my schedule and remind me on time. I'll also never ask Google to take care of my cat. Sounds pretty straightforward to me.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoAnd again they don't stand if your perspective accounts for the following observable facts: - Multinational corporations care little about their reputation - the public has very short memory, and it's rare that a reputational issue outweighs considerations like sunk costs, network effect, or lack of better alternative on the market. See literally almost every scandal involving a corporation ever. - The larger the organization, the less individual ethical and reputational concerns of bottom-line workers matter. See literally every corporation. For particular recent examples, see e.g. Volkswagen emissions scandal or Boeing 737 Max fiasco, both cases involving actual engineers with actual careers on the line, and not just software devs risking unemployment for 10 minutes. Note that both statements are explainable even without attributing malice to any corporation. They're side effect of scale and market power.
- greyhair 7y agoI'm your only friend I'm not your only friend But I'm a little glowing friend But really I'm not actually your friend But I am (Blue Canary, TMBT)